Carbon price is a key variable in management and risk decisions in activities related to the burning of fossil fuels. Different major players in this market, such as polluters, regulators and financial actors, have different time horizons. We use innovative multivariate wavelet analysis tools, including partial wavelet coherence and partial wavelet gain, to study the link between carbon prices and final energy prices in the time and frequency dimensions in California's carbon market, officially known as the California cap-and-trade programme. We find that gasoline prices lead an anti-phase relation with carbon prices. This result is very stable at lower frequencies (close to 1-year period cycles), and it is also present before mid-2015 in the 20–34 weeks frequency band. Regarding electricity, we find that at about a 1-year period, a rise in carbon prices is reflected in higher electricity prices. We conclude that the first 5 years of compliance of the California cap-and-trade programme show that emissions trading is a significant measure for climate change mitigation, with visible rising carbon prices. The quantitative financial analytics we present supports the recent decision to extend the current market to 2030 without the need for complementary carbon pricing schemes. This article is part of the theme issue ‘Redundancy rules: the continuous wavelet transform comes of age’.
We provide a comparative analysis of how short-run variations in carbon and energy prices relate to each other in the emerging greenhouse gas market in California (Western Climate Initiative [WCI], and the European Union Emission Trading Scheme [EU ETS]). We characterize the relationship between carbon, gas, coal, electricity and gasoline prices and an indicator for economic activity, and present a first analysis of carbon prices in the WCI. We also provide a comparative analysis of the structures of the two markets. We estimate a vector autoregressive model and the impulse--response functions. Our main findings show a positive impact from a carbon shock toward electricity, in both markets, but larger in the WCI electricity price, indicating more efficiency. We propose that the widening of carbon market sectors, namely fuels transport and electricity imports, may contribute to this result. To conclude, the research shows significant and coherent relations between variables in WCI, which demonstrate some degree of success for a first year in operation. Reversely, the EU ETS should complete its intended market reform, to allow for more impact of the carbon price. Finally, in both markets, there is no evidence of carbon pricing depleting economic activity.
This work analyses the economic implications of introducing an Emissions Trading System (ETS) in Colombia for compliance with emission reduction agreements. For this purpose, an emissions trading module was designed and incorporated into the general equilibrium model MEG4C. From this analysis, it was possible to identify two effects of an ETS: (i) the regulated sectors incorporate the marginal cost of emissions into production, which brings about a reduction in production, and (ii) the sectors substitute emission intensive goods, seeking to minimize the costs associated with the value of the emission permit, which leads to a reduction in emissions due to a change in intensity. Finally, it is observed that when the funds from the sale of permits are used to promote capital demand (to encourage investment), abatements are achieved at a lower cost to GDP, given that these resources contribute to economic transformation, sustainable development and the generation of other co-benefits. Key policy insights An emissions trading system in Colombia would allow mitigation targets under its nationally determined contribution (NDC) to be achieved cost-effectively. Modelling suggests the implementation of a full sector ETS would result in a reduction in the annual GDP growth rate of 0.8 percentage points, on average, versus the business as usual scenario. The option of recycling the revenues of the ETS into capital support, leads to long-term substitution for less emission intensive energy sources, negatively impacting production in the oil, coal and livestock sectors. The demand for capital increases in capital intensive sectors, even more so if they are low-emission sectors, while it decreases in all others.