In nonlinear dynamics, there are three classic routes to chaos, namely the period-doubling route, the Ruelle–Takens–Newhouse route and the intermittency route. The first two routes have previously been observed in self-excited thermoacoustic systems, but the third has not. In this experimental study, we present evidence of the intermittency route to chaos in the self-excited regime of a prototypical thermoacoustic system – a laminar flame-driven Rijke tube. We identify the intermittency to be of type II from the Pomeau–Manneville scenario through an analysis of (i) the probability distribution of the quiescent epochs between successive bursts of chaos, (ii) the first return map, and (iii) the recurrence plot. By establishing the last of the three classic routes to chaos, this study strengthens the universality of how strange attractors arise in self-excited thermoacoustic systems, paving the way for the application of generic suppression strategies based on chaos control.

We experimentally investigate the synchronization dynamics of a self-excited thermoacoustic system forced beyond its phase-locked state. The system consists of a laminar premixed flame in a tube combustor subjected to periodic acoustic forcing. On increasing the forcing amplitude above that required for phase locking, we find that the system can transition out of phase locking and into chaos, which is consistent with the Afraimovich–Shilnikov theorem for the breakdown of a phase-locked torus. However, we also find some unexpected behavior, most notably the emergence of a strange nonchaotic attractor (SNA) before the onset of chaos. We verify the existence of the SNA and chaotic attractor by examining the correlation dimension, the autocorrelation function, the power-law scaling in the Fourier amplitude spectrum, the permutation entropy in a pseudoperiodic surrogate test, and the permutation spectrum. In summary, this study explores the SNA and chaotic dynamics of a thermoacoustic system forced beyond its phase-locked state, opening up new pathways for the development of alternative strategies to control self-excited thermoacoustic oscillations in combustion devices such as gas turbines and rocket engines.

In self-excited combustion systems, the application of open-loop forcing is known to be an effective strategy for controlling periodic thermoacoustic oscillations, but it is not known whether and under what conditions such a strategy would work on thermoacoustic oscillations that are not simply periodic. In this study, we experimentally examine the effect of periodic acoustic forcing on a prototypical thermoacoustic system consisting of a ducted laminar premixed flame oscillating quasiperiodically on an ergodic $\mathbb{T}^{2}$ torus at two incommensurate natural frequencies, $f_{1}$ and $f_{2}$ . Compared with that of a classical period-1 system, complete synchronization of this $\mathbb{T}_{1,2}^{2}$ system is found to occur via a more intricate route involving three sequential steps: as the forcing amplitude, $\unicode[STIX]{x1D716}_{f}$ , increases at a fixed forcing frequency, $f_{f}$ , the system transitions first (i) to ergodic $\mathbb{T}_{1,2,f}^{3}$ quasiperiodicity; then (ii) to resonant $\mathbb{T}_{1,f}^{2}$ quasiperiodicity as the weaker of the two natural modes, $f_{2}$ , synchronizes first, leading to partial synchronization; and finally (iii) to a $P1_{f}$ limit cycle as the remaining natural mode, $f_{1}$ , also synchronizes, leading to complete synchronization. The minimum $\unicode[STIX]{x1D716}_{f}$ required for partial and complete synchronization decreases as $f_{f}$ approaches either $f_{1}$ or $f_{2}$ , resulting in two primary Arnold tongues. However, when forced at an amplitude above that required for complete synchronization, the system can transition out of $P1_{f}$ and into $\mathbb{T}_{1,2,f}^{3}$ or $\mathbb{T}_{2,f}^{2}$ . The optimal control strategy is to apply off-resonance forcing at a frequency around the weaker natural mode ( $f_{2}$ ) and at an amplitude just sufficient to cause $P1_{f}$ , because this produces the largest reduction in thermoacoustic amplitude via asynchronous quenching. Analysis of the Rayleigh index shows that this reduction is physically caused by a disruption of the positive coupling between the unsteady heat release rate of the flame and the $f_{1}$ and $f_{2}$ acoustic modes. If the forcing is applied near the stronger natural mode ( $f_{1}$ ), however, resonant amplification can occur. We then phenomenologically model this $\mathbb{T}_{1,2}^{2}$ thermoacoustic system as two reactively coupled van der Pol oscillators subjected to external sinusoidal forcing, and find that many of its synchronization features – such as the three-step route to $P1_{f}$ , the double Arnold tongues, asynchronous quenching and resonant amplification – can be qualitatively reproduced. This shows that these features are not limited to our particular system, but are universal features of forced self-excited oscillators. This study extends the applicability of open-loop control from classical period-1 systems with just a single time scale to ergodic $\mathbb{T}^{2}$ quasiperiodic systems with two incommensurate time scales.