In papers on cold field electron emission from large-area field emitters (LAFEs), it has become widespread practice to publish a misleading Fowler-Nordheim-type (FN-type) equation. This equation over-predicts the LAFE-average current density by a large highly variable factor thought to usually lie between 10(3) and 10(9). This equation, although often referenced to FN's 1928 paper, is a simplified equation used in undergraduate teaching, does not apply unmodified to LAFEs and does not appear in the 1928 paper. Technological LAFE papers often do not cite any theoretical work more recent than 1928, and often do not comment on the discrepancy between theory and experiment. This usage has occurred widely, in several high-profile American and UK applied-science journals (including Nanotechnology), and in various other places. It does not inhibit practical LAFE development, but can give a misleading impression of potential LAFE performance to non-experts. This paper shows how the misleading equation can be replaced by a conceptually complete FN-type equation that uses three high-level correction factors. One of these, or a combination of two of them, may be useful as an additional measure of LAFE quality; this paper describes a method for estimating factor values using experimental data and discusses when it can be used. Suggestions are made for improved engineering practice in reporting LAFE results. Some of these should help to prevent situations arising whereby an equation appearing in high-profile applied-science journals is used to support statements that an engineering regulatory body might deem to involve professional negligence.
8 October 2013 in Proceedings of the Royal Society A: Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences
The orthodox emission hypothesis is a set of physical and mathematical assumptions that permit well-specified analysis of measured current–voltage data relating to field electron emission (FE). If these assumptions are not adequately satisfied, then widely used FE data-analysis methods can generate spurious values for emitter characterization parameters, particularly field enhancement factors (FEFs). This paper describes development of a simple quantitative test for whether FE data are incompatible with the hypothesis. It applies to any geometrical emitter shape and any Fowler–Nordheim (FN) plot type, and involves extracting the related range of scaled-barrier-field values ( f values). By analysing historical data, this paper identifies ‘apparently reasonable’ and ‘clearly unreasonable’ experimental ranges for f . The historical data, taken between 1926 and 1972, are internally self-consistent. This test is then applied to 19 post-1975 datasets, mainly for various carbon and semiconductor nanostructures. Some extracted f -value ranges (including many carbon results) are apparently reasonable, some are clearly unreasonable. It is shown that if extracted f values are ‘unreasonably high’, then FEF values extracted by literature methods are spuriously large. New materials and published FN plots that generate particularly high FEF values require testing, and improved data-analysis theory is needed for non-orthodox emitters. A spreadsheet for implementing the test is provided.
Measured field electron emission (FE) current–voltage Im ( Vm ) data are traditionally analysed via Fowler–Nordheim (FN) plots, as versus 1/ Vm . These have been used since 1929, because in 1928 FN predicted they would be linear. In the 1950s, a mistake in FN's thinking was found. Corrected theory by Murphy and Good (MG) made theoretical FN plots slightly curved. This causes difficulties when attempting to extract precise values of emission characterization parameters from straight lines fitted to experimental FN plots. Improved mathematical understanding, from 2006 onwards, has now enabled a new FE data-plot form, the ‘Murphy–Good plot'. This plot has the form versus 1/ Vm , where η ≅ 9.836239 (eV/ ϕ ) 1/2 and ϕ is the local work function. Modern (twenty-first century) MG theory predicts that a theoretical MG plot should be ‘almost exactly' straight. This makes precise extraction of well-defined characterization parameters from ideal Im ( Vm ) data much easier. This article gives the theory needed to extract characterization parameters from MG plots, setting it within the framework of wider difficulties in interpreting FE Im ( Vm ) data (among them, use of ‘smooth planar emitter methodology'). Careful use of MG plots could also help remedy other problems in FE technological literature. It is suggested that MG plots should replace FN plots.
18 May 2011 in Proceedings of the Royal Society A: Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences
In field electron emission theory, evaluating the transmission coefficient DET for an exact triangular (ET) potential energy barrier is a paradigm problem. This paper derives a compact, exact, general analytical expression for DET , by means of an Airy function approach that uses a reflected barrier and puts the origin of coordinates at the electron's outer classical turning point. This approach has simpler mathematics than previous treatments. The expression derived applies to both tunnelling and ‘flyover’ (wave-mechanical transmission over the barrier), and is easily evaluated by computer algebra. The outcome is a unified theory of transmission across the ET barrier. In different ranges of relevant physical parameters, the expression yields different approximate formulae. For some ranges, no simple physical dependences exist. Ranges of validity for the most relevant formulae (including the Fowler–Nordheim 1928 formula for DET ) are explored, and a regime diagram constructed. Previous treatments are assessed and some discrepancies noted. Further approximations involved in deriving the Fowler–Nordheim 1928 equation for current density are stated. To assist testing of numerical procedures, benchmark values of DET are stated to six significant figures. This work may be helpful background for research into transmission across barriers for which no exact analytical theory yet exists.
Field electron emission (FE) has relevance in many technological contexts. However, many technological papers use a physically defective elementary FE equation for local emission current density (LECD). This equation takes the tunneling barrier as exactly triangular, as in the original FE theory 90 years ago. More than 60 years ago, it was shown that the Schottky-Nordheim (SN) barrier, which includes an image-potential-energy term (that models exchange-and-correlation effects), is better physics. For a metal-like emitter with a work function of 4.5 eV, the SN-barrier-related Murphy-Good FE equation predicts LECD values that are higher than the elementary equation values by a large factor, often between 250 and 500. By failing to mention/apply this 60-year-old established science or to inform readers of the large errors associated with the elementary equation, many papers (aided by inadequate reviewing) spread a new kind of “pathological science” and create a modern research-integrity problem. The present paper aims to enhance author and reviewer awareness by summarizing relevant aspects of the FE theory, by explicitly identifying the misjudgment in the original 1928 Fowler-Nordheim paper, by explicitly calculating the size of the resulting error, and by showing in detail why most FE theoreticians regard the 1950s modifications as better physics. Suggestions are made, about nomenclature and about citation practice, which may help diminish misunderstandings. It is emphasized that the correction recommended here is one of several needed to improve the presentation of theory in the FE literature and is only a first step toward higher-quality emission theory and improved methodology for current-voltage data interpretation.