The Technology Readiness Level (TRL) has been used for a few decades by NASA and the Department of Defense (DoD) to assess the maturity of a technology and evaluate the risks associated with its development. The traditional TRL measure suggests nine levels, from the conception of technology to maturation and deployment. However, the TRL measure is not designed to monitor a system as it matures, ages, and eventually becomes obsolete. There is a critical need for a new measure that captures the performance status and relevance of a system as it ages and eventually becomes a legacy system. This paper proposes a novel measure that extends the existing TRL measure, beginning where the traditional TRL stops measuring. The authors propose an extended Technology Readiness Level (eTRL) that measures the contextual relevance of a system and communicates the risks as it ages, faces various environmental, political, and economic changes, or becomes obsolete. The proposed measure takes advantage of set theory to measure the overlaps in requirements, system performance, and system environment to define the eTRL scale from the system's deployment to obsolescence. The eTRL scale will enable stakeholders and program managers to identify and monitor the aging segments within a system and act as a decision analysis tool. The application of the eTRL is demonstrated through a case study of the B52-H airplane, a successful legacy system.
The sustainable design transition has proven to be a challenging process, in part due to the diverse set of stakeholders, which includes the general public, policymakers, scientific researchers, and businesses. In prior work, the interconnected relationships among systematic drivers and barriers for sustainable design were identified and mapped using a causal loop diagram at a relatively abstract level. To further understand and characterize this complex system, this research aims to identify the relationship strength levels among the variables in the system, as indicated by previous research identified in the literature. In addition, the knowledge maturity levels of these identified relationships are specified to illustrate strengths and gaps in the literature. The findings are used to create a refined system representation that illustrates the power dynamics between systemic driving forces to sustainable design transitions. The results of this work reveal valuable insights about the linkages among the driving forces of sustainable design transitions that can be used as a foundation for further investigation, such as experiments and data analytics that can better quantify these relationships.
Sustainable product design addresses sustainability challenges through product development processes and tools. The number of sustainable design methods has been increasing rapidly in recent years. Still, their adoption is limited, and many of these methods exclusively focus on the environmental impacts of products rather than taking a holistic perspective that includes social and economic sustainability. This research provides a holistic sustainable design framework by integrating change propagation methods and sustainable design tools to enable simultaneous consideration of design parameters’ impacts on the three dimensions of sustainability. A reusable water bottle is used to demonstrate the application of the proposed holistic sustainable design (HSD) framework. A multi-domain matrix (MDM) is used to capture the interdependencies among these design parameters of the product, and then equations are defined to quantify them. Life cycle assessment (LCA) is then automated to evaluate the product’s environmental impacts, and the investigation of its results provides details to identify critical unit processes contributing to the environmental categories. Sensitivity analyses reveal how changes to individual design parameters propagate through the model to influence the three dimensions of sustainability. Ultimately, the designer can select optimal design parameter values to balance environmental, social, and economic sustainability.
To achieve triple bottom line sustainability, a system requires a balance of its social, economic, and environmental axioms. This multi-dimensional system has multiple stakeholders with different objectives acting within the system, leading to an increased level of complexity. Product design is an area with significant potential to achieve sustainable development, which is also influenced by policies. Product designers/managers and policymakers have been identified as critical stakeholders within this complex system, and their decisions directly affect the transition toward sustainable product design. However, these stakeholders have different perspectives on sustainability, and there is a lack of understanding of the main characteristics of a sustainable design system and its requirements. This research aims to find a detailed and unified understanding of these stakeholder’s perspectives, practices, and requirements. An online survey investigated the views of engineers/managers and policymakers in the United States to find their definitions of sustainability, their assessment methods, drivers, and barriers of sustainability. Finally, the participants were asked to identify their requirements for a sustainable design tool that can assist them effectively in designing a sustainable product. Considering the exploratory nature of this study, a targeted sample of 50 participants was selected to capture in-depth, qualitative insights, enabling a nuanced understanding of this complex system. The open-ended questions were designed to obtain detailed responses, which were analyzed qualitatively to develop a comprehensive view of the current state and future requirements for sustainable design tools. This targeted approach allowed the study to probe deeply into each stakeholder’s frame of reference, facilitating the identification of critical factors for a successful transition to sustainable design in both industry and policy. The results identified the critical factors that contribute to a successful transition toward sustainable product design in industry and policies while the requirements found in this study provided a road map to meet the diverse needs of these stakeholders.
Sustainable design has gained high importance over the past decade due to global environmental concerns. There are various design of sustainability tools available; however, their adoption are limited mainly due to their lack of integration and holistic approach. This research aims to integrate product structural complexity and sustainability assessment methods to find sustainable design strategies. The structural complexity of the product is captured by automatically generating design structure matrix from the product CAD model. The influence and propagation index is used to capture the local and global influence of each component within the product structure. The sustainability assessment for each component is conducted using life cycle assessment and an opportunity score is proposed to find the components with high sustainability impacts and low systemic risks to the design. The sustainable design strategies are investigated through the investigation of the environmental impacts of these components.