Variable traffic conditions cause travel time uncertainty and further lead to time-varying accessibility. Most current studies do not fully consider fluctuations in accessibility and use complicated methods that likely overestimate the level of accessibility and hinder the application of accessibility measures. To address this issue, we utilized large-scale open-source data and proposed an interpretation of the reliability of accessibility concept that incorporates reliability, travel time uncertainty, and a cumulative opportunity measure. We examined the reliability of accessibility to Shenzhen, a major city in China, focusing on transit accessibility and job opportunities. The results demonstrate that the reliability of accessibility displays a bimodal distribution along urban railway lines and can be used to calculate the impact of urban railways in terms of punctuality. The new approach illustrates time-varying characteristics in the form of probabilities and provides further guidance on accessibility for governments.
Evaluating the public welfare level of the urban rail transit systems has not only great significance for the government to provide fair and reasonable subsidies but for the better operation and management of urban rail transit enterprises. An evaluation index system composed of 3 criterion-level indicators and 12 subindexes has been established in this paper. The 3 criterion-level indicators conclude service level, social benefit, and policy loss which are all affected by operation management. Besides, the subjective and objective comprehensive weighting method combined with the analytic hierarchy process method and the entropy weight method is proposed to calculate the index-level weights. Furtherly, the grey correlation-TOPSIS comprehensive evaluation method was designed to calculate the comprehensive evaluation value of the public welfare level of each city. To verify the effectiveness of the proposed method, urban rail transit systems in 16 Chinese cities are studied as a case study. The results show that (1) the three indicators of passenger travel cost (25.69%), the increase in housing prices around urban rail transit(10.74%), and operating cost ratio(9.95%) are more likely to affect the evaluation of public welfare level of urban rail transit. (2) the level of public welfare in different cities is not balanced. The cities with a relatively high level of public welfare relative closeness exceeding 0.5 include Shanghai, Beijing, Shenzhen, Guangzhou, Suzhou, Wuhan, Nanjing, Wuxi, and Dalian. (3) Both GDP and urban population are positively correlated with the relative closeness of social benefit and service level. (4) The level of public welfare can be improved by reducing the fare price and improving the service level, such as increasing the network density, reducing the departure interval, and increasing the average speed.
1 January 2026 in IET Intelligent Transport Systems
Evaluating the accessibility of amenities is fundamental to achieving equitable urban planning of cities. The cumulative opportunity measure (CO) and the two‐step floating catchment area method (2SFCA) are widely used in previous studies. Although there is ongoing debate and discussion about the choice of method for measuring accessibility, the comparison between these two methods has not been thoroughly examined and differences in the spatial distribution of accessibility and the resulting equity from them have tended to be ignored. Here, we contrasted the similarities and differences in spatial accessibility in 12 different scenarios by using CO and 2SFCA, respectively. The scenarios considered the two models in two transportation modes, public transport (PT) and private car (PC), and six key urban services, company, education, healthcare, shopping, restaurant, and scenery, are thoroughly explored. Equity, between different housing price areas, was also evaluated by using the Gini coefficient and Palma ratio. The findings show that the spatial distributions of accessibility from CO are more related to the whole city structure, while the results from 2SFCA can better reflect the local characteristics and spatial heterogeneity. Regarding equity, PT accessibility is less equitable than PC under CO, but more equitable under 2SFCA. We also found that the accessibility and equity of PT are more susceptible to the chosen method compared to PC. This study can help planners understand accessibility and equity from different views and make adjustments of resources allocation in future planning.