This article presents the testing of the principle of risk-based planning using the example of the city of Erftstadt, Germany, which was affected by the devastating flood of 2021. The basis of this article was a simulated land use plan approval procedure for a flood-prone site in the urban district of Erftstadt-Liblar. In the contributions, the contents of the environmental report relating to effects to be expected for disasters as well as designations of a risk-based flood-proofed land use plan are presented. As a result of the gaming simulation, the hazard zone plan proves to be a suitable instrument for operationalizing the consideration of flood prevention in risk-prone areas. The simulation also provides evidence that it is possible to implement a risk-based approach within the current legal planning framework in Germany that is laid down by the Federal Building Code (BauGB). Innovative elements are the considerations of the protection worthiness of different types of infrastructures by spatially and contextually differentiated designations. The hazard zone concept, as such, and the findings of the gaming simulation will be used by the state planning authority for an amendment of the regional plan of North-Rhine Westphalia and will therefore be mandatory for the land use planning of all municipalities.
The floods in Western Europe in July 2021 demonstrated the diverse ways and varying paces at which neighborhoods recover from disasters. Based on two exemplary neighborhoods affected by the floods in the city of Hagen, Germany, this study examines the reconstruction process, highlighting the influence of social vulnerabilities and community resilience on private reconstruction processes. Despite differing contexts, both case studies demonstrated a significant reliance on external support during reconstruction. Individual needs varied based on social vulnerabilities within and between population groups, primarily manifesting as challenges in information dissemination and access to support services like funding and expertise. The findings reveal differences in the ability and capacity of neighborhoods to collectively address these vulnerabilities. While small neighborhood networks effectively facilitated information sharing in both cases, one case study relied more heavily on external assistance from nonprofit organizations for larger and longer‐term community‐driven initiatives. The study underscores the need for improvements in postdisaster reconstruction governance. Public authorities predominantly view neighborhoods as recipients rather than partners in the reconstruction process, without adequately addressing their social vulnerabilities within their governance approaches. Supporting local social infrastructures is crucial, as they connect formal reconstruction with the neighborhood, aiding resource access and resilience building.
8 November 2024 in International Journal of Climate Change Strategies and Management
Purpose: Sustainable and climate-adapted urban development requires integrative governance approaches and forms of collaboration between different disciplinary actors in urban society. Integrative approaches are a particular challenge for those planning cultures in which they are not yet sufficiently established. This also applies to formal urban land-use planning in Germany, which forms the governance setting of this study. This study aims to examine how interdisciplinary participation in formal urban land-use planning contributes to the consideration of climate adaptation in the planning process. Design/methodology/approach: This paper traces the process of two differently designed interdisciplinary participation formats based on the methodological framework of a gaming simulation, each in the context of a formal urban land-use planning procedure in Bottrop, Germany. The gaming simulations are designed as performance simulations in which we involved several representatives from different public authorities. Findings: The gaming simulations show that interdisciplinary participation can lead to an increased awareness of climate adaptation requirements in particular and a mutual understanding of different logics of action in the context of comprehensive and sustainable urban planning in general. In addition, this paper provides recommendations as to how and under what conditions the benefits of the simulations can be transferred to municipal practice. Originality/value: While integrative and interdisciplinary formats are increasingly being used in the context of informal urban planning, this does not apply to formal urban land-use planning. Participation in formal urban land-use planning procedures is classically linear and multidisciplinary in Germany. Using two simulated interdisciplinary participation formats, this paper tested to what extent the consideration of climate adaptation requirements as a cross-sectoral task can benefit from interdisciplinarity in the context of two formal urban land-use planning procedures.
28 February 2025 in Raumforschung und Raumordnung | Spatial Research and Planning
This research paper addresses the role of central places in communal fiscal equalisation and, in particular, the question of whether and, if so, how the additional burden associated with the provision of central place functions for the inhabitants of third municipalities is. For this purpose, the fiscal equalisation laws of the federal states are evaluated comparatively. While the role of central places in communal fiscal compensation is widely discussed in the spatial and financial literature, this does not apply to the specific question of the distribution of the additional burden on the municipalities involved in a function-sharing central place. The paper discusses this using the example of the proposed function-sharing upper centre consisting of the City of Halberstadt, World Heritage City Quedlinburg and the City of Wernigerode in the Harz planning region, Germany. This region has so far lacked an upper centre that is reasonably accessible and could help to ensure equal living conditions. It is argued that the distribution of the additional burden equalisation should not only consider the fiscal capacity of the municipalities involved but also their contribution to the joint fulfilment of functions, based on the respective upper-central supply function.