The implosion of underwater composite structures is a critical and complex engineering problem, necessitating high-strength, lightweight, and corrosion-resistant materials for deep-sea applications. This manuscript reviews the intricate failure mechanisms of composite structures, focusing on cylindrical structures under extreme underwater conditions. The recent Titan submersible implosion serves as a case study, highlighting the significance of rigorous design considerations. Key topics include material degradation, buckling instability, and material failure, with a detailed analysis of composite layup optimization and manufacturing processes such as filament winding and roll wrapping. The manuscript underscores the need for comprehensive testing, advanced simulation techniques, and monitoring system integration to ensure the safety and effectiveness of composite pressure hulls. Future research should focus on developing more accurate failure models, optimizing manufacturing processes, and enhancing material properties through innovations in composite science to realize the full potential of composite materials in deep-sea applications.
8 September 2022 in Journal of Pressure Vessel Technology
Deep-sea structures will collapse/implode under hydrostatic pressure when the structure dives below an instability threshold, leading to catastrophic failure. To better understand how the layup angle of composite cylindrical shells influences this instability threshold, this work explores how composite cylinders can achieve the highest (optimum) critical collapse pressure under hydrostatic loading conditions. To perform this analysis, a closed-form analytical cylinder buckling solution developed by previous work is used in conjunction with different cylindrical geometrical configurations and composite properties for glass, carbon, and intraply hybrid composite properties for woven and unidirectional structures. The results show that a composite structure's optimum layup configuration is unique to the structure's geometry and material system. However, general trends are observed for these different systems, such as how symmetric and asymmetric constructions place the axial-resistant layers near the neutral plane of the composite system. In addition, both constructions need an increase in shear-resistance layers as the L/D ratio decreases regardless of the material system. Lastly, the analytical approach presented in this work can be used to accurately determine the optimum layup angle for thin composite cylindrical structures that are subjected to external hydrostatic pressure.
An experimental study was performed to analyze the dynamic buckling behavior of stiffened composite tubes. The structures analyzed were filament-wound carbon-fiber/epoxy composite tubes with press-fitted compliant and rigid aluminum ring stiffeners. The ring thicknesses were chosen for a consistent buckling pressure for equally spaced one, two, and three compliant stiffener configurations. The composite structures were submerged inside a pressure vessel and then subjected to increasing hydrostatic pressure until buckle initiation. High-speed photography and Digital Image Correlation were used to acquire full-field displacements and velocities of the collapse event. In addition, piezoelectric transducers were used to concurrently record the local dynamic pressure histories along the length of the tube. The results show that increasing the number of stiffeners for the same collapse pressure decreases the overall energy emission from the implosion event by more than 16%. However, the energy mitigation effects are also influenced by the location of the stiffeners in relation to the buckling initiation point.
Experiments were conducted to investigate the dynamic buckling behavior of underwater hybrid composite tubes. The study focused on roll-wrapped hybrid layered glass-carbon fiber epoxy composite shells with a six-layer quasi-isotropic layup configuration. In addition to control specimens consisting of fully glass fiber-reinforced polymer and carbon fiber-reinforced polymer, four different hybrid layup patterns were examined. These specimens fitted with custom endcaps were placed inside a 7-kiloliter pressure vessel and subjected to increasing hydrostatic pressure until dynamic implosion occurred. High-speed cameras captured the failure event, and the resulting images were analyzed using Digital Image Correlation (DIC) techniques to obtain full-field displacement data. Additionally, tourmaline pressure transducers positioned around the specimens recorded local dynamic pressure histories. The results revealed that the contribution of each ply location varied in the overall failure behavior of the structures. The thickness of the internal plies played a dominant role in enhancing the structural performance, while the stiffness of the outer plies greatly influenced the bending stiffness. The energy released during the collapse was highly dependent on the failure mechanism of the internal plies. Specifically, for the considered geometries, tubes with glass fiber internal plies exhibited significantly lower energy emissions compared to carbon fiber inner plies.