In recent years, the field of precipitation concentration has garnered significant research interest owing to the importance of precipitation for economic activities related to agriculture, energy production, and drinking water supply management. For the study and characterization of precipitation concentration, different approaches have been defined, such as consideration of the concentration index (CI), Theil index (TI), Q index (QI), and precipitation concentration degree (PCD) index. However, in the literature, there is only one study that evaluates the performance of the CI and TI in conjunction on a spatial basis. Another study evaluates the behaviour of the QI and PCD indices on a temporal basis. Thus, the objective of this work was to analyse the behaviour of the four indices both on temporal and spatial scales according to Mexico's precipitation. Results show that the four indices can detect, in a similar manner, the concentration degree of regions with different rainfall regimes, each within its own variability. A lower range of variability was found for the TI, while the highest was found for the CI and the PCD index. In addition, the PCD index showed high sensitivity within its concentration degree when calculated for different time intervals. The results of the temporal and spatial correlation analysis show a very high correlation between the CI and TI, and moderate and low correlations among the other indices. Low correlations can be attributed to the differences in the theoretical bases of each index. Although low correlations were shown for some indices, the results indicate that these can be used in a complementary manner to improve the precipitation concentration analysis on temporal and spatial scales.
1 January 2019 in Ingeniería Agrícola y Biosistemas
In recent years, precipitation concentration indices have become popular, and the daily precipitation concentration index has been widely used worldwide. This index is based on the Lorenz curve fitting. Recently, some biases in the fitting process have been observed in some research. Therefore, this research’s objective consisted of testing the performance of one alternative equation for fitting the Lorenz curve through the analysis of the daily precipitation concentration in Brazil. Daily precipitation data from 735 time series were used to fit the Lorenz curve and calculate the concentration index. Therefore, the goodness of fit was evaluated to determine which equation better describes the empirical data. Results show that the mean value for the concentration index based on Equation (1) was 0.650 ± 0.079, while the mean value based on Equation (2) was 0.624 ± 0.070. The results of the fitting performance show a better fitting with Equation (2) compared to Equation (1) as indicated by R2, RSS, and RMSE values, R2 = 0.9959 for Equation (1) versus 0.9996 for Equation (2), RSS = 252.78 versus 22.66, and RMSE = 1.5092 versus 0.0501. Thus, Equation (2) can be considered an alternative to improve the calculation of the concentration index.
Precipitation concentration indices have become a popular tool for analyzing the structure of daily precipitation amounts. Among the existing indices, the concentration index (CI) is widely used. In calculating the CI, an important aspect is adjusting the Lorenz curve based on the observed precipitation data. Usually, the fit has been carried out with equations of the type y = axebx. However, in some research work, it has been observed that sometimes, the fit obtained only partially describes the behavior of the data. Thus, this work evaluated an alternative functional form to fit the Lorenz curve. For this, daily precipitation data from 44 climatological stations in Mexico were used to assess two equations for adjusting the Lorenz curve. Once the fit was made, the goodness of fit was evaluated to determine which of the functional forms best described the behavior of the data. Results showed that the two functional forms produced similar results for low precipitation concentrations. However, when the concentration increased, the alternative functional form generated results following the behavior of the observations. Thus, it is recommended to use the alternative functional form to avoid overestimations of the concentration of daily precipitation in areas where it is known that a high concentration occurs.