This study investigates the interaction of polyacrylamide (PAM) of different functional groups (sulfonate vs. carboxylate) and charge density (30% hydrolysed vs. 10% hydrolysed) with calcium carbonate (CaCO3) via atomic force microscopy (AFM) and partly via molecular dynamic (MD) simulations. The PAM used were F3330 (30% hydrolysed), AN125 (25% sulfonated), and AN910 (% hydrolysed). A total of 100 ppm of PAMs was prepared in 0.1% NaCl, 3% NaCl, and 4.36% NaNO3 to be employed in AFM experiments, while oligomeric models (30 repeating units) of hydrolysed polyacrylamide (HPAM), sulfonated polyacrylamide (SPAM), and neutral PAM (NPAM) were studied on a model calcite surface on MD simulations. AFM analysis indicated that F3330 has a higher average adhesion and interaction energy with CaCO3 than AN125 due to the bulky sulfonate side group of AN125 interfering with SPAM adsorption. Steric repulsion of both PAMs was similar due to their comparable molecular weights and densities of the charged group. In contrast, AN910 showed lower average adhesion and interaction energy, along with slightly longer steric repulsion with calcite than F3330, suggesting AN910 adopts more loops and tails than the slightly flatter F3330 configuration. An increase in salt concentration from 0.1% to 3% NaCl saw a reduction in adhesion and interaction energy for F3330 and AN125 due to charge screening, while AN910 saw an increase, and these values increased further at 4.36% NaNO3. MD simulations revealed that the salt ions in the system formed salt bridges between PAM and calcite, indicating that the adhesion and interaction energy observed from AFM are likely to be the net balance between PAM charged group screening and salt bridging by the salt ions present. Salt ions with larger bare radii and smaller hydrated radii were shown to form stronger salt bridges.
In this work, the interaction of hydrolysed polyacrylamide (HPAM) of two molecular weights (F3330, 11–13 MDa; F3530, 15–17 MDa) with calcium carbonate (CaCO3) was studied via atomic force microscopy (AFM). In the absence of polymers at 1.7 mM and 1 M NaCl, good agreement with DLVO theory was observed. At 1.7 mM NaCl, repulsive interaction during approach at approximately 20 nm and attractive adhesion of approximately 400 pN during retraction was measured, whilst, at 1 M NaCl, no repulsion during approach was found. Still, a significantly larger adhesion of approximately 1400 pN during retraction was observed. In the presence of polymers, results indicated that F3330 displayed higher average adhesion (450–625 pN) and interaction energy (43–145 aJ) with CaCO3 than F3530’s average adhesion (85–88 pN) and interaction energy (8.4–11 aJ). On the other hand, F3530 exerted a longer steric repulsion distance (70–100 nm) than F3330 (30–70 nm). This was likely due to the lower molecular weight. F3330 adopted a flatter configuration on the calcite surface, creating more anchor points with the surface in the form of train segments. The adhesion and interaction energy of both HPAM with CaCO3 can be decreased by increasing the salt concentration. At 3% NaCl, the average adhesion and interaction energy of F3330 was 72–120 pN and 5.6–17 aJ, respectively, while the average adhesion and interaction energy of F3530 was 11.4–48 pN and 0.3–2.98 aJ, respectively. The reduction of adhesion and interaction energy was likely due to the screening of the COO− charged group of HPAM by salt cations, leading to a reduction of electrostatic attraction between the negatively charged HPAM and the positively charged CaCO3.
In this work, the consolidation of calcium carbonate (CaCO3) by polyacrylamide (PAM) of different molecular weights, charge densities, and functional groups was investigated via oscillatory rheology and unconfined compressive strength (UCS) analysis. Oscillatory rheology showed that the storage modulus G′ was approximately 10 times higher than the loss modulus G″, indicating a highly elastic CaCO3 sample upon consolidation via PAM. Both oscillatory rheology and UCS analysis exhibited similar trends, wherein the mechanical values (G′, G″, and UCS) first increased with increasing polymer dosage, until they reached a peak value (typically at 3 mgpol/gCaCO3), followed by a decrease in the mechanical values. This indicates that there is an optimum polymer dosage for the different PAM-CaCO3 colloidal systems, and that exceeding this value induces the re-stabilisation of the colloidal system, leading to a decreased degree of consolidation. Regarding the effect of the PAM molecular weight, the peak G′ and UCS values of CaCO3 consolidated by hydrolysed PAM (HPAM) of different molecular weights are very similar. This is likely due to the contour length of the HPAMs being either almost the same or longer than the average distance between two CaCO3 particles. The effect of the PAM charge density revealed that the peak G′ and UCS values decreased as the charge density of the PAM increased, while the optimum PAM dosage increased with decreasing PAM charge density. The higher likelihood of lower-charge PAM bridging between the particles contributes to higher elastic energy and mechanical strength. Finally, regarding the PAM functional group, CaCO3 consolidated by sulfonated polyacrylamide (SPAM) typically offers lower mechanical strength than that consolidated with HPAM. The bulky sulfonate side groups of SPAM interfere with the surface packing, reducing the number of polymers able to adsorb onto the surface and, eventually, reducing the degree of consolidation of CaCO3. The zeta potential of the PAM-CaCO3 samples became more negative with increasing PAM concentration due to the saturation of the particle surface. Good agreement between oscillatory rheology and UCS analysis could accelerate PAM screening for optimum CaCO3 consolidation.