Background: Food Is Medicine (FIM) interventions are increasingly integrated into health care and community settings. Although FIM interventions show promise for improving diet and clinical outcomes, results have been mixed, and positive effects may attenuate over time. Digital nutrition and cooking mobile apps and web applications have emerged as part of FIM interventions and may help FIM participants apply nutrition education to develop meal-preparation skills. The GRACE (get a base, round with real produce and proteins, add aromatics, cook gently, and enhance with flavor to align with dietary guidance) Framework provides the foundation for integrating ways to create and adapt meals. The GRACE Kitchen progressive web application (PWA) prototype was designed to operationalize this framework. Objective: This study describes the development of the GRACE Framework, its translation into the GRACE Kitchen PWA prototype, and examines preliminary user feedback on the prototype. Methods: An iterative developmental design based on 2 separate pilots (Food Is Medicine Healing Together [FIM-HT] and Food Is Medicine for Black Breast Cancer Survivors [FIM-BCS]) was organized into 3 developmental stages. In stage 1, qualitative interviews (n=17) with participants with hypertension from a 12-week pilot FIM intervention (FIM-HT) were analyzed to identify facilitators and barriers to sustaining Dietary Approaches to Stop Hypertension (DASH)–aligned eating, including produce delivery and nutrition education. Themes elicited from the FIM-HT interviews informed the development of the GRACE Framework. In stage 2, the GRACE Framework was translated into the GRACE Kitchen prototype. In stage 3, breast cancer survivors (n=12) participated in an 8-week FIM pilot (FIM-BCS) and simultaneously underwent preliminary testing of GRACE Kitchen. User experiences were assessed using a modified Mobile App Usability Questionnaire and focus group data. Results: Across the 3 developmental stages, feedback from 29 participants contributed to the development of the GRACE Framework and the GRACE Kitchen prototype. During stage 1, initial conceptual ideas for the GRACE Framework were based on 3 themes identified in the FIM-HT interview data: Changes in Eating Behaviors, Challenges to Cooking, and the Maintenance of Healthy Cooking and Eating Behaviors. Participants emphasized finding new ways to incorporate vegetables, spices, and herbs; swapping in healthier ingredients; adapting recipes to their preferences; and navigating the challenges of meal preparation and cooking. In stage 2, this feedback informed the development of the GRACE Kitchen PWA. During PWA testing (stage 3), FIM-BCS participants (n=12) reported ease of use (2.70/4), satisfaction (2.67/4), and usefulness (2.71/4). The FIM-BCS participants also provided qualitative feedback indicating strong acceptability of GRACE Kitchen’s guidance on making meals easier to prepare. However, they found the interface challenging to use and preferred a more mobile-friendly, easier-to-navigate approach. Conclusions: Preliminary feedback suggests that GRACE Kitchen was perceived as moderately useful and highly acceptable, while also revealing important usability limitations. Although participants reported that the GRACE Framework was supportive, further evaluation is needed to determine whether GRACE Kitchen can help sustain dietary practices.