Would another origin of life resemble Earth’s biochemical use of amino acids? Here, we review current knowledge at three levels: (1) Could other classes of chemical structure serve as building blocks for biopolymer structure and catalysis? Amino acids now seem both readily available to, and a plausible chemical attractor for, life as we do not know it. Amino acids thus remain important and tractable targets for astrobiological research. (2) If amino acids are used, would we expect the same L-alpha-structural subclass used by life? Despite numerous ideas, it is not clear why life favors L-enantiomers. It seems clearer, however, why life on Earth uses the shortest possible (alpha-) amino acid backbone, and why each carries only one side chain. However, assertions that other backbones are physicochemically impossible have relaxed into arguments that they are disadvantageous. (3) Would we expect a similar set of side chains to those within the genetic code? Many plausible alternatives exist. Furthermore, evidence exists for both evolutionary advantage and physicochemical constraint as explanatory factors for those encoded by life. Overall, as focus shifts from amino acids as a chemical class to specific side chains used by post-LUCA biology, the probable role of physicochemical constraint diminishes relative to that of biological evolution. Exciting opportunities now present themselves for laboratory work and computing to explore how changing the amino acid alphabet alters the universe of protein folds. Near-term milestones include: (a) expanding evidence about amino acids as attractors within chemical evolution; (b) extending characterization of other backbones relative to biological proteins; and (c) merging computing and laboratory explorations of structures and functions unlocked by xeno peptides.
Moyer, M. J., E. M. Rose, D. A. Moreland, A. Raza, S. M. Brown, A. L. Scarselletta, B. Lohr, K. J. Odom, and K. E. Omland. 2022. Female song is structurally different from male song in Orchard Orioles, a temperate-breeding songbird with delayed plumage maturation. Journal of Field Ornithology 93(1):3. https://doi.org/10.5751/JFO-00073-930103
Life on Earth builds genetically encoded proteins by using a standard alphabet of just 20 L-α-amino acids, although many others were available to life's origins and early evolution. To better understand the causes of this foundational evolutionary outcome, we extend previous analyses which have identified a highly unusual distribution of biophysical properties within the set used by life. Specifically, we use a heuristic search algorithm to identify other sets of amino acids, from a library of plausible alternatives, that emulate life's signature. We find that a subset of amino acids seems predisposed to forming such sets. We present other examples of such alphabets under various assumptions, along with analysis and reasoning about why each might be simplistic. We do so to introduce the central, open question that remains: while fundamental biophysics related to protein folding can potentially reduce a library of 10 54 possible amino acid alphabets by 7 orders of magnitude, the framework of assumptions that does so leaves a further 10 45 possibilities. It is therefore tempting to ask what additional assumptions can further reduce these 45 orders of magnitude? We thus conclude with a focus on library and alphabet construction as a useful target for subsequent research that may help future science speak with more confidence about what an alien amino acid alphabet would look like and why.
Mass spectrometry is one of the most effective analytical methods for unknown compound identification. By comparing observed m/z spectra with a database of experimentally determined spectra, this process identifies compound(s) in any given sample. Unknown sample identification is thus limited to whatever has been experimentally determined. To address the reliance on experimentally determined signatures, multiple state-of-the-art MS spectra prediction algorithms have been developed within the past half decade. Here we evaluate the accuracy of the NEIMS spectral prediction algorithm. We focus our analyses on monosubstituted α-amino acids given their significance as important targets for astrobiology, synthetic biology, and diverse biomedical applications. Our general intent is to inform those using generated spectra for detection of unknown biomolecules. We find predicted spectra are inaccurate for amino acids beyond the algorithms training data. Interestingly, these inaccuracies are not explained by physicochemical differences or the derivatization state of the amino acids measured. We thus highlight the need to improve both current machine learning based approaches and further optimization of ab initio spectral prediction algorithms so as to expand databases for structures beyond what is currently experimentally possible, even including theoretical molecules.
The central dogma of molecular biology describes how genetic information stored in nucleic acids guides the formation of structured proteins from a single molecular alphabet of twenty amino acids (C20). The extent to which C20 is uniquely capable of forming structural polymers remains a fundamental open question. Here we demonstrate that peptides built from other, "xeno" amino acid alphabets can adopt protein-like secondary structural motifs. Having designed two different xeno alphabets, with them we constructed both combinatorial random sequence libraries and specific, designed 25-mer sequences. We report sequence-dependent structural motifs that result according to circular dichroism, infrared spectroscopy and nuclear magnetic resonance interpreted by molecular dynamics simulations, supported by extensive quantum mechanical calculations. This evidence, including a solution-phase NMR-resolved helical motif, demonstrates that the potential for amino acids to form structure bearing sequences is not unique to life's alphabet, and thereby reveals a previously unexplored sequence-structure space. Results inform the search for extraterrestrial life, lay foundations for incorporating novel synthetic functional groups and heteroatoms into structure-bearing alphabets, and provide the first truly independent data with which to test and improve all that has been learned about protein folding from the study of life's 20 side chains.
The standard set of 20 genetically-encoded amino acids (C20) exhibits a statistically non-random distribution in two structurally-relevant physicochemical properties: hydrophobicity and molecular volume. It remains an open question, however, whether evolutionary pressures similarly optimized the same alphabet for the distribution of functionally-relevant properties, such as reactivity. In this study, we used quantum chemistry simulations to calculate the highest occupied molecular orbital and lowest unoccupied molecular orbital (HOMO-LUMO) gaps for 84 xeno amino acids and constructed 10 million random 20-mer amino acid alphabets to determine where C20 fit amongst this background in terms of reactivity. The HOMO-LUMO gap measurements demonstrated that C20, similar to hydrophobicity and volume, also exhibits a non-random distribution in expected reactivity. However, unlike hydrophobicity and volume, this distribution is non-random across an unevenly broad range of values. The results expand upon previous theory and suggest HOMO-LUMO gap measurements as one synthetic biologists may consider when developing novel protein design tools or designing functional xeno amino acid alphabets.