In this article, we examine the place of culture in the human sciences with specific reference to psychology and the cultural histories of India. Despite the depth of scholarly writing on the intimate and inextricable ties between culture and psychological processes, core advancements and definitive positions in psychology have remained elusive. The privileging of a single culturally specific world-view alongside the exclusion of others has seriously hindered the authentic internationalization of psychology. We propose that linkages between culture and psychology need to be visualized as a dialogue between different cultural traditions. In the dialectics between bheda–abheda (difference and non-difference), structural-developmental, dispositional-relational, and social-collective processes will be invoked to develop our arguments for a human-science approach to the study of persons in culture. We argue that it is through the inclusion, rather than suppression, of diverse ideologies that generalizability can be best achieved. This is a call for an audit and reconstruction of psychology and its practices as an international discipline with a roadmap for theory construction and research informed by a cultural psychological approach toward human phenomena.
20 April 2018 in Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology
This article presents an accurate assessment of international aid and its failure to reach declared objectives. The reason for this widespread miscarriage is attributed to the inability to understand cultural differences. People’s opposition, resistance, or apathy toward interventions are credited to social-psychological predispositions. To save the “saviors,” Brouwers suggests that welfare initiatives should collaborate with cultural sciences, more specifically cross-cultural psychology. I agree with the author about interventions being rather blind to cultural differences resulting in frequent failure to achieve ecological validity. The potential contributions of cultural and social scientists in this field are also undeniable. However, I have some reservations about the confidence placed in cross-cultural psychology for several reasons. Cross-cultural psychology works with individual-psychological and social-collective phenomena, addressing only a fragment of the story of inequality among and between the people of the world. There is little or no attention to history, geography, economics, or politics, all of which have profound impact on poverty and disadvantage. It is as if the world’s problems of poverty can be fixed by reframing how people (both agents and beneficiaries) think about “culture-behavior relationships.” This optimism appears to emerge from overconfidence or naiveté, or both.
Emerging from an invited lecture presentation at the APA conference in 2024, this article discusses how communities of the Global South can actively participate in the future of psychology theory, research, practice and publication. It is abundantly clear that psychology is a product of Euro-American academic practice, with the transportation of knowledge from this region to the rest of the world. Inevitably, there have been many concerns about this transfer of the model to regions that are vastly different in their ontological orientations. After a brief overview of the key issues in this global epistemic imbalance, we raise some critical theoretical and methodological possibilities based on scholarship from other regions to make our case for the future of psychology as a global human science.