Computing has been historically taught as neutral and devoid of any connection with societies. But more recently, technical tools are taking center stage at societal problem solving, influencing policies and practices around issues such as surveillance, privacy, and algorithmic bias. In this sociopolitical moment, people across different efforts within K-12 computing education are calling for integration of computing with social sciences to center implications of technologies on peoples, communities, and societies. There are multiple facets to these efforts: studying K-12 student engagement with critical content to preparing K-12 educators and ecosystems, developing pedagogical frameworks, and redesigning existing high school computing program to center justice. This panel will present a broad range of efforts towards critical introduction of computing within K-12 settings. While briefly introducing themselves and their work, each panelist will answer the questions: (a) How does your work and experiences address critical computing education? (b) What are some barriers that you have encountered? And (c) How have you addressed these concerns within your designs? Overall, the panel will open the space for discussing, highlighting, and learning from this set of diverse and synergetic critical computing efforts within K-12 computing education.
There have been calls recently to integrate social justice issues with computing and to teach computing as a non-neutral discipline. Among many critical perspectives considered, colonialism and its manifestation in computing is emerging lately. While we barely know about its implications for secondary computing education, high school teachers' engagement with this issue is yet to be examined. In this paper, we qualitatively analyzed the participation of 12 high school computing teachers in the U.S. in curricular co-design sessions to understand: How did teachers relate to the theme of colonialism? And, what connections did they see to secondary computing teaching? We saw that teachers, though not fluent with the theme initially, quickly related to it through their racial and ethnic backgrounds and U.S. colonial history. They further proposed pedagogical strategies to support student learning within classrooms. Based on these findings, we discuss the need to investigate these connections and their implications for design, research, and practices within K-12 computing education globally.
Continued and amplified harm to marginalized communities by computing solutions is pushing computing education to orient towards justice. Resisting harm requires elevating teacher voices within curricular design. We partnered with twelve high school teachers to co-design and revise an existing introductory computing program. We qualitatively analyzed post-co-design teacher inter- views to answer the following: (1) How did teachers perceive their involvement in curricular design? (2) What design aspects of the curricular revision did teachers identify as important to participate as co-designers? (3) What design features supported or challenged teacher participation? Being involved in co-design made teachers feel valued and respected rather than deprofessionalized. Holding a safe space with politicized trust was key to their participation, and opportunities to reflect, share, and listen from diverse perspectives were essential. Policies around curricular design work should emphasize empowering trusting teacher communities to advance justice-oriented goals within computing education.
While most of the identity-related work within STEAM education has examined learners from different marginalized groups, Asians and Asian Americans are some of the least studied identities despite the underrepresentation of several Asian sub-groups within STEAM fields. Educational research has embraced the “model minority” myth, adopted a White-colonial gaze, aggregated Asians into a single “racial group”, and treated it as a dominant group within STEM fields. By resisting the White-centered, colonial simplifications and also conducting ways of engaging with learners that identify with Asian communities, we present four case studies of “Asian” high school students in two STEAM classrooms (which were both implementing an electronic textiles unit) in an attempt to disaggregate and to highlight the diversity and complications in the the otherwise simplified “Asian” identity. We answer the question of how electronic textiles projects support students’ “Asian” identity expression, negotiation, and development. We share how our cases accentuated the role of materiality and pedagogical context in opening possibilities for students to narrate stories of historical, cultural, and familial significance while navigating their complicated “Asian” (or not) identities. We discuss the implications of our findings for the research, design, and practice within STEAM activities to better support the highly diverse and invisibly marginalized Asian-origin students.