Photon Stereotactic Body Radiotherapy (SBRT) for primary and metastatic tumors of the liver is challenging for larger lesions. An in silico comparison of paired SBRT and Stereotactic Body Proton Therapy (SBPT) plans was performed to understand the potential advantages of SBPT as a function of tumor size and location. Theoretical tumor volumes with maximum diameter of 1–10 cm were contoured in the dome, right inferior, left medial, and central locations. SBRT and SBPT plans were generated to deliver 50 Gy in 5 fractions, max dose <135%. When organs-at-risk (OAR) constraints were exceeded, hypothetical plans (not clinically acceptable) were generated for comparison. Liver normal tissue complication probability (NTCP) models were applied to evaluate differences between treatment modalities. SBRT and SBPT were able to meet target goals and OAR constraints for lesions up to 7 cm and 9 cm diameter, respectively. SBPT plans resulted in a higher integral gross target dose for all lesions up to 7 cm (mean dose 57.8 ± 2.3 Gy to 64.1 ± 2.2 Gy, p < 0.01). Simultaneously, SBPT spared dose to the uninvolved liver in all locations (from 11.5 ± 5.3 Gy to 8.6 ± 4.4 Gy, p < 0.01), resulting in lower NTCP particularly for larger targets in the dome and central locations. SBPT also spared duodenal dose across all sizes and positions (from 7.3 ± 1.1 Gy to 1.1 ± 0.3 Gy, p < 0.05). The main advantages of SBPT over SBRT is meeting plan goals and constrains for larger targets, particularly dome and central locations, and sparing dose to uninvolved liver. For such patients, SBPT may allow improvements in tumor control and treatment safety.
Background: This study aims to present the feasibility of developing a synchrotron-based proton ultra-high dose rate (UHDR) pencil beam scanning (PBS) system. Methods: The RF extraction power in the synchrotron system was increased to generate 142.4 MeV pulsed proton beams for UHDR irradiation at ~100 nA beam current. The charge per spill was measured using a Faraday cup. The spill length and microscopic time structure of each spill was measured with a 2D strip transmission ion chamber. The measured UHDR beam fluence was used to derive the spot dwell time for pencil beam scanning. Absolute dose distributions at various depths and spot spacings were measured using Gafchromic films in a solid-water phantom. Results: For proton UHDR beams at 142.4 MeV, the maximum charge per spill is 4.96 ± 0.10 nC with a maximum spill length of 50 ms. This translates to an average beam current of approximately 100 nA during each spill. Using a 2 × 2 spot delivery pattern, the delivered dose per spill at 5 cm and 13.5 cm depth is 36.3 Gy (726.3 Gy/s) and 56.2 Gy (1124.0 Gy/s), respectively. Conclusions: The synchrotron-based proton therapy system has the capability to deliver pulsed proton UHDR PBS beams. The maximum deliverable dose and field size per pulse are limited by the spill length and extraction charge.
10 May 2021 in IEEE Transactions on Radiation and Plasma Medical Sciences
Ultrahigh dose rate (FLASH) proton therapy is of great interest due to potential reduced normal tissue toxicities without compromising tumor killing effect compared to current clinical proton practices. However, the ionization chamber response to proton beams under ultra-high dose rates (>40Gy/s) has not been thoroughly investigated. In this study, four different ion chambers (PTW 34045 Advanced Markus, PPC-40, CC-04, and CC-13 from IBA Dosimetry) were irradiated with 230MeV proton beams at 1.5Gy/s, 63.7Gy/s, and 127.6Gy/s dose rates. Theoretical values of ion recombination correction factor (k2) were calculated from saturation curves using Niatel’s model. The theoretical k2 values were compared to the values using the two-voltage (2V) method from standard dosimetry protocols and the three-voltage linear (3VL) method proposed by Rossomme et al. Both parallel plate chambers and CC-04 demonstrated adequate ion collection efficiency at the highest dose rate. For these three chambers, there is no statistically significant difference between theoretical k2 values and those calculated with 2V and 3VL methods. However, significant ion recombination correction was found in CC-13 (k2>1.50) when dose rate reached 63.7Gy/s. The assumption of insignificant initial recombination in standard dosimetry protocols also underestimated the ion recombination effect in this scenario.
Objectives: Ultra-high dose-rate FLASH radiotherapy has demonstrated strong potential in reducing normal tissue toxicity while maintaining effective tumor control. However, its underlying radiobiological mechanisms remain unclear, highlighting the need for novel approaches to probe the effects of radiation during and immediately after delivery. This study presents the first exploration of 3D PET imaging of positron-emitting nuclei (PENs) generated by a FLASH proton beam. Methods: A home-built 12-panel preclinical small-animal PET system was employed for recording coincidence events. A 142.4 MeV FLASH proton beam with a 100 ms delivery time was directed into a solid water phantom. PET coincidence signals were recorded during the first 1 s and up to 11 min. The system’s capability for 3D localization was also assessed, and Monte Carlo simulations were performed for validation. Results: The PET system successfully recorded coincidence data within the first second, including the 100 ms beam delivery interval. Detector dead-time effects under the high beam flux were observed, leading to underestimated event counts. Following irradiation, the measured activity and decay behavior were consistent with simulations. The PET system accurately reconstructed the spatial distribution of PEN activities, with discrepancies in measured versus calculated line profiles ranging from 3.35–6.85%. Reconstructed PET images enabled reliable 3D localization with sub-millimeter accuracy in both lateral and depth dimensions. Conclusions: Our findings demonstrate that a multi-detector PET system is a promising tool for investigating the radiation effects of FLASH beams.
21 October 2026 in International Journal of Radiation Biology