Protected and conserved areas (PCAs) are increasingly recognized as essential tools for their effectiveness in conservation and the benefits they provide. However, their challenges are still significant. The concepts, legislation, and governance surrounding PCAs are the results of social contexts. Due to the evolution of scientific knowledge, human rights, and diversified demands, new approaches are necessary to fulfill their functions. To better understand the context and possibilities, a study group was established to evaluate the current research, exchange experiences, guide dialogues, and identify lessons from experiences. The core of the experiences and cases considered and the reflections developed focused on the Brazilian context. This article analyzes the collected information and reflections related to several themes associated with challenges. The results reinforce the importance of PCAs but warn about the limitations of current conservation strategies to respond to social actors’ expectations, the needs of the vulnerable social groups, and evolving demands. The complexity of PCA systems is evident in view of the multiplicity of interests, potential contributions, and possibilities for participatory arrangements. There is a need to improve management and governance conceptions to promote the reconnection between society and nature. Therefore, the concept of collaborative conservation is proposed as an instrumental approach to advance towards inclusive and effective conservation strategies.
Management councils of Protected Areas are an important tool to the exercise of social participation of individuals and groups struggling for social-environmental causes in Brazil’s democracy. This paper aims to integrate the main regulations guiding the social participation in Management Councils of Protected Areas in Brazil and the perception of managers and technicians in order to understand the process of elaboration of the rules, the behind the scenes, and negotiations. Our findings highlight that social participation has been formally ensured in many aspects, revealing democratic advancements in the field of Protected Areas management in Brazil. However, despite remarkable progress, many challenges remain, including aspects of representation, independency, level of influence, and sharing power in decision-making processes. The outcomes of participation are ongoing processes of learning and negotiation, which are reflected in the improvement of the legal arrangements analyzed.
30 November 2018 in Desenvolvimento e Meio Ambiente
Este artigo concentra-se na análise das reservas extrativistas, em especial as reservas extrativistas marinhas, instrumento de cogestão criado no Brasil a partir dos conflitos que envolveram variáveis de pobreza e conservação do ambiente natural e que, inicialmente concebidas para ambiente florestal, foram ampliadas para outros ecossistemas. Como alternativa aos modelos restritivos de conservação importados do primeiro mundo, a concepção de reservas extrativistas, em sua gênese, dirige-se ao atendimento simultâneo de princípios de qualidade social e ambiental. No entanto, em que pese o fato desse tipo de área protegida proporcionar múltiplas possibilidades de inserção social e oportunidades para a cogestão colaborativa e adaptativa de recursos naturais de uso comum (em especial os recursos pesqueiros), não se trata de uma panaceia. Existem muitas variáveis que devem ser consideradas em sua criação e implantação, em especial o entendimento das populações beneficiadas sobre direitos e responsabilidades da gestão compartilhada. O objetivo do artigo é refletir sobre algumas perspectivas desse instituto que tem vinte de oito anos de existência, mas que ainda oferece dúvidas sobre a utilização sustentável dos recursos do mar e reais benefícios para as comunidades costeiras.
1 July 2018 in Ethnoscientia - Brazilian Journal of Ethnobiology and Ethnoecology