Do people routinely pre-activate the meaning and even the phonological form of upcoming words? The most acclaimed evidence for phonological prediction comes from a 2005 Nature Neuroscience publication by DeLong, Urbach and Kutas, who observed a graded modulation of electrical brain potentials (N400) to nouns and preceding articles by the probability that people use a word to continue the sentence fragment (‘cloze’). In our direct replication study spanning 9 laboratories (N=334), pre-registered replication-analyses and exploratory Bayes factor analyses successfully replicated the noun-results but, crucially, not the article-results. Pre-registered single-trial analyses also yielded a statistically significant effect for the nouns but not the articles. Exploratory Bayesian single-trial analyses showed that the article-effect may be non-zero but is likely far smaller than originally reported and too small to observe without very large sample sizes. Our results do not support the view that readers routinely pre-activate the phonological form of predictable words.
Facilitation of general cognitive capacities such as executive functions through training has stirred considerable research interest during the last decade. Recently we demonstrated that training of auditory attention with forced attention dichotic listening not only facilitated that performance but also generalized to an untrained attentional task. In the present study, 13 participants underwent a 4-week dichotic listening training programme with instructions to report syllables presented to the left ear (FL training group). Another group (n = 13) was trained using the non-forced instruction, asked to report whichever syllable they heard the best (NF training group). The study aimed to replicate our previous behavioural results, and to explore the neurophysiological correlates of training through event-related brain potentials (ERPs). We partially replicated our previous behavioural training effects, as the FL training group tended to show more allocation of auditory spatial attention to the left ear in a standard dichotic listening task. ERP measures showed diminished N1 and enhanced P2 responses to dichotic stimuli after training in both groups, interpreted as improvement in early perceptual processing of the stimuli. Additionally, enhanced anterior N2 amplitudes were found after training, with relatively larger changes in the FL training group in the forced-left condition, suggesting improved top-down control on the trained task. These results show that top-down cognitive training can modulate the left-right allocation of auditory spatial attention, accompanied by a change in an evoked brain potential related to cognitive control.
17 May 2016 in International Journal of Language & Communication Disorders
The Dysarthria-in-Interaction Profile's potential contribution to the clinical assessment of dysarthria-in-conversation has been outlined in the literature, but its consistency of use across different users has yet to be reported. To establish the level of consistency across raters on four different interaction categories. That is, how reliable clinicians are when rating a series of videos. A secondary aim was to investigate the relationship between raters' estimates of dysarthric speech intelligibility and their rating of each dyad's overall interaction. Ten UK speech and language therapists rated independently a series of 40 video samples featuring people with progressive dysarthria in conversation with family members. An equal number of video samples was selected from a collection of recordings featuring four different types of interactional relationship. The results show that practising speech and language therapists can rate consistently, and with a high degree of agreement, a series of everyday conversation videos featuring dyads with progressive dysarthria and presenting at different interaction levels. The results also indicate that speech intelligibility does not predict the level of impairment in the interaction in a systematic way suggesting that conversation contains elements that are not directly related to speech intelligibility. Further work is required to establish the clinical functionality of this tool, but the results presented here support the development of this conversation profiling system, particularly for people experiencing significant intelligibility problems but remaining highly interactive/communicative.
This study compared cortical responses to speech in preschoolers with typical language development (TLD) and with Developmental Language Disorder (DLD). We investigated whether top-down language effects modulate speech perception in young children in an adult-like manner. We compared cortical mismatch responses (MMRs) during the passive perception of speech contrasts in three groups of participants: preschoolers with TLD (n = 11), preschoolers with DLD (n = 16), and adults (n = 20). We also measured children’s phonological skills and investigated whether they are associated with the cortical discrimination of phonemic changes involving different linguistic complexities. The results indicated top-down language effects in adults, with enhanced cortical discrimination of lexical stimuli but not of non-words. In preschoolers, the TLD and DLD groups did not differ in the MMR measures, and no top-down effects were detected. Moreover, we found no association between MMRs and phonological skills, even though the DLD group’s phonological skills were significantly lower. Our findings suggest that top-down language modulations in speech discrimination may not be present during early childhood, and that children with DLD may not exhibit cortical speech perception deficits. The lack of association between phonological and MMR measures indicates that further research is needed to understand the link between language skills and cortical activity in preschoolers.
Communication naturally occurs in dynamic face-to-face environments where spoken words are embedded in linguistic discourse and accompanied by multimodal cues. Existing research supports predictive brain models where prior discourse but also prosody, mouth movements, and hand-gestures individually contribute to comprehension. In electroencephalography (EEG) studies, more predictable words show reduced negativity, peaking at approximately 400ms after onset of the word (N400). Meaningful gestures and prosody also reduce the N400, while the effects of rhythmic gestures and mouth movements remain unclear. However, these studies have only focused on individual cues while in the real world, communicative cues co-occur and potentially interact. We measured EEG elicited by words while participants watched videos of a speaker producing short naturalistic passages. For each word, we quantified the information carried by prior linguistic discourse (surprisal), prosody (mean pitch), mouth informativeness (lip-reading), and presence of meaningful and/or rhythmic gestures. Discourse predictability reduced the N400 amplitude and multimodal cues impacted and interacted with this effect. Specifically, higher pitch and meaningful gestures reduced N400 amplitude, beyond the effect of discourse, while rhythmic gestures increased the N400 amplitude. Moreover, higher pitch overall reduced N400 amplitude while informative mouth movements only showed effects when no gestures were present. These results can constrain existing predictive brain models in that they demonstrate that the brain uses cues selectively in a dynamic and contextually determined manner in real-world language comprehension. Significance Statement Language originated, is learnt and is mostly used in face-to-face contexts comprising linguistic information and multimodal cues such as intonation of the speech, meaningful/rhythmic hand gestures and mouth movements. Yet, the rich multimodal context of real-world language use is usually stripped away in language studies. Here, we developed quantifications of the visual and acoustic non-linguistic cues accompanying speech and we investigate how, jointly, the cues shape brain activity. We find that the brain activity associated with processing is always modulated by the multimodal non-linguistic cues and their interactions. Thus, this work questions the validity of language comprehension models only based on speech. It further presents new methods for the study of real-world language.