Galaxy clusters as gravitational lenses play a unique role in astrophysics and cosmology: they permit mapping the dark matter distribution on a range of scales; they reveal the properties of high and intermediate redshift background galaxies that would otherwise be unreachable with telescopes; they constrain the particle nature of dark matter and are a powerful probe of global cosmological parameters, like the Hubble constant. In this review we summarize the current status of cluster lensing observations and the insights they provide, and offer a glimpse into the capabilities that ongoing, and the upcoming next generation of telescopes and surveys will deliver. While many open questions remain, cluster lensing promises to remain at the forefront of discoveries in astrophysics and cosmology.
9 April 2020 in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
In the near future, ultra deep observations of galaxy clusters with Hubble Space Telescope or James Webb Space Telescope will uncover 300–1000 lensed multiple images, increasing the current count per cluster by up to an order of magnitude. This will further refine our view of clusters, leading to a more accurate and precise mapping of the total and dark matter distribution in clusters, and enabling a better understanding of background galaxy population and their luminosity functions. However, to effectively use that many images as input to lens inversion will require a re-evaluation of, and possibly upgrades to the existing methods. In this paper, we scrutinize the performance of the free-form lens inversion method grale in the regime of 150–1000 input images, using synthetic massive galaxy clusters. Our results show that with an increasing number of input images, grale produces improved reconstructed mass distributions, with the fraction of the lens plane recovered at better than $10{{\ \rm per\ cent}}$ accuracy increasing from $40\!-\!50{{\ \rm per\ cent}}$ for ∼150 images to $65{{\ \rm per\ cent}}$ for ∼1000 images. The reconstructed time delays imply a more precise measurement of H0, with $\lesssim 1{{\ \rm per\ cent}}$ bias. While the fidelity of the reconstruction improves with the increasing number of multiple images used as model constraints, ∼150 to ∼1000, the lens plane rms deteriorates from ∼0.11 to ∼0.28 arcsec. Since lens plane rms is not necessarily the best indicator of the quality of the mass reconstructions, looking for an alternative indicator is warranted.
28 April 2021 in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
We use the Beyond Ultra-deep Frontier Fields and Legacy Observations (BUFFALO) strong lensing image catalog of the merging galaxy cluster Abell 370 to obtain a mass model using free-form lens inversion algorithm grale. The improvement of the strong lensing data quality results in a lens plane rms of only 0.45 arcsec, about a factor of two lower than that of our existing HFF v4 reconstruction. Since the number of images is nearly the same in both, we attribute the improvement to the improvement in the data quality. In our reconstructed mass model, we found indications of three distinct mass features in Abell 370: (i) a ∼35 kpc offset between the northern BCG and the nearest mass peak, (ii) a ∼100 kpc mass concentration of roughly critical density ∼250 kpc east of the main cluster, and (iii) a probable filament-like structure passing N-S through the cluster. While (i) is present in some form in most publicly available reconstructions spanning the range of modeling techniques: parametric, hybrid, and free-form, (ii) and (iii) are recovered by only about half of the reconstructions. We tested our hypothesis on the presence of the filament-like structure by creating a synthetic cluster - Irtysh IIIc - mocking the situation of a cluster with external mass. We also computed the source plane magnification distributions. Using them we estimated the probabilities of magnifications in the source plane, and scrutinized their redshift dependence. Finally, we explored the lensing effects of Abell 370 on the luminosity functions of sources at zs = 9.0, finding it consistent with published results.
21 August 2023 in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
Abell 1689 is a well-studied cluster of galaxies and one of the largest gravitational lens systems ever observed. We have obtained a reconstruction of the cluster Abell 1689 using grale, a free-form lens inversion method that relies exclusively on the multiple image data. Non-inclusion of any data related to cluster member galaxies ensures an unbiased measure of the mass distribution, which is the most notable feature of free-form methods like grale. We used two different sets of multiple image systems from the available strong lensing data – one containing only the secure systems (107 images) and the other containing all available systems, only excluding some very non-secure systems (151 images). For the very well-constrained central ∼100 kpc region of the cluster, we made a detailed comparison of the grale reconstructed lensing mass and stellar mass retrieved by the Spectral Energy Distribution (SED) fitting software fast++. We found a light-unaccompanied mass peak in this region, whose existence, while tentative, is favoured by the distribution of nearby images that are local maxima in the Fermat potential. However, further tests, using different methodologies are needed to confirm the reality of this feature. If it is shown to be real, this light-unaccompanied mass peak is consistent with dark matter self-interaction cross-section σ ≲ 1 cm2 g−1, while being in tension with larger cross-sections.
3 November 2023 in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
SDSS J1004+4112 is a well studied gravitational lens with a recently measured time delay between its first and fourth arriving quasar images. Using this new constraint, we present updated free-form lens reconstructions using the lens inversion method GRALE, which only uses multiple image and time delay data as inputs. In addition, we obtain hybrid lens reconstructions by including a model of the brightest cluster galaxy (BCG) as a Sersic lens. For both reconstructions, we use two sets of images as input: one with all identified images, and the other a revised set leaving out images that have been potentially misidentified. We also develop a source position optimization MCMC routine, performed on completed GRALE runs, that allows each model to better match observed image positions and time delays. All the reconstructions produce similar mass distributions, with the hybrid models finding a steeper profile in the center. Similarly, all the mass distributions are fit by the Navarro-Frenk-White (NFW) profile, finding results consistent with previous parametric reconstructions and those derived from Chandra X-ray observations. We identify a ∼5 × 1011M⊙ substructure apparently unaffiliated with any cluster member galaxy and present in all our models, and study its reality. Using our free-form and hybrid models we predict a central quasar image time delay of ∼2980 ± 270 and ∼3280 ± 215 days, respectively. A potential future measurement of this time delay will, while being an observational challenge, further constrain the steepness of the central density profile.
1 September 2023 in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
All lens modelling methods, simply parametrized, hybrid, and free-form, use assumptions to reconstruct galaxy clusters with multiply imaged sources, though the nature of these assumptions (priors) can differ considerably between methods. This raises an important question in strong lens modelling: how much information about the mass model comes from the lensed images themselves, and how much is a consequence of model priors. One way to assess the relative contributions of the lensing data versus model priors is to estimate global lens properties through images alone, without any prior assumptions about the mass distribution. This is our approach. We use 200 mock cluster lenses, half of which have substructures, which vary from clumpy and compact to smooth and extended, a simulated cluster Ares, and real clusters Abell 1689 and RX J1347.5−1145 to show that the centre, ellipticity, and position angle can be estimated quite well, and nearly perfectly for weakly substructured clusters, implying that the recovery of these properties is largely driven by the images, not priors. However, the correlation between the true and image-estimated amount of substructure has a lot of scatter, suggesting that multiple images do not uniquely constrain substructure. Therefore, in general, lens model priors have a stronger effect on smaller scales. Our analysis partly explains why reconstructions using different methodologies can produce qualitatively different mass maps on substructure scales. Our analysis is not meant to aide or replace lens inversion methods, but only to investigate what cluster properties are constrained with multiple images.