Personal Information Management Systems (PIMS) are acquiring a prominent role in the data economy by promoting services that help individuals to have more control over the processing of their personal data, in line with the European data protection laws. One of the highlighted solutions in this area is Solid, a new protocol that is decentralizing the storage of data, through the usage of interoperable web standards and semantic vocabularies, to empower its users to have more control over the processing of data by agents and applications. However, to fulfill this vision and gather widespread adoption, Solid needs to be aligned with the law governing the processing of personal data in Europe, the main piece of legislation being the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR). To assist with this process, we analyze the current efforts to introduce a policy layer in the Solid ecosystem, in particular, related to the challenge of obtaining consent for processing personal data, focusing on the GDPR. Furthermore, we investigate if, in the context of using personal data for biomedical research, consent can be expressed in advance, and discuss the conditions for valid consent and how it can be obtained in this decentralized setting, namely through the matching of privacy preferences, set by the user, with requests for data and whether this can signify informed consent. Finally, we discuss the technical challenges of an implementation that caters to the previously identified legal requirements.
In the context of biomedical research, consent is both a ground for the lawful processing of personal data and a bioethical requirement for participation in scientific research projects. While the conditions for obtaining valid consent are extensively discussed in legal and bioethical literature, withdrawal of consent has received considerably less attention. According to the EU General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), that data subjects have the right to withdraw their consent at any time, but the duties of the entities processing personal data are not clearly defined in the text of the Regulation. 1 Pursuant to Article 7 GDPR, withdrawal ‘shall not affect the lawfulness of processing based on consent before its withdrawal’, but there is no clear specification of the rules governing what happens after this moment.
E-Health data is sensitive and consenting to the collection, processing, and sharing involves compliance with legal requirements, ethical standards, and appropriate digital tools. We explore two legal-ethical challenges: 1) What are the scope and requirements of digital health data consent? 2) What are the legal-ethical reasons for obtaining consent beyond the GDPR’s legal basis, and how might such consent be obtained? We then propose human-centered solutions to help navigate standards of ethical and legal consent across the EU, purposefully addressing those use cases to compensate for human difficulties in managing consent without clear guidelines. These solutions – including ISO standards, ontologies, consent mechanisms, value-centered privacy assistants, and layered dynamic consent platforms – complement and aid humans to help uphold ethical and rigorous consent.
Personal Information Management Systems (PIMS) are acquiring a prominent role in the data economy by promoting services that help individuals to have more control over the processing of their personal data, in line with the European data protection law. One of the highlighted solutions in this area is Solid, a new protocol that is decentralizing the storage of data, through the usage of interoperable Web standards and semantic vocabularies, to empower its users to have more control over the processing of data by agents and applications. However, to fulfill this vision and gather widespread adoption, Solid needs to be aligned with the law governing the processing of personal data in Europe, the main piece of legislation being the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR). To assist with this process, we analyze the current efforts to introduce a policy layer in the Solid ecosystem, in particular, related to the challenge of obtaining consent for processing personal data, focusing on the GDPR. Furthermore, we investigate if, in the context of using personal data for biomedical research, consent can be expressed in advance, discuss the conditions for valid consent and how it can be obtained in this decentralized setting, namely through the matching of privacy preferences, set by the user, with requests for data and whether this can signify informed consent. Finally, we discuss the technical challenges of an implementation that caters to the previously-identified legal requirements.