The capture and killing of free-living small cetaceans in the Faroe Islands is described. After being driven on-shore by motor vessels, the animals are killed without pre-stunning using officially-prescribed methods that involve severing the spinal cord and the associated blood vessels using a long-handled lance. The claim that this induces near instantaneous unconsciousness and death lacks supporting evidence: it is believed that the animals are simply paralyzed, not immediately rendered unconscious. The cervical and spinal arterial circulation of cetaceans differs from that of terrestrial mammals and it is likely the spinal lance does not completely destroy the supply of oxygenated blood to the brain. In conclusion, the entire process from driving the animals onto the shore, to restraint and to killing stranded cetaceans is very likely to be detrimental to their welfare. Detailed studies would be necessary to determine the veracity of the claimed efficacy of the process. A bespoke humane killer may improve welfare at the time of killing but its development is considered challenging.
Drive hunts in the Faroes and Japan typically involve prolonged herding of cetaceans (over hours or even days) into shallow water, forced stranding, restraint and killing using a spinal lance and exsanguination. These methods raise significant animal welfare concerns. This study applies the Five Domains Model to the Faroe Islands’ grindadráp hunt to consider potential welfare implications and associated affective states. We examined published hunting guidelines and divided the hunt into six stages. Each author independently summarized potential impacts within the Five Domains Model; subsequent group consensus via online meetings assigned likely welfare impacts and affective states. Demonstrable welfare impacts and negative affective states were identified for each grindadráp stage. The prolonged chase, forced stranding, capture and restraint probably cause chronic and acute physiological stress. The spinal lance may not render animals instantaneously unconscious, raising substantial concerns that some animals may remain aware during exsanguination. Commonly inferred affective states for each domain included: pain, anxiety, disorientation, fear and panic. Given the inherent constraints of the hunt, it is unlikely that grindadráp can be undertaken humanely. If the hunt is to continue, substantial reform would be necessary to minimize animal suffering and align with welfare standards applicable to mammals in food production or research.
Drive hunts in the Faroes and Japan typically involve prolonged herding of cetaceans into shallow water, forced stranding, restraint and killing using a spinal lance and exsanguination. These methods raise significant animal welfare concerns. This study applies the Five Domains Model to the Faroe Islands’ Grindadráp hunt to consider potential welfare divided the hunt into six stages. Each author independently summarised potential impacts within the Five Domains Model; subsequent group consensus via online meetings assigned likely welfare impacts and affective states. Demonstrable welfare impacts and negative implications and associated affective states. We examined published hunting guidelines and affective states were identified for each Grindadráp stage. The prolonged chase, forced stranding, capture and restraint likely cause chronic and acute physiological stress. The spinal lance may not render animals instantaneously unconscious, raising substantial concerns that some animals may remain aware during exsanguination. Commonly inferred affective states for each domain included: pain, anxiety, disorientation, fear and panic. Given the inherent constraints of the hunt, it is unlikely that the Grindadráp can be undertaken humanely. If the hunt is to continue, substantial reform would be necessary to minimise animal suffering and align with welfare standards applicable to mammals in food production or research.