Caglar Koksal

Dr. Caglar Koksal

orcid

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

8Years (2019-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
5 January 2023 in International Journal of Qualitative Methods
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
GBGeoff Bates
Geoff Bates
AGAnna R Le Gouais
Anna R Le Gouais
Andrew BarnfieldAndrew Barnfield
Andrew Barnfield
Rosalie CallwayRosalie Callway
Rosalie Callway
NHNazmul Hasan
Nazmul Hasan
SASarah Ayres
Sarah Ayres
Large scale, multi-organisational collaborations between researchers from diverse disciplinary backgrounds are increasingly recognised as important to investigate and tackle complex real-world problems. However differing expectations, epistemologies, and preferences across these teams pose challenges to following best practice for ensuring high-quality and rigorous qualitative research, while maintaining goodwill and team cohesion across team members. This article presents critical reflections from the real-world experiences of a team navigating the challenges of collaborating on a large-scale, cross-disciplinary interview study. Based on these experiences, we extend the literature on large team qualitative collaboration by highlighting the importance of balancing autonomy and collaboration, and propose eight recommendations to support high quality research and team cohesion. We identify how this balance can be achieved at different times: when centralised decision-making should be prioritised, and autonomy can be allowed. We argue that prioritising time to develop shared understandings, build trust, and creating positive environments that accept and support differing researcher perspectives on qualitative methods is paramount. By exploring and reflecting on these differences, teams can identify how and when to support autonomy in decision-making, when to move forward collaboratively, and how to ensure that shared processes reflect the needs of the whole team. The reflexive findings, emanating from practical experience, can inform large research teams undertaking qualitative studies to explore complex issues. We make an original contribution to qualitative methods research by arguing that balancing autonomy and collaboration is the key to promoting high quality research and cohesion in large teams.


16 March 2022 in Sustainability
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
MNMee Kam Ng
Mee Kam Ng
CKCaglar Koksal
Caglar Koksal
CWCecilia Wong
Cecilia Wong
YTYuanzhou Tang
Yuanzhou Tang
This paper proposes an integrative analytical framework to critically review the genesis of smart city development and evaluate its sustainability outcomes from a spatial planning perspective. It argues that historical contexts and modes of governance, together with holistic place-based knowledge, provide important clues to understand the ensuing visions, goals, and objectives, as well as processes and contents of smart city initiatives. Shenzhen (SZ), China’s first special economic zone, and Greater Manchester (GM), the birthplace of the industrial revolution in the United Kingdom, are used to illustrate how the conceptual framework helps reveal two very different pathways towards smart sustainability. SZ, as a pioneering testbed of China’s reforms, is closely directed by top-down initiatives in its smart and sustainable development efforts. GM, given its rich history of local collaboration between the public, private and third sectors, adopts a bottom-up approach to achieve smart sustainability. The case studies prove the robustness of the framework in narrating smart sustainable development in a city-region, highlighting different trajectories and necessary areas for improvement.

1 January 2025 in Ecological Solutions and Evidence
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
ITIan Thornhill
Ian Thornhill
AGAnna Gilchrist
Anna Gilchrist
BSBethany Searle
Bethany Searle
CKCaglar Koksal
Caglar Koksal
DSDavid Sampson
David Sampson
Urban growth is a major driver of biodiversity loss, as natural habitats are destroyed or fragmented. To address this, nature‐positive initiatives aim to balance development with nature conservation. In the UK, Biodiversity Net Gain (BNG) was introduced through the 2021 Environment Act, requiring developers to deliver a minimum 10% biodiversity increase for new developments. Despite BNG's potential, doubts exist about local planning authorities' (LPAs) abilities to implement and enforce BNG effectively, due to resource limitations, inconsistent ecological expertise, and ineffective monitoring. This study examined 44 residential developments across two case studies where biodiversity measures were mandated through prior planning policy and assessed (i) how well ecological advice was integrated into planning decisions, and (ii) whether biodiversity measures were effectively implemented. The study revealed significant gaps between approved plans and actual implementation. The ecological advice transposed into planning decisions and approved documentation was biased towards European protected species (EPS) or more charismatic fauna. Additionally, many developments failed to properly implement biodiversity measures, with frequent deviations from approved plans for artificial and semi‐natural habitats. Solution. Improved awareness and knowledge of biodiversity, increased LPA resources, better communication between planners, ecologists and developers, stronger enforcement and improved monitoring are essential for BNG's success. Without these actions, BNG may fail to leave the natural environment in a measurably better state.

20 April 2023 in Cities & Health
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
CKCaglar Koksal
Caglar Koksal
With growing evidence of the links between the built environment and population health, there is an increasing demand for practical guides and toolkits to help decision-makers improve public health...

1 May 2019 in Town Planning Review
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
BDBertie Dockerill
Bertie Dockerill
CKCaglar Koksal
Caglar Koksal
Helen ZhengHelen Zheng
Helen Zheng