Background: Keel flowers are bilaterally symmetrical, pentamerous flowers with three different petal types and reproductive organs enclosed by keel petals; generally there is also connation of floral parts such as stamens and keel petals. In this study, the evolution of keel flowers within the order Fabales is explored to investigate whether the establishment of this flower type within one of the species-rich families, the Fabaceae (Leguminosae), preceded and could have influenced the evolution of keel flowers in the Polygalaceae. We conducted molecular dating, and ancestral area and ancestral state analyses for a phylogeny constructed for 678 taxa using publishedmatK,rbcLandtrnLplastid gene regions.Results: We reveal the temporal and spatial origins of keel flowers and traits associated with pollinators, specifically floral symmetry, the presence or absence of a pentamerous corolla and three distinct petal types, the presence or absence of enclosed reproductive organs, androecium types, inflorescence types, inflorescence size, flower size, plant height and habit. Ancestral area reconstructions show that at the time keel flowers appeared in the Polygaleae, subfamily Papilionoideae of the Fabaceae was already distributed almost globally; at least eight clades of the Papilionoideae had keel flowers with a functional morphology broadly similar to the morphology of the first evolving Polygaleae flowers.Conclusions: The multiple origins of keel flowers within angiosperms likely represent convergence due to bee specialization, and therefore pollinator pressure. In the case of the Fabales, the first evolving keel flowers of Polygaleae have a functional morphology that corresponds with keel flowers of species of the Papilionoideae already present in the environment. These findings are consistent with the keel-flowered Polygaleae exploiting pollinators of keel-flowered Papilionoideae. The current study is the first to use ancestral reconstructions of traits associated with pollination to demonstrate that the multiple evolutionary origins of the keel flower pollinator syndrome in Fabales are consistent with, though do not prove, mimicry.
The evolution of keel flowers within Fabaceae, Polygalaceae and some other clades of angiosperms is attributed to skilled and strong bees. However, whether this is true or not, is still an open question. Therefore, the literature is surveyed for the Hymenopteran pollinators of keel flowers, for 119 sources and for 112 species, six genera and two tribes for five characters which are the size of the flowers, Hymenopteran flower visitors/pollinators, size of the Hymenopteran pollinators, pollen and nectar robbers/thieves and size of the Hymenopteran thieves/robbers. The results suggest that Fabales keel flowers are mainly pollinated by long-tongued bees, from Apidae and Megachilidae families; and the most common pollinators of the keel flowers are small Megachile and Osmia; medium-sized Apis, Anthophora and Eucera; and large Xylocopa, Bombus and Centris. While the literature suggests that keel flowers are pollinated by skilled and strong bees, the results of the current review have shown that this is not the whole case in terms of flower size and bee size. There is no difference between pollinator diversity and flower size. While floral robbers/thieves are mostly up to 2 cm, among them honey-bees (Apis mellifera) both pollinate and rob the keel flowers. Keel flowers of Polygalaceae and other angiosperm lineages are somehow similar to the keel flowers of Papilionoideae.
8 September 2025 in Anales del Jardín Botánico de Madrid
The internal transcribed spacer 2 (ITS2) of the ribosomal cistron, functioning as a mini barcode, has proven successful in numerous angiosperm DNA barcoding studies. However, its efficiency has not been thoroughly questioned in the existing literature. This review statistically evaluates 197 angiosperm DNA barcoding studies that utilized the ITS2 mini barcode. The assessment encompasses not only the ease of amplification, sequencing, and species identification success of the ITS2 region but also a comparison with ITS1, the entire ITS region, matK, and trnH-psbA. The results align with the previous conclusion that ITS2 can be effectively utilized for angiosperm identification. While the amplification, sequencing, and identification to the genus level of the ITS2 region were high, the success in species identification was not as prominent. No significant differences were observed among the types of material or the primer pairs used in terms of the success of the region. The utilization of only the ITS2 region performed well in comparison to DNA barcode combinations. However, it is noteworthy that none of the reviewed regions can be considered a universal barcode for angiosperms. The results suggest that the ITS1 and ITS2 are equally effective as mini-DNA barcodes, followed by the entire ITS region, while matK and trnH-psbA should not be the primary choices.
(1) Background: The genus Euphorbia L. in Egypt is represented by 40 species, one subspecies, and three varieties which are distributed in almost all phytogeographical regions in Egypt. The genus is well known for its medicinal importance; however, various and sometimes anomalous morphological characters make the identification of the genus a problematic case. (2) Methods: In this study, six DNA markers: matK, rbcL, ETS, trnL intron, trnL spacer, and the entire ITS region (ITS1 + 5.8S + ITS2), as well as subunits ITS1 and ITS2 were evaluated singly and in combination to investigate their usage as potential DNA barcodes. The Maximum Likelihood (ML) and BLASTn analyses were conducted for 37 individuals representing 26 species of Egyptian Euphorbia. (3) Results: The BLASTn comparison of the newly generated DNA sequences of the Egyptian Euphorbia species showed that ITS, ITS1 and ITS2 subunits displayed high levels of species discrimination. On the other hand, the ML analysis of the DNA sequences of trnL intron yielded a better resolved phylogenetic tree than the other regions. However, our phylogenetic analysis based on DNA sequences of other markers: matK, rbcL, trnL, and the entire ITS region, with additional sequences from GenBank have shown that E. dracunculoides, E. hyssopifolia, E. lasiocarpa and E. granulata are probably not monophyletic. (4) Conclusion: This study, along with the broadest taxon coverage in Egypt, emphasizes the importance of using DNA markers for precise identification and phylogenetic placement of the genus Euphorbia in Egypt within the whole genus.
31 January 2025 in Botanical Journal of the Linnean Society
Keel flowers are bilaterally symmetrical, pentamerous flowers with the reproductive organs enclosed by keel petals. Within Fabales, keel flowers are dominant in two species-rich lineages, tribe Polygaleae (Polygalaceae) and subfamily Fabaceae (Papilionoideae); however, independent events are also observed, such as in the genus Cercis. Prior to advances in phylogenetics (i.e. in contrast to more recent studies), most of the studies hypothesized a non-keeled origin for the Faboideae, although a detailed investigation has never been carried out. In this study, using the results of Aygören Uluer et al. (2020a, 2022a), the origin of some important morphological characters of the keel flower are examined, namely floral symmetry, perianth heteromorphism (i.e. three distinct petal/+sepal types), and the presence of enclosed reproductive organs. These characters are analysed within the Fabales using three different ancestral state analyses based on a phylogeny constructed for 678 taxa using published matK, rbcL, and trnL plastid gene regions. The analyses show that symmetry probably originated in the (Fabaceae + Polygalaceae) clade, while the enclosed reproductive organs and three types of petals appear to have evolved independently multiple times. Interestingly, neither enclosed reproductive organs nor petal heteromorphism evolved in the MRCA of the Faboideae, but rather in a very early stage of the evolution of the subfamily. While future homology assessments and/or evolutionary developmental genetic (evo-devo) studies will be required to more clearly elucidate the evolutionary processes, the current study is the first attempt to investigate the origin of some important characteristics of keel flowers within the order Fabales.