Victoria Isabel Moreno Gil

Dr. Victoria Isabel Moreno Gil


Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

8Years (2019-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
3 March 2021 in Media and Communication
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
VGVictoria Isabel Moreno Gil
Victoria Isabel Moreno Gil
XRXavier Ramon
Xavier Ramon
RMRuth Rodríguez- Martínez
Ruth Rodríguez- Martínez
As democracy-building tools, fact-checking platforms serve as critical interventions in the fight against disinformation and polarization in the public sphere. The Duke Reporters’ Lab notes that there are 290 active fact-checking sites in 83 countries, including a wide range of initiatives in Latin America and Spain. These regions share major challenges such as limited journalistic autonomy, difficulties of accessing public data, politicization of the media, and the growing impact of disinformation. This research expands upon the findings presented in previous literature to gain further insight into the standards, values, and underlying practices embedded in Spanish and Latin American projects while identifying the specific challenges that these organizations face. In-depth interviews were conducted with decision-makers of the following independent platforms: Chequeado (Argentina), UYCheck (Uruguay), Maldita.es and Newtral (Spain), Fact Checking (Chile), Agência Lupa (Brazil), Ecuador Chequea (Ecuador), and ColombiaCheck (Colombia). This qualitative approach offers nuanced data on the volume and frequency of checks, procedures, dissemination tactics, and the perceived role of the public. Despite relying on small teams, the examined outlets’ capacity to verify facts is noteworthy. Inspired by best practices in the US and Europe and the model established by Chequeado, all the sites considered employ robust methodologies while leveraging the power of digital tools and audience participation. Interviewees identified three core challenges in fact-checking practice: difficulties in accessing public data, limited resources, and the need to reach wider audiences. Starting from these results, the article discusses the ways in which fact-checking operations could be strengthened.

29 March 2022 in Profesional de la información
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
VGVictoria Isabel Moreno Gil
Victoria Isabel Moreno Gil
XRXavier Ramon
Xavier Ramon
MMMarcel Mauri-Ríos
Marcel Mauri-Ríos
The rise of fact-checking as an innovative tool aimed at improving democratic well-being has become a transnational movement in journalism. In June 2021, the Duke Reporters’ Lab database features 341 such initiatives around the world, including 33 active fact-checking projects in countries pertaining to the Mediterranean or Polarized Pluralist Model (Hallin; Mancini, 2004). Following previous research on fact-checking in other territories, this qualitative study expands the understanding of how this practice is performed by four platforms of countries belonging to this journalistic culture: Maldita.es (Spain), Les Surligneurs (France), Observador (Portugal), and Pagella Politica (Italy). Through in-depth interviews with their decision-makers, this work offers a deep understanding of the structure, agenda, practices, and values, the role of the public, and the challenges that these organizations face. Normally run by small but multidisciplinary teams, the studied initiatives show high levels of transparency and a tendency for continuous improvement and professionalization despite their limitations. Following the example of leading initiatives in the USA, the UK, Latin America and Europe, the analyzed organizations cover a wide range of thematic areas and make use of the latest digital tools. They employ robust methodologies when selecting the content they verify, consult an extensive range of sources, and set various control filters before publication, which proves their commitment to transparency and accountability. Furthermore, they guarantee the right of reply and are widely open to public participation and broader dissemination of their work through mainstream media. From difficulties in accessing public information to scarcity of resources and increased competition, fact-checking platforms in the Mediterranean context face major challenges that have forced them to rethink their role and find new revenue streams. These organizations highlight the need to enhance the impact of fact-checking among citizens, journalists, and politicians and, ultimately, to go back to the roots of journalism.

7 November 2023 in Societies
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
VGVictoria Isabel Moreno Gil
Victoria Isabel Moreno Gil
XRXavier Ramon
Xavier Ramon
RMRuth Rodríguez- Martínez
Ruth Rodríguez- Martínez
MMMarcel Mauri-Ríos
Marcel Mauri-Ríos
In the post-COVID era, explanatory journalism is undergoing a resurgence that can be attributed to the proliferation of false content disseminated via social networks and the maturation of fact checking initiatives. Fact checkers are beginning to delve into those topics that are recurrent targets of disinformation to make complex issues accessible to the public. This study investigates the characteristics and methodologies of contemporary explanatory journalism by analysing four European verification platforms (Newtral in Spain, Les Décodeurs in France, FACTA.news in Italy and The Journal FactCheck unit in Ireland). We employed content analysis of a corpus of explainers and semi-structured interviews with the managers of these outlets. Our findings reveal that explainers encompass a wide range of topics, typically revolving around current affairs. These pieces are usually authored by fact checkers and published, with bylines, within dedicated sections that encourage audience participation. Explainers do not adhere to a fixed periodicity or length and adopt a format similar to feature articles, displaying a degree of flexibility. They leverage data provided by experts and official sources and employ visual elements to convey information clearly. The interviewed managers concur that explanatory journalism represents an invaluable tool in combatting disinformation and has a promising future ahead.

