Contribution: This article describes how a peer learning strategy called student-led tutorials (SLTs) can improve student performance in an electromagnetism course (EM). This study provides empirical evidence on how promoting student active participation in collaborative problem-solving activities improves performance rates. Background: In 2019, an EM bachelor course introduced SLTs as a strategy to improve the 40% passing rates. Before SLTs, students perceived this course as very hard, uninteresting, disengaging, and nonfundamental to their studies. Intended Outcomes: A participatory environment that promotes active learning can deepen understanding of EM through problem discussion and peer collaboration. Application Design: This study uses an action research approach to analyze teaching practices and students performance. Based on this analysis, SLT is implemented and the results are examined. Drawing on professors’ research on engineering education, traditional practice hours were transformed into SLT hours. Passing rates before and after the intervention were compared and correlated with SLT participation. In-depth qualitative interviews with students were conducted to understand how SLT related to their learning process. Findings: Since the intervention, the course passing rates increased 20%. More importantly, the grade distribution changed from a steep double exponential shape to a normal curve suggesting more students are doing better. There is a positive correlation between SLT participation and student performance. Students highly valued SLTs as a teaching strategy because it allowed discussion, enabled keeping up with the course pace, and created a culture of collaboration. Students also valued the mandatory aspect of SLTs, though they mentioned it increased the course workload.
Research that integrates Learning Analytics (LA) with formative feedback has been shown to enhance student individual learning processes and performance. Debates on LA-based feedback highlight the need to further understand what data sources are appropriate for LA, how soon the feedback should be sent to students and how different types of feedback promote learning. This study describes an empirical case of LA-based feedback in higher education and analyzes how content-focused feedback promotes student achievement. The model combines quantitative achievement indicators with qualitative data about student learning challenges to develop feedback. Data sources include student pretest results, participation in practice exercises as well as midterm and final exam grades. In addition, in-depth interviews with high-, medium- and low-performing students are conducted to understand learning challenges. Based on their performance, students receive content-focused feedback every two weeks. The results show statistically significant improvements in final grades, in addition to a higher rate of problem-solving participation among students who receive feedback compared to their peers who opt out of the study. The contributions to the area of LA-based formative feedback are the following: (a) a model that combines quantitative with qualitative data sources to predict and understand student achievement challenges, (b) templates to design pedagogical and research-based formative feedback, (c) quantitative and qualitative positive results of the experience, (d) a documented case describing the practical implementation process.
28 September 2018 in Edutec. Revista Electrónica de Tecnología Educativa
Este artículo analiza una experiencia de enseñanza de la programación con robots en un centro de educación infantil. Basándonos en observaciones, trabajos prácticos de los alumnos y grupos focales; identificamos que los niños logran construir ideas complejas sobre qué es una computadora, qué es programar y qué hace un programador. La programación de robots con lenguaje icónico también permite desarrollar conceptos computacionales como secuencia, parámetro, ciclo y condicional. Los niños de 5 años establecen correspondencia entre el código programado por ellos y el desplazamiento de los robots, apropiándose de la noción de computadora como máquina programable. Los pequeños de 3 y 4 años no logran comprender esta idea.
Resumen En este artículo presentaramos un análisis de distintas situaciones de aprendizaje y enseñanza que se registraron en escuelas primarias y secundarias a partir del desarrollo de clases de programación desde el enfoque de la enseñaza por descubrimiento. Específicamente trabajaremos sobre los datos obtenidos durante los dos años en que nuestro equipo ofreció un curso de formación docente en didáctica de la programación. Estos datos incluyen pre y post encuestas a docentes que participaron del curso y trasladaron lo aprendido a sus aulas como así también, registros de campo y observaciones de clases realizadas por tutores -especialistas en Ciencias de la Computación- que asistieron a las clases de los docentes para acompañar sus prácticas en el aula. A partir de esta información, se analizaron los datos obtenidos y se observaron recurrencias que permitieron repensar las experiencias de enseñanza de los docentes a la hora de introducir las CC en las escuelas. Cuatro situaciones se reportan recurrentemente en ambos años, las cuales, en lo que respecta a la enseñanza y el aprendizaje de la computación, desafían la estructura tradicional de las escuela formal.
In the last years, many agencies are changing their curriculums to include Computer Science Education in mandatory schooling. The expansion of computational systems to the many aspects of human life allows both, widening human cognition, and requiring computational knowledge and practices as key components of citizenship education. This challenge is immersed in a context with deep digital gaps that contribute to unequally developing the possibilities of computational literacy, thinking and participation among the population. Relying on a systematic review, this article analyzes how specialized literature defined these notions for schooling purposes. Results show that computational literacy is mostly associated with artificial intelligence and programming. This risks reducing the disciplinary field to these hegemonic areas. At the same time, computational participation approaches are linked to the social impact of computer systems. These contributions deepen the discussion, definition and analysis of computational literacy in schools, particularly in the Latin American context where there are few empirical studies in this area.
Contribution: This study identifies the types of interaction that contribute to student learning with student-led tutorials (SLTs). The quality of these interactions include peer discussion, student tutor presentation, joint reasoning, and constructive feedback. Background: The introduction of SLTs in an advanced electromagnetics bachelor course has improved the passing rates from 40% to 60%. SLTs, as one type of peer learning and tutoring, correlate with active learning and student achievement. However, there is not much knowledge about the different kinds of student interactions and its respective impact on learning. Research Question: How students’ interactions contribute to students understanding of content and problem-solving skills in electromagnetism and what influences the quality of such interactions? Design/Method: The study inductively analyzed different sources of data that included classroom observations, student surveys, focus groups, and interviews to identify SLTs interactions. Findings: SLTs contributed to student understanding of concepts, practicing general engineering problem-solving skills, and keeping pace with the course activities. The quality of students’ presentations, the type of questions that tutors posed, the tension between revising all problems in broader terms and discussing concepts in-depth, the difficulty of content knowledge and tutors’ understanding of the problems; influenced the quality of SLT interactions. This research finds that, while in general SLT promotes learning, teaching students how to actively participate and training teaching assistants how to organize classroom interactions, can further contribute to in-depth conceptual discussions of the subject matter.