Background: Prior research reported that motivational beliefs that individuals attach to specific tasks predict continuing interest and persistence in the task. A motivational approach may be particularly useful for understanding undergraduate students’ engagement with research in their first and second years in college. The current study utilizes the expectancy-value theory of achievement motivation to qualitatively explore how much and in what ways early year undergraduate researchers value their research experience and what kinds of costs they associate with it. Results: The results revealed that intrinsic value had the highest expression in participants’ motivation to engage in research. The second most expressed value type was the utility value of undergraduate research with regards to obtaining the desired outcomes, and attainment value played the least important role in participants’ motivation to engage in research. Findings also indicated that some of the participants associated a cost(s) to their research experience. The highest mentioned perceived cost was opportunity cost, where participants commented on losing other valued alternatives when engaging in research. Participants commented on the time, effort, or amount of work needed to engage in research, and a few participants commented on the emotional cost associated with their research experience in terms of the fear of failure. Conclusion: As perceived cost is the least studied in the expectancy-value framework, this study contributes to cost values within college students, particularly about early year undergraduate researchers. The findings of this study can form the basis for future work on exploring ways to increase the values and decrease the costs students experience in their undergraduate research experiences.
29 April 2015 in International Journal of STEM Education
This auto-ethnographic study describes research conducted in a science teacher education program at a state university in Turkey, where I had taught the ‘laboratory applications’ course for the four previous years. While the students learned the basic skills needed to implement a laboratory course, I detected some deficiencies in their understanding of scientific practices. Consequently, I decided to adopt a different approach. In the fall of 2013 to 2014, I participated in a project aimed at improving pre-service science teachers’ understanding of scientific practices (SPs) using a model known as the Benzene Ring Heuristic (Erduran and Dagher 2014).
This study investigated undergraduate researchers’ perspectives on mentoring structures and the support provided to them in their first and sophomore years. Participants reported receiving different types of support from faculty and postgraduates depending on their mentoring structures and the amount of research experience they gained.
1 April 2021 in Journal of Science Teacher Education
A common practice amongst scientists is to evaluate the connections between evidence and claims about natural and human-induced phenomena. Teacher education coursework may improve understanding of this important activity and facilitate teachers to implement evidential thinking approaches into their future science teaching. Instructional scaffolds that actively engage students in scientific evaluation can be introduced in teacher education programs to increase pre-service teachers’ understanding of critical evaluation as a scientific practice. The purpose of this qualitative exploratory study was to investigate pre-service science teachers’ critical evaluation and decision-making practices using scientific evidence to consider competing, alternative explanations about controversial phenomena (genetically modified organisms and climate change). In this context, we analyzed pre-service science teachers’ evaluations about the connections between scientific evidence and alternative explanations, as well as their decision-making practices by examining their certainty and plausibility judgments. Our findings indicated that participants’ associations between evidence and explanatory models, their evaluative reasoning practices, and the correctness and complexity of their evaluations revealed variations in both topics. The participants’ evaluation and decision-making practices also showed disputes with their plausibility judgments about alternative explanations, as well as the certainty of their evaluations. The findings were discussed in the light of the literature and suggested that critical evaluation is a scientific practice that should be explicitly taught in teacher education programs to increase pre-service science teachers’ engagement and understanding of evidence-based decision-making practices.
18 September 2019 in International Journal of Higher Education
The Strategic Undergraduate STEM Talent Acceleration INitiative (SUSTAIN) provided a coherent ecosystem of academic, social, and career support services designed for a diverse cohort of high-achieving, low-income STEM students during their first year of undergraduate study. Findings are discussed in terms of the efficacy of the program interventions to enhance students’ socialization and retention within the STEM community. Results indicate that participants perceived the interventions to have helped them adjust to college life and develop skills in understanding science and the scientific process. Which in turn, participants reported, helped them to succeed in their STEM courses and visualize themselves as part of the larger STEM community. The participants rated STEM faculty mentoring, research experience and community building as more helpful than other interventions. Our findings will aid researchers to better understand how SUSTAIN interventions influence students’ socialization into the STEM community and provide valuable insight to guide policymakers in shaping future programs that are successful in retaining diverse students in STEM fields.