We have developed additive logistic models for the occurrence of lightning, large hail (≥2 cm), and very large hail (≥5 cm) to investigate the evolution of these hazards in the past, in the future, and for forecasting applications. The models, trained with lightning observations, hail reports, and predictors from atmospheric reanalysis, assign an hourly probability to any location and time on a 0.25° × 0.25° × 1-hourly grid as a function of reanalysis-derived predictor parameters, selected following an ingredients-based approach. The resulting hail models outperform the significant hail parameter, and the simulated climatological spatial distributions and annual cycles of lightning and hail are consistent with observations from storm report databases, radar, and lightning detection data. As a corollary result, CAPE released above the −10°C isotherm was found to be a more universally skillful predictor for large hail than CAPE. In the period 1950–2021, the models applied to the ERA5 reanalysis indicate significant increases of lightning and hail across most of Europe, primarily due to rising low-level moisture. The strongest modeled hail increases occur in northern Italy with increasing rapidity after 2010. Here, very large hail has become 3 times more likely than it was in the 1950s. Across North America trends are comparatively small, apart from isolated significant increases in the direct lee of the Rocky Mountains and across the Canadian plains. In the southern plains, a period of enhanced storm activity occurred in the 1980s and 1990s.
29 November 2023 in Natural Hazards and Earth System Sciences
Additive logistic regression models for lightning (ARlig) and large hail (ARhail) were developed using convective parameters from the ERA5 reanalysis, hail reports from the European Severe Weather Database (ESWD), and lightning observations from the Met Office Arrival Time Difference network (ATDnet). The models yield the probability of lightning and large hail in a given timeframe over a particular grid point. To explore the value of this approach to medium-range forecasting, the models were applied to the European Centre for Medium Range Weather Forecasts (ECMWF) reforecasts to reconstruct probabilistic lightning and large hail forecasts for 11 ensemble members, from 2008 to 2019 and for lead times up to 228 h. The lightning and large hail models were based on different predictor parameters: most unstable convective available potential energy (CAPE), 925–500 hPa bulk shear, mixed layer mixing ratio, wet bulb zero height (for large hail), most unstable lifted index, mean relative humidity between 850 and 500 hPa, 1 hourly accumulated convective precipitation and specific humidity at 925 hPa (for lightning). First, we compared the lightning and hail ensemble forecasts for different lead times with observed lightning and hail focusing on a recent hail outbreak. Second, we evaluated the predictive skill of the model as a function of forecast lead time using the area under the ROC curve (AUC) as a validation score. This analysis showed that ARhail has a very high predictive skill (AUC > 0.95) for a lead time up to 60 h. ARhail retains a high predictive skill even for extended forecasts (AUC = 0.86 at 180 h lead time). Although ARlig exhibits a lower predictive skill than ARhail, lightning forecasts are also skilful both in the short term (AUC = 0.92 at 60 h) and in the medium range (AUC = 0.82 at 180 h). Finally, we compared the performance of the 4-dimensional hail model with that of composite parameters such as the significant hail parameter (SHP) or the product of CAPE and the 925–500 hPa bulk shear (CAPESHEAR). Results show that ARhail outperforms CAPESHEAR at all lead times and SHP at short-to-medium lead times. These findings suggests that the combination of additive logistic regression models and ECMWF ensemble forecasts can create highly skilful medium-range hail and lightning forecasts for Europe.
23 February 2024 in Environmental Research: Climate
We study the role of changes in circulation type frequency on the evolution of summertime thunderstorm and large hail frequency across Europe since 1950 until 2020 to find out if they are responsible for the changes that an additive regression convective hazard models model (AR-CHaMo) predicts to have happened. To define circulation types, the 500 hPa geopotential height anomaly field on each day was clustered into 14 distinct patterns using principal component analysis and k-means clustering. We show that lightning and hail occurrence, both observed and modeled by AR-CHaMo, strongly depend on the circulation type, with a higher frequency observed in poleward flow downstream of a trough and on the lee side of mountains. AR-CHaMo predicts strong increases in hail frequency across central parts of Europe to have occurred in the 1950–2020 period. During this period, changes in circulation type frequency are small and only significant for 2 of the 14 clusters. The trends in both lightning and hail frequency to be expected if they were solely determined by circulation patterns, are small, with typical values of 1%–3% per decade relative to the mean, whereas the trends expected by AR-CHaMo are on the order of 4%–10% in most areas. Across many regions, the sign of the changes does not agree in sign, in particular across European Russia where circulation types have become more favorable for lightning and hail, but a decreasing probability was modeled by AR-CHaMo. We conclude that changing circulation types are, in general, not responsible for changes in thunderstorm and hail frequency, which included the strong increase of conditions favorable for large hail in central Europe.
