Concrete made of recycled coarse aggregate (RCA) derived from multiple sources can have relative variation in mechanical properties compared with natural aggregate concrete (NAC), resulting in a lower reliability of a recycled aggregate concrete (RAC) beam than that of NAC beam. In this paper, a method is proposed to improve the reliability of beams made with RAC by increasing the reinforcement ratio. According to the equilibrium equations of beams subjected to bending moment, the increase in reinforcement ratio can be achieved by decreasing the RAC design strength. Same mean compressive strengths are assumed for RAC and NAC and four factors are considered including concrete grade, reinforcement grade, reinforcement ratio and the ratio of external loads in reliability analysis. Using NAC beams as a reference and keeping the target reliability index the same as that of RAC beams, the analysis results show that RAC design strength decreases with increase in coefficient of variation (CoV) of RAC compressive strength. When the CoV of RAC compressive strength is 20%, the RAC design strengths are 0.93 and 0.90 times of the NAC design strength with a 95% confidence level for grade C30 and C40 concrete, respectively.