This study investigated the public acceptance of drones in six European countries. For this purpose, an online questionnaire was created, which was completed by 2998 participants. The general attitude towards drones, concerns, approval for different use cases, minimum tolerable flight altitude, acceptable flight areas, and the impact of personal and demographic attributes on drone acceptance were analyzed. Overall, attitudes towards drones were quite positive in the entire sample and even improved slightly in a second measurement at the end of the questionnaire. However, the results also show that acceptance strongly depends on the use case. Drones for civil and public applications are more widely accepted than those for private and commercial applications. Moreover, the population still has high concerns about privacy and safety. Knowledge about drones, interest in technologies, and age proved essential to predicting acceptance. Thus, tailored communication strategies, for example, through social media, can enhance public awareness and acceptance.
Drones may play an essential role in future traffic. As with every innovation, not only is the technical maturity decisive for its success, but also whether the general public will accept it. This paper uses a mixed-method approach combining quantitative and qualitative methods to investigate social acceptance concerning drones. The study included 20 participants and comprised a virtual simulation, a team task, and a group discussion. This way, different aspects of drone acceptance were investigated. On the one hand, a simulative approach was tested to explore the visual perception of drone flights in an urban setting. On the other hand, the acceptance of various drone applications such as civil protection, parcel delivery, and air taxis was studied. Furthermore, this research identified requirements for coordinating and managing future drone traffic. This paper combines two acceptance models from the literature as a theoretical framework: an adoption of Chamata’s and Winterton’s Technical Acceptance Model by Krempel and the Unacceptability–Acceptance Scale by Hofinger.
The technology of unmanned aerial vehicles (i.e., civilian drones) continues to improve and concepts of operations are being developed. Against this background, the importance of public acceptance has grown and the number of studies on the subject has increased in recent years. In this context and as a follow-up to the study by Eißfeldt and colleagues (Eißfeldt et al. in CEAS Aeronaut. J. 11:665–676, 2020), a representative telephone survey on the acceptance of civilian drones in Germany was conducted at the end of 2022. In addition to re-evaluating the attitude towards civilian drones in general, the current study particularly examined the use case of air taxis. It was found that the attitude towards civilian drones tended to be slightly more positive than in the first study. For air taxis, attitudes were revealed to be relatively balanced, with a slight negative tendency. Moreover, extensive inferential statistical analyses showed several factors such as active experience with drones, general sensitivity to noise, and interest in environmental protection to be significantly associated with the attitudes towards civilian drones and air taxis. The application of three different prediction models revealed that a person’s attitude towards civilian drones could be predicted with up to 71% accuracy by drone-related concerns. In this context, concerns about the violation of privacy and animal welfare had the highest predictive value. In sum, the current study provides a comprehensive overview on the acceptance of civilian drones and air taxis in Germany. Its findings underline that citizens’ opinions and concerns must be considered when designing future air mobility concepts.
The acceptance of air taxi passengers is expected to be a relevant factor for the success of urban air mobility. The authors follow a user-centered design approach—which involves potential users as early as possible—to reach this goal. However, this requires a highly customizable simulation environment where different cabin arrangements and interface designs can be realized and evaluated quickly and cost-efficiently. At the same time, the experience must be immersive enough to give the users the feeling of a realistic flight. This article analyzes available mixed reality technologies and explains how these can be applied to create a simulator that fulfills these requirements. The focus is on head-mounted displays with video-see-through functionality, which allows the fusion of a customizable computer-generated world with a video stream of the real surroundings. The work includes the development of different approaches for the blending of real and virtual content as well as for the user interaction with mixed reality. The four resulting setups are then assessed in an experiment with twelve participants. Thereafter, the favored setup was improved and used for a human-in-the-loop study with 30 participants investigating passenger acceptance aspects of air taxi operations. Both studies confirm the usefulness of the mixed reality approach for the development of a future urban air mobility system. Regarding the various setups, users rated the completely virtual variant as the most immersive but favored the interaction with a physical input device over a virtual touch display. Further, the experiment emphasized the importance of precise alignment between real and virtual contents, which must be ensured by high-quality tracking systems and correct calibration of the video-see-through goggles.
This paper reports an explorative approach to research factors influencing how people experience urban drone traffic. The study used a virtual reality environment to show people what future drone traffic could look like. A total of ten people took part in the survey. They experienced different types of drones with varying purposes in four urban areas: an industrial area, a city center, a residential area, and a park. Various types of data were collected in the study, focusing on qualitative data from interviews. The goal was to collect a rich and comprehensive data set that thoroughly understands acceptance factors related to drones, recommendations on how future research scenarios in high-fidelity simulation should be designed, and which factors should be included or need more investigation. The findings reveal that drone acceptance is determined by a complex interaction of numerous factors, which need more investigation and validation in future research.
1 January 2024 in Proceedings of Meetings on Acoustics
In a telephone survey on the acceptance of civilian drones in Germany conducted at the end of 2022, a certain portion of the questions was dedicated to air taxi In a telephone survey on the acceptance of civilian drones in Germany conducted at the end of 2022, a certain portion of the questions was dedicated to air taxi