We present a novel global 3D coronal MHD model called COCONUT, polytropic in its first stage and based on a time-implicit backward Euler scheme. Our model boosts run-time performance in comparison with contemporary MHD-solvers based on explicit schemes, which is particularly important when later employed in an operational setting for space-weather forecasting. It is data-driven in the sense that we use synoptic maps as inner boundary inputs for our potential-field initialization as well as an inner boundary condition in the further MHD time evolution. The coronal model is developed as part of the EUropean Heliospheric FORecasting Information Asset (EUHFORIA) and will replace the currently employed, more simplistic, empirical Wang–Sheeley–Arge (WSA) model. At 21.5 R⊙ where the solar wind is already supersonic, it is coupled to EUHFORIA’s heliospheric model. We validate and benchmark our coronal simulation results with the explicit-scheme Wind-Predict model and find good agreement for idealized limit cases as well as real magnetograms, while obtaining a computational time reduction of up to a factor 3 for simple idealized cases, and up to 35 for realistic configurations, and we demonstrate that the time gained increases with the spatial resolution of the input synoptic map. We also use observations to constrain the model and show that it recovers relevant features such as the position and shape of the streamers (by comparison with eclipse white-light images), the coronal holes (by comparison with EUV images), and the current sheet (by comparison with WSA model at 0.1 au).
This paper is dedicated to the new implicit unstructured coronal code COCONUT, which aims at providing fast and accurate inputs for space-weather forecasting as an alternative to empirical models. We use all 20 available magnetic maps of the solar photosphere covering the date of 2019 July 2, which corresponds to a solar eclipse on Earth. We use the same standard preprocessing on all maps, then perform coronal MHD simulations with the same numerical and physical parameters. We conclude by quantifying the performance of each map using three indicators from remote-sensing observations: white-light total solar eclipse images for the streamers’ edges, EUV synoptic maps for coronal holes, and white-light coronagraph images for the heliospheric current sheet. We discuss the performance of space-weather forecasting and show that the choice of the input magnetic map has a strong impact. We find performances between 24% and 85% for the streamers’ edges, 24%–88% for the coronal hole boundaries, and a mean deviation between 4° and 12° for the heliospheric current sheet position. We find that the HMI runs perform better on all indicators, with GONG-ADAPT being the second-best choice. HMI runs perform better for the streamers’ edges, and GONG-ADAPT for polar coronal holes, HMI synchronic for equatorial coronal holes, and the streamer belt. We especially illustrate the importance of the filling of the poles. This demonstrates that the solar poles have to be taken into account even for ecliptic plane previsions.
We developed a novel global coronal COCONUT (Coolfluid Corona Unstructured) model based on the COOLFluiD code. The steady-state model is predetermined by magnetograms set as boundary conditions, while inside the numerical domain the corona is described by MHD equations. This set of equations is solved with the use of an implicit solver on unstructured grids. Here we present numerically obtained results for two extremes of the solar activity cycle represented by CR 2161 and CR 2219 for solar maximum and minimum, respectively. We discuss the impact of reconstruction level on representative solar corona solutions and thus also the impact of small magnetic structures on the overall structure of the solar wind. Moreover, both cases correspond to particular solar eclipses, namely those in 2015 March and 2019 July, to allow us the direct comparison of simulations with observed coronal features. We use a validation scheme proposed by Wagner et al. (from less to more sophisticated methods, i.e., visual classification, feature matching, streamer direction and width, brute force matching, topology classification). The detailed comparison with observations reveals that our model recreates relevant features such as the position, direction, and shape of the streamers (by comparison with white-light images) and the coronal holes (by comparison with extreme ultraviolet images) for both cases of minimum and maximum solar activity. We conclude that an unprecedented combination of accuracy, computational speed and robustness even in the case of maximum activity is accomplished at this stage, with possible further improvements in a foreseeable perspective.
Magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) simulations of the solar corona have become more popular with the increased availability of computational power. Modern computational plasma codes, relying upon computational fluid dynamics (CFD) methods, allow the coronal features to be resolved using solar surface magnetograms as inputs. These computations are carried out in a full three-dimensional domain and, thus, selection of the correct mesh configuration is essential to save computational resources and enable/speed up convergence. In addition, it has been observed that for MHD simulations close to the hydrostatic equilibrium, spurious numerical artefacts might appear in the solution following the mesh structure, which makes the selection of the grid also a concern for accuracy. The purpose of this paper is to discuss and trade off two main mesh topologies when applied to global solar corona simulations using the unstructured ideal MHD solver from the COOLFluiD platform. The first topology is based on the geodesic polyhedron and the second on $UV$ mapping. Focus is placed on aspects such as mesh adaptability, resolution distribution, resulting spurious numerical fluxes and convergence performance. For this purpose, first a rotating dipole case is investigated, followed by two simulations using real magnetograms from the solar minima (1995) and solar maxima (1999). It is concluded that the most appropriate mesh topology for the simulation depends on several factors, such as the accuracy requirements, the presence of features near the polar regions and/or strong features in the flow field in general. If convergence is of concern and the simulation contains strong dynamics, then grids which are based on the geodesic polyhedron are recommended compared with more conventionally used $UV$ -mapped meshes.
Context.The text has been edited to adhere to American English based on the spelling style used in the text. In order to anticipate the geoeffectiveness of coronal mass ejections (CMEs), heliospheric simulations are used to propagate transient structures injected at 0.1 AU. Without direct measurements near the Sun, the properties of these injected CMEs must be derived from models coming from observations or numerical simulations, and thus they contain a lot of uncertainty.Aims.The aim of this paper is to demonstrate the possible use of the new coronal model COCONUT to compute a detailed representation of a numerical CME at 0.1 AU after its injection at the solar surface and propagation in a realistic solar wind, as derived from observed magnetograms.Methods.We present the implementation and propagation of modified Titov-Démoulin flux ropes in the COCONUT 3D magnetohydrodynamics coronal model. Background solar wind was reconstructed in order to model two opposite configurations representing a solar activity maximum and minimum, respectively. Both configurations were derived from magnetograms that were obtained by the Helioseismic and Magnetic Imager on board the Solar Dynamic Observatory satellite. We tracked the propagation of 24 flux ropes that differ only by their initial magnetic flux. In particular, we investigated the geometry of the flux ropes during the early stages of their propagation as well as the influence of their initial parameters and solar wind configuration on 1D profiles derived at 0.1 AU.Results.At the beginning of the propagation, the shape of the flux ropes varied between simulations during low and high solar activity. We found dynamics that are consistent with the standard CME model, such as pinching of the CME legs and the appearance of post-flare loops. Despite the differences in geometry, the synthetic density and magnetic field time profiles at 0.1 AU are very similar in both solar wind configurations. These profiles are also similar to those observed further in the heliosphere and suggest the presence of a magnetic ejecta composed of the initially implemented flux rope and a sheath ahead of it. Finally, we uncovered relationships between the properties of the magnetic ejecta, such as relationships between density or speed and the initial magnetic flux of our flux ropes.Conclusions.The implementation of the modified Titov-Démoulin flux rope in COCONUT enables us to retrieve the major properties of CMEs at 0.1 AU for any phase of the solar cycle. When combined with heliospheric simulations, COCONUT could lead to more realistic and self-consistent CME evolution models and thus more reliable predictions.
1 November 2022 in The Astrophysical Journal Supplement Series
In recent years, global coronal models have experienced an ongoing increase in popularity as tools for forecasting solar weather. Within the domain of up to 21.5 R⊙, magnetohydrodynamics (MHD) is used to resolve the coronal structure using magnetograms as inputs at the solar surface. Ideally, these computations would be repeated with every update of the solar magnetogram so that they could be used in the ESA Modeling and Data Analysis Working Group magnetic connectivity tool (http://connect-tool.irap.omp.eu/). Thus, it is crucial that these results are both accurate and efficient. While much work has been published showing the results of these models in comparison with observations, not much of it discusses the intricate numerical adjustments required to achieve these results. These range from the details of boundary condition formulations to adjustments as large as enforcing parallelism between the magnetic field and velocity. By omitting the electric field in ideal MHD, the description of the physics can be insufficient and may lead to excessive diffusion and incorrect profiles. We formulate inner boundary conditions that, along with other techniques, reduce artificial electric field generation. Moreover, we investigate how different outer boundary condition formulations and grid design affect the results and convergence, with special focus on the density and radial component of the B-field. The significant improvement in accuracy of real magnetic map–driven simulations is illustrated for an example of the 2008 eclipse.