In the last decade, parameter-free approaches to shape optimization problems have matured to a state where they provide a versatile tool for complex engineering applications. However, sensitivity distributions obtained from shape derivatives in this context cannot be directly used as a shape update in gradient-based optimization strategies. Instead, an auxiliary problem has to be solved to obtain a gradient from the sensitivity. While several choices for these auxiliary problems were investigated mathematically, the complexity of the concepts behind their derivation has often prevented their application in engineering. This work aims to explain several approaches to compute shape updates from an engineering perspective. We introduce the corresponding auxiliary problems in a formal way and compare the choices by means of numerical examples. To this end, a test case and exemplary applications from computational fluid dynamics are considered.
1 January 2021 in Engineering Applications of Computational Fluid Mechanics
This paper reports on the derivation and implementation of a shape optimization procedure for the minimization of hemolysis induction in blood flows through biomedical devices.Despite the significant progress in relevant experimental studies, the ever-growing advances in computational science have made computational fluid dynamics an indispensable tool for the design of biomedical devices. However, even the latter can lead to a restrictive cost when the model requires an extensive number of computational elements or when the simulation needs to be overly repeated. This work aims at the formulation of a continuous adjoint complement to a power-law hemolysis prediction model dedicated to efficiently identifying the shape sensitivity to hemolysis. The proposed approach can accompany any gradient-based optimization method at the cost of approximately one additional flow solution per shape update. The approach is verified against analytical solutions of a benchmark problem and computed sensitivity derivatives are validated by a finite differences study on a generic 2D stenosed geometry. The included application addresses a 3D ducted geometry which features typical characteristics of blood-carrying devices. An optimized shape, leading to a potential improvement up to 22%, is identified. It is shown that the improvement persists for different hemolysis-evaluation parameters.
14 July 2023 in International Journal for Numerical Methods in Fluids
This article discusses the derivation and numerical implementation of an adjoint system, to the primal Navier–Stokes equations, for the computation of shape sensitivities of ducted blood flows considering non‐Newtonian fluid properties. The ever‐growing advancements in blood flow simulations are, naturally, accompanied by an increased interest in the optimization of related medical devices. In the majority of the computational studies, the Newtonian assumption is used to describe the rheology of blood. While this assumption has been shown to satisfactorily capture the flow when it is governed by high shear rates, it falls short at low shear rates. A rich variety of viscosity models has been proposed to tackle this shortcoming. In this article we show how such models can be incorporated into an adjoint system targeting to produce the shape sensitivity which can be used by a gradient‐based optimization method for the minimization of an objective functional. A general formulation of the adjoint equations is proposed, in which contributions of the non‐Newtonian properties explicitly occur. The numerical implementation is discussed and the validity of the method is assessed by means of numerical experiments of steady blood flows in a 2D stenosed duct, where results are compared against second‐order finite‐difference (FD) studies. The proposed methodology is then applied to CAD‐free, gradient‐based shape optimizations of an idealized 3D arterial bypass‐graft operating at three relevant Reynolds numbers. It is observed that the impact of the adjoint viscosity treatment is amplified in low shear‐rate flow regimes while fades for higher shear‐rates, analogous to its primal counterpart.
The contribution is devoted to combined shape- and mesh-update strategies for parameter-free (CAD-free) shape optimization methods. Three different strategies to translate the shape sensitivities computed by adjoint shape optimization procedures into simultaneous updates of both the shape and the discretized domain are employed in combination with a mesh-morphing strategy. Considered methods involve a linear Steklov–Poincaré (Hilbert space) approach, a recently suggested highly non-linear p-Laplace (Banach space) method, and a hybrid variant which updates the shape in Hilbert space. The methods are scrutinized for optimizing the power loss of a two-dimensional bent duct flow using an unstructured, locally refined grid that initially displays favorable grid properties. Optimization results are compared with respect to the optimization convergence, the computational effort, and the preservation of the mesh quality during the optimization sequence. Results indicate that all methods reach, approximately, the same converged optimal solution, which reduces the objective function by about 18% for this classical benchmark example. However, as regards the preservation of the mesh quality, more advanced Banach space methods are advantageous in comparison to Hilbert space methods even when the shape update is performed in Hilbert space to save costs. In specific, while the computational cost of the Banach space method and the hybrid method is about 3.5 and 2.5 times the cost of the pure Hilbert space method, respectively, the grid quality metrics are 2 times and 1.7 times improved for the Banach space and hybrid method, respectively.
21 June 2025 in Structural and Multidisciplinary Optimization
This paper presents the shape optimization of an idealized arterial bypass graft under uncertainties. The underlying blood flow problem is numerically solved using computational fluid dynamics (CFD) simulations, able to account for mechanical hemolysis and non-Newtonian viscosity properties of blood. The employed hemolysis and non-Newtonian models utilize a set of parameters that are considered uncertain in this work. To this end, the optimization problem is rendered robust and targets the minimization of the first two statistical moments of a hemolysis index. The propagation of the uncertainties to the hemolysis index is done through the first-order second-moment method (FOSM). The necessary derivatives are computed by the adjoint method and finite differences. Several steady-state robust shape optimization simulations of the idealized bypass graft are presented. Selected optimized shapes are further assessed by means of additional fluid–structure interaction (FSI) simulations under unsteady conditions.
Accurate resolution of propeller-hull interaction is essential for predicting the self-propulsion point in ship CFD, yet motion-resolving methods such as sliding interfaces (SI) are computationally expensive, while the classical Moving Reference Frame (MRF) approach cannot capture unsteady interaction effects. Partially rotating grid methods bridge this gap by splitting the propeller rotation into a grid-resolved and an MRF component, but the abrupt transition between the rotating and stationary domains introduces discontinuities in the velocity field. This work presents a modified MRF (mMRF) formulation in which the reference-frame rotation rate is scaled by a spatially varying function that decays smoothly from unity near the propeller to zero at the domain interface, restoring velocity and pressure continuity across the boundary. The governing equations are derived and implemented in the RANS solver FreSCo+, verified against the analytical Taylor–Couette solution, and applied to open-water propeller and Japan Bulk Carrier self-propulsion simulations at model scale. Both MRF and mMRF reproduce the principal integral propulsion quantities (n, KT, KQ, 1-t, 1-wT, ηR) accurately, but the mMRF markedly reduces interface discontinuities and non-physical artifacts in the local flow field, particularly at large MRF fractions, at essentially the same computational cost.