Hailstorms producing hail larger than 5 cm cause the most severe damage to property and infrastructure, often leading to multibillion-dollar losses. Here we develop a global climatology of these very large hail events from 1950 to 2023 by combining statistical modelling with atmospheric reanalysis and examine trends in their frequency and related economic impacts. Northern Argentina emerges as the global hotspot of very large hail events, followed by Uruguay, Paraguay, southern Brazil, the US Great Plains and South Africa. Asia—and to a lesser extent, Europe and Australia—show substantially lower frequencies. Europe is seeing the sharpest rise in the frequency of very large hail events, driven by increasing low-level moisture and atmospheric instability. By contrast, the Southern Hemisphere—especially South America—is experiencing notable declines, linked to reduced mid-level humidity and instability. Hail-related losses have increased in the USA, Australia and Europe. In Europe, the rise is mainly due to more frequent very large hail events, whereas in the USA and Australia, increasing exposure and vulnerability are the primary drivers. These contrasting regional trends in hail frequency and related losses underscore the need for tailored risk management strategies that account for both climatic drivers and socio-economic vulnerabilities.
An Additive Logistic Regression model for large hail (ARhail) was developed using convective parameters from the ERA5 reanalysis, hail reports from the European Severe Weather Database (ESWD) and lightning observations from the Met Office Arrival Time Difference network (ATDnet). This model was shown to accurately reproduce the climatological distribution and the seasonal cycle of observed hail events in Europe. To explore the value of this approach to medium-range forecasting, a similar four-dimensional model was developed using predictor parameters retrieved from the ECMWF reforecasts: Mixed Layer CAPE, Deep Layer Shear, Mixed Layer Mixing Ratio and the Wet Bulb Zero Height. This model was applied to ECMWF reforecasts to compute probabilistic large hail forecasts for all available 11 ensemble members, from 2008 to 2019 and for lead times up to 228 hours. First, we compared the hail ensemble forecasts for different lead times with observed hail occurrence from the ESWD focusing on a recent hail outbreak. Secondly, we systematically evaluated the model’s predictive skill depending on the forecast lead time using the Area under the ROC Curve (AUC) as a validation score. This analysis showed that ARhail has a very high predictive skill (AUC > 0.95) for forecasts up to 60 hours lead time. Although the performance scores progressively decrease with increasing lead time, ARhail retains a high predictive skill even for extended forecasts (AUC = 0.86 at 180 hours lead time) showing that it can provide useful guidance in hail forecasting well in advance. Finally, the performance of the four-dimensional model was compared with that of composite parameters such as the Significant Hail Parameter (SHP) and the product of CAPE and Deep Layer Shear (CAPESHEAR). Results show that ARhail outperforms CAPESHEAR (at all lead times) and SHP (especially at short lead times). This suggest that the developed Additive Logistic Regression model can improve hail forecasting compared to currently used composite indices in Europe.
Understanding convective processes leading to severe weather hazards within Mediterranean cyclones is relevant for operational forecasters, insurance industry, and enhancing societal preparedness. In this work we examine the climatological link between Mediterranean cyclones and atmospheric conditions conducive to the formation of severe convection and convective hazards (convective precipitation, lightning and hail potential). Using ATDnet lightning detections we find that, from autumn to spring, 20 to 60% of lightning hours over the Mediterranean basin and adjacent land regions are associated with the presence of a nearby cyclone. Based on reanalysis data, severe convective environments, deep, moist convection (i.e., lightning potential) and related hazards are frequent in the warm sector of Mediterranean cyclones and to the north-east of their centres. In agreement with previous literature, convective processes and hazards peak approximately six hours prior to the time of minimum pressure of the cyclone centre. Moreover, severe convective environments are often detected in cyclone categories typical of transition seasons (especially autumn) and summer, while they are rarer in deep baroclinic cyclones with peak occurrence during winter. Finally, we show that dynamical cyclone features distinguish regions favourable to deep, moist convection. Warm conveyor belts of Mediterranean cyclones, characterised by large-scale ascent and located in regions of high thermodynamic instability, have the largest lightning potential. The potential is only half as intense along the cyclones' cold fronts.