We discuss the violation of quark-flavor symmetry at high temperatures, induced from nonperturbative thermal loop corrections and axial anomaly, based on a three-flavor linear-sigma model including an flavor violation induced by anomaly which we call an axial-anomaly induced-flavor breaking term. We employ a nonperturbative analysis following the Cornwall-Jackiw-Tomboulis formalism, and show that the model undergoes a chiral crossover with a pseudocritical temperature, consistently with lattice observations. We find following features regarding the flavor breaking eminent around and above the pseudocritical temperature: (i) up-and down-quark condensates drop faster than the strange quark’s toward the criticality, but still keep nonzero value even going far above the critical temperature; (ii) the introduced anomaly-related flavor-breaking effect acts as a catalyzer toward the chiral restoration, and reduces the amount of flavor breaking in the up, down and strange quark condensates; (iii) a dramatic deformation for the meson flavor mixing structure is observed, in which the anomaly-induced favor breaking is found to be almost irrelevant; (iv) the meson spectroscopy gets corrected by the net nonperturbative flavor breaking effects, where the scalar meson mass hierarchy (inverse mass hierarchy) is significantly altered by the presence of the anomaly-related flavor breaking; (v) the topological susceptibility significantly gets the contribution from the surviving strange quark condensate, which cannot be dictated by the chiral perturbation theory, and deviates from the dilute instanton gas prediction. There the anomaly-induced flavor breaking plays a role of the destructive interference for the net flavor violation, as in the flavor breaking in the quark condensates; (vi) the breaking signaled by nonzero topological susceptibility is enhanced by the nonperturbative strange quark condensate, which may account for the tension in the effective restoration of the symmetry currently observed on lattices with two flavors and flavors near the chiral limit. Our founding critical natures can be checked in the future lattice simulations, and will give some implications to the thermal history of QCD axion.
We find that the chiral phase transition (chiral crossover) in QCD at a physical point is triggered by a big imbalance among three fundamental quantities essential for the QCD vacuum structure; susceptibility functions for the chiral symmetry, axial symmetry, and the topological charge. The balance, dobbed the QCD trilemma, is unavoidably violated when one of the magnitudes among them is highly dominated, or suppressed. Based on a three-flavor Nambu-Jona-Lasinio model, we explicitly evaluate the amount of violation of the QCD trilemma at a physical point, and show that the violation takes place not only at vacuum, but even in a whole temperature regime including the chiral-crossover epoch. This work confirms and extends the suggestion recently reported from lattice QCD with two flavors on the dominance of the axial and topological susceptibilities left in the chiral susceptibility at high temperatures. It turns out that the imbalance is essentially due to the flavor symmetry violation of the lightest three flavors, and the flavor breaking specifically brings enhancement of the axial anomaly contribution in the chiral-order parameter, while the strength of the axial breaking and the transition rate of the topological charge are fairly insensitive to the flavor symmetry. The violation of the QCD trilemma and its flavor dependence can be tested by lattice simulations with flavors in the future, and would also give a new guiding principle to explore the flavor dependence of the chiral phase transition, such as the Columbia plot, including a possible extension with external fields.
We explore the topological susceptibility at finite quark chemical potential and zero temperature in two-color QCD (QC2D) with two flavors. Through the Ward-Takahashi identities of QC2D, we find that the topological susceptibility in the vacuum solely depends on three observables: the pion decay constant, the pion mass, and the η mass in the low-energy regime of QC2D. Based on the identities, we numerically evaluate the topological susceptibility at finite quark chemical potential using the linear sigma model with the approximate Pauli-Gursey SU(4) symmetry. Our findings indicate that, in the absence of U(1)A anomaly effects represented by the Kobayashi-Maskawa-’t Hooft-type determinant interaction, the topological susceptibility vanishes in both the hadronic and baryon superfluid phases. On the other hand, when the U(1)A anomaly effects are present, the constant and nonzero topological susceptibility is induced in the hadronic phase, reflecting the mass difference between the pion and η meson. Meanwhile, in the superfluid phase it begins to decrease smoothly. The asymptotic behavior of the decrement is fitted by the continuous reduction of the chiral condensate in dense QC2D, which is similar to the behavior observed in hot three-color QCD matter. In addition, effects from the finite diquark source on the topological susceptibility are discussed. We expect that the present study provides a clue to shed light on the role of the U(1)A anomaly in cold and dense QCD matter.
Recently, the peak structure of the sound velocity was observed in the lattice simulation of two-color and two-flavor QCD at the finite quark chemical potential. The comparison with the chiral perturbation theory (ChPT) result was undertaken; however, the ChPT failed in reproducing the peak structure. In this study, to extend the ChPT framework, we incorporate contributions of the meson, that is identified as the chiral partner of pions, on top of the low-energy pion dynamics by using the linear sigma model (LSM). Based on the LSM, we derive analytic expressions of the thermodynamic quantities as well as the sound velocity within a mean-field approximation. As a result, we find that those quantities are provided by sums of the ChPT results and corrections, where the latter is characterized by a mass difference between the chiral partners, the meson and pion. The chiral partner contributions are found to yield a peak in the sound velocity successfully. We furthermore show that the sound velocity peak emerges only when and , with and being the meson (pion) mass and the quark chemical potential, respectively. The correlation between the sound velocity peak and the sign of the trace anomaly is also addressed.