3 January 2025 in Profesional de la información
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
SPSonia Parratt-Fernández
Sonia Parratt-Fernández
MCMaría-Ángeles Chaparro-Domínguez
María-Ángeles Chaparro-Domínguez
VGVictoria Isabel Moreno Gil
Victoria Isabel Moreno Gil
Journalists are expected to make an ethical use of artificial intelligence (AI) systems in their editorial work in order to maintain journalistic principles while adapting to AI. The growing academic interest in the journalistic use of AI and its ethical limits results in research of potential value for newsrooms. The first purpose of this study is to outline emerging ethical codes and guidelines on the use of AI in newsrooms developed and made public by news organizations worldwide. Secondly, it aims at systematizing proposals and recommendations from academic sources that could potentially contribute to develop new ethical codes and guidelines on the use of AI in newsrooms and to improve the existing ones. The third purpose is to assess to what extent such proposals and recommendations appear in ethical codes and guidelines. Ultimately, this allows us to find out whether academic contributions could be better exploited by media practitioners. Documents from 84 media organizations of Europe, America, and Asia, and eight major proposals or recommendations from twelve academic papers were identified and analyzed. Results show that, at present, 40 ethical codes or recommendations around the world are accessible to the public. Proposals coming from academic sources are related to accuracy and credibility, accessibility, relevant contents, diversity, transparency and accountability, data and privacy, human factor, and interdisciplinary teams. One significant finding is that the proposals have a limited presence in media organizations' ethical codes on AI and the ones with greater presence focus on the importance of the human factor, both in editorial decision-making and in the creative part of the journalistic process. Ultimately, the results highlight the need to discuss the professional-academic divide.

4 April 2023 in Communication & Society
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
VGVictoria Isabel Moreno Gil
Victoria Isabel Moreno Gil
MCMaría-Ángeles Chaparro-Domínguez
María-Ángeles Chaparro-Domínguez
MPMarta Pérez Pereiro
Marta Pérez Pereiro
Disinformation has become a global problem affecting mass media, governments and citizens globally. Besides the loss of trust in the media and its weakening influence, exposure to all manner of messages on social media in recent years has paved the way for disinformation, which has become a considerable challenge for journalism. According to the 2022 Edelman Trust Barometer, Spain is one of the countries most concerned about this phenomenon (Edelman, 2022). However, is this concern shared by Spanish journalist associations? What training initiatives are being carried out for future journalists to counter the spread of disinformation? How should fact-checking be taught in university? This study aims to answer these questions by using a dual methodology. First, a review and analysis were undertaken on the different training initiatives for bachelor’s and university-specific master’s degree students. Then, 15 in-depth interviews were conducted with experts, including fact-checkers, experienced journalists and representatives of sectoral associations, to ascertain their views on fact-checking and disinformation. The main results show that Spanish universities offer few training fact-checking-related initiatives, particularly at bachelor’s degree level, although more and more university-specific degrees and master’s degrees on this topic are becoming available. Furthermore, most interviewees view specialised training for the next generation of journalists as a key factor for fighting disinformation, and they provide guidelines to achieve this.

7 January 2023 in Revista de Comunicación
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
FDFrancesc Salgado-De Dios
Francesc Salgado-De Dios
VGVictoria Isabel Moreno Gil
Victoria Isabel Moreno Gil
Tras ser fundadas de forma mayoritaria entre 2017 y 2019, las plataformas de verificación en España han conseguido presencia y estabilidad públicas suficientes como para comprender el papel que realizan en la lucha contra la desinformación. Con el objetivo de investigar cuál es el seguimiento que estas organizaciones realizan de las normas internacionales, este artículo investiga la asunción de los principios de la International Fact-Checking Network (IFCN) por parte de las plataformas españolas vinculadas: Maldita.es, Newtral, Verificat y EFE Verifica. Para llevarlo a cabo, se elabora una ficha de codificación con el objetivo de testar la asimilación de los principios de imparcialidad, transparencia de las fuentes, financiación, metodología y política de corrección de errores. En general, se da un alto cumplimiento de los principios de la IFCN, en especial en la aplicación de una metodología estándar internacional en los procesos de verificación, que ha sido asumida en las cuatro plataformas estudiadas. Sin embargo, algunos índices presentan un menor cumplimiento, como aquellos que tienen que ver con la transparencia económica y empresarial de las plataformas, mejorable tanto al detallar en los balances anuales las listas de principales donantes como en informar en detalle acerca de los tratos comerciales con terceros, ya sean otras empresas informativas o entidades con las que se firman convenios comerciales, como ocurre por ejemplo con Google o Facebook. Con todo, las plataformas de fact-checking españolas han encontrado en la colaboración supranacional una forma de legitimidad y seguridad institucional, pero su consolidación presenta algunas fisuras deontológicas y metodológicas que podrían comprometer su legitimidad en un futuro.