This is a systematic review conducted to explore the primary research literature on student agency in higher education, as well as links between student agency and student learning. Out of more than 2,300 results, 42 articles published between 1980 and 2021 were assessed. Of these, 29 studies were included in a narrative review based on their centrality of student agency and methodological quality. We found that a student agency perspective is integrated into research focussed on assessment and feedback, globalisation and internationalisation, knowledge production, learning analytics, learning connections and transfer, real-life learning situations, and student-focussed teaching and learning. Our study reveals that researchers report a link between sources of agency and student agency, as well as between agency and individual outcomes, but the relationship between agency and societal outcomes requires further investigation. We argue that research must include holistic notions and critical discussions of agency for moving higher education practices and student agency literature forward.
29 July 2020 in Assessment & Evaluation in Higher Education
This paper focuses on the relationship between social aspects and individual agency in digital education, analysed in the context of online peer assessment in a first-semester course. Applying the adapted participation gestalt framework to identify how a particular form of participation emerges, and how it is constituted, individual interviews and focus group meetings with 13 Danish students were carried out. The analysis highlights a number of signs accumulated by students to construct their participation in the interaction. These signs argue against simplistic accounts of student agency in educational research, whereby student agency is approached as an individual and cognitive phenomenon and relationships as stable and unproblematic. The paper argues that student agency should not automatically be assumed possible as part of digital education or digital student-centred learning activities. Instead, the social aspects of educational interactions need to be taken into consideration when presenting digital education as a means to enhance student agency.
21 December 2023 in Edutec. Revista Electrónica de Tecnología Educativa
This study investigates Danish university teachers’ agency in using digital technologies in teaching. Furthermore, it explores how teachers’ conduct and experienced constraints are connected to different dimensions of teachers’ agency. The paper is based on survey responses from 344 teachers about their agentic will and power to influence aspects of technology usage in teaching. Using an exploratory factor analysis, we identify three distinct factors and their relations: 1) wanting to control digital data and having the power to do so is distinct from 2) teachers’ power and will to control the technologies adopted and 3) how technologies are applied in teaching. Furthermore, all factors correlate with the teachers’ conduct (extent to which technology facilitates education interactions), while there are factor-specific patterns to the constraints (e.g., time, experience). The results provide a basis for revisiting teachers’ role in university decision-making. We include a discussion on the entangledness of agency across institutional levels.
Student engagement plays an important role in realising the potential of interdisciplinary learning in monodisciplinary higher education, in which developing interdisciplinary student collaboration has proved challenging. A necessary first step to further discussions around cultivating and supporting disciplinary student engagement in interdisciplinary higher education is to map the landscape of higher education research on student engagement within this content. This article reports on a scoping review of the vast body of empirical research literature. Based on a corpus of 80 included studies published between 2018 and 2023, the study depicts a research field predominantly undertaken within European and North American countries and involving students within STEM disciplines. Studies most often used mixed methods, followed by qualitative methods and quantitative methods. None of the included studies defined student engagement. More often, student engagement was subsumed to other theoretical frameworks adopted. Stemming from the use of engagement and the dimensions of students' experience explored, behavioural and cognitive dimensions of engagement were most often identified, followed by affective engagement. Implications and further directions are discussed. Context and implications: Rationale for this study : Student engagement is central to interdisciplinary student collaboration, the facilitation of which is a key concern and challenge of education. This paper aims to map approaches to student engagement adopted by the research field. Why the new findings matter : In support of meaningful discussions on what engaging in interdisciplinary collaboration requires and involves on the student's part, this study provides a synthesis of current approaches to student engagement within research into interdisciplinary collaboration among monodisciplinary students. Implications for research and practice : The study paves the way for a more understanding of students' investments and expectations towards students in interdisciplinary education.
8 September 2025 in International Journal for Academic Development
In the wake of COVID-19, enthusiasm is growing for hybrid and other blended forms of teaching. Before celebrating the hybrid future of education, however, it is instructive to interrogate its hybrid presence. Accordingly, this article explores pedagogical challenges prompted by the pandemic pivot to online teaching. Analysing qualitative survey data from Danish university teachers (n = 488), we identify five critical stances towards educational technology: (1) technologies are fine when used correctly; (2) technical issues are a major obstacle; (3) hybrid teaching is overwhelming; (4) one's sense of students suffers online; and (5) students hide behind their screens. Based on these results, this article identifies two challenges for the hybrid future of education: the problem of presence and the webcam-related tension between surveillance and care.