Capital project benchmarking requires an effective cost normalization process to achieve reasonable comparisons of cost-related performance for projects that are executed at different times and locations. Traditionally, cost normalization approaches were developed for ex post facto analysis of project performance and assume that all required information is fully available from a completed project. However, practitioners have expressed the need for cost normalization techniques to evaluate phase-level outcomes during ongoing projects. This paper aims to provide a cost normalization framework tailored to phase-based performance assessment. The framework involves three main steps: currency conversion, location adjustment, and time adjustment with considerations for various scenarios where the required information is not fully available. Case studies are conducted to demonstrate how the proposed cost normalization framework has been applied to phase-based performance assessment for capital projects. The proposed framework can benefit both researchers and industrial professionals interested in cost estimation, feasibility analysis, and performance assessment.
1 May 2022 in Journal of Management in Engineering
For credible project benchmarking, like-for-like project comparison is a prerequisite to set realistic targets for improvement, especially when a heterogeneous sample of healthcare projects is compared to another. However, the current method for determining the groups of similar projects relies on an ad-hoc technique that can lead to suboptimal target settings for improvement. To address this issue, this research proposes a novel approach to capture similarity for capital project benchmarking by leveraging Classification and Regression Trees (CART). This research focuses on healthcare projects. The data collected from a total of 89 healthcare projects were used to construct the trees by selecting a set of critical and flexible features that are closely associated with two metrics representing cost and schedule performance of the selected projects. The effectiveness of results derived from the proposed method was validated through statistical methods and comparative analysis. The proposed method allows for more targeted performance comparisons by capturing similarity using flexible sets of meaningful features, which reduces the search space of determining a group of similar projects. The new approach is, thus, expected to help organizations gain better insights into their relative performance position when benchmarking their capital projects.
Road sign support systems are not usually well managed because bridges and pavement have budget and maintenance priority while the sign boards and sign supports are considered as miscellaneous items. The authors of this paper developed a simple deterioration prediction model for sign support systems. Asset risk analysis was performed to develop the repair priority list. The data were collected from the Connecticut Department of Transportation (CTDOT) asset management database. There are many advanced and complicated deterioration prediction models; however, authors adopted the Weibull function for the deterioration prediction curve because it is a proven method used in reliability theory and a simple probability function that fits for simple structures like sign supports. Asset risks and repair priority lists were developed using the probability of failure and commuter impacts that are functions of ages, structure types and materials, number of traffic, population, etc. This paper shows the complete cycle of infrastructure asset management, starting from asset condition database management, deterioration prediction modeling, risk analysis, and repair priority decision-making.
1 November 2023 in Journal of Management in Engineering
Reducing the quantities of engineered materials provides a significant opportunity to mitigate the environmental impacts caused by material production and processing. Although the efficient use of materials in building construction has been emphasized, there has been little attention given to measuring the material use efficiency (MUE) of a project. This research fulfills this gap by using data envelopment analysis (DEA) as a benchmarking tool to generate an overall perspective on the MUE and to further compare its efficiency with that of peer projects, thereby promoting enhanced efficiency through target setting. In this research, MUE was measured by adopting the quantities of a variety of materials consumed during construction as input variables and the floor area of a built facility as an output variable. To generate a reliable MUE performance, a stepwise variable selection process was applied and then the performance was ranked based on evaluating cross-efficiency. In addition, clustering analysis and DEA were fused to enable a more realistic target to be set for each input, thereby determining practical targets for each underperforming project. It is anticipated that the proposed MUE benchmarking model would enable projects to recognize the gap with the best-performing projects and help them determine the targets to focus on to become efficient.