When an invasive species first breaches quarantine and establishes in yet another country, it invariably causes consternation for growers, in part because of incomplete understanding of the plants that are at risk. The Fall Armyworm, Spodoptera frugiperda (J.E. Smith) is the most recent example in Australia. The number of plants that this polyphagous noctuid is reported to attack is vast, including many crop species. Consequently, initial reactions from grower industry groups that perceived themselves at risk were to demand emergency use of insecticides. Yet the field evidence suggests that many crops might not be at risk and since S. frugiperda arrived in Australia, maize crops have suffered most damage, followed by sorghum. We question the accuracy of some of the claims of reported host plants of S. frugiperda and report experiments that compared oviposition behavior, neonate silking behavior, and larval performance on five crops: the known hosts maize and sorghum, and the putative hosts cotton, peanut, and pigeon pea. Maize ranked highest in all preference and performance measures, followed by sorghum and peanut, with pigeon pea and cotton ranking lowest. Although S. frugiperda can survive, develop, and pupate on the crop species we examined, cotton and pigeon pea are not preferred by the pest in either the larval or adult stages. We suggest that before a plant is listed as a host for a given insect that the evidence should be fully reported and carefully evaluated. Collecting an immature insect from a plant does not make that plant a host!
Pigeonpea is one of the world's most important grain legume crops. Mostly grown and consumed in India, where it is a staple food, pigeonpea production also occurs elsewhere in Asia, Africa, Latin America and Australia. Despite widespread cultivation and staple food status, pigeonpea yields have barely increased over the last half century. The prevalence and severity of insect pests present major constraints to increasing pigeonpea yields. Two of the most significant pests of pigeonpea are the lepidopteran ‘pod‐borers’–Helicoverpa armigera and Maruca vitrata. The pod fly (Melanagromyza obtusa) and several species of pod‐feeding Hemiptera are also regular pests, and numerous other minor or sporadic pests have been recorded throughout the cultivated distribution of the crop. Current pigeonpea pest management practices rely heavily on the application of synthetic insecticides. Most research has focused on the management of H. armigera, M. vitrata and M. obtusa due to their damaging feeding behaviour, and the propensity of H. armigera to evolve resistance to synthetic insecticides. Not surprisingly, pest management in pigeonpea is largely based around these three major pests, particularly the lepidopteran pod‐borers which appear to be more damaging to modern short‐duration cultivars than to older cultivars. A large amount of research has attempted to develop pigeonpea cultivars with conventional host‐plant resistance to pod‐borers and pod fly, but with limited success. Future pigeonpea pest management research should take a more integrated approach, exploring underexamined areas such as: understanding how modern pigeonpea varieties and traditional landraces respond to pest herbivory, identifying what cultural control methods are available to smallholder farmers, and investigating how biological control can be incorporated into management practices. Future research has the potential to develop IPM strategies in pigeonpea and provide farmers with an alternative to an unsustainable dependence on synthetic insecticides.