A Japanese national representative survey—the comprehensive survey of living conditions (CSLC)—included the Washington Group Short Set (WGSS) in 2022. This study aimed to characterize the WGSS in comparison to an existing disability measure (EDM), regarding the difference between disability prevalence defined by these two measures and the factors attributable to disagreements between them. A cross-sectional analysis using secondary data from the CSLC (n = 32,212) was conducted. The disability prevalences and their ratios (WGSS to EDM) were computed overall and by demographic sub-groups. Binomial logistic regression analyses were performed to explore factors relating to disagreements that functioned to relatively lower/increase the prevalence defined by the WGSS. Consequently, the prevalences defined by the WGSS and EDM were 10.7% (95% confidence interval (CI): 10.4–11.1) and 13.1% (95%CI: 12.7–13.5), respectively. The ratios by the sub-groups were around 0.80–0.90, with the exception of the age-defined sub-group, whose ratios were 0.63 (older sub-group) to 1.23 (child sub-group). Age was the only independent factor associated with two types of disagreements: older age (odds ratios: 1.23–1.80) was associated with disagreement functioning to relatively lower the prevalence defined by the WGSS, and similarly, younger age (ORs: 1.42–2.79) increased the figure. The WGSS may be characterized as being less susceptible to the influence of aging compared to the EDM.
Background Cancer information service (CIS) programmes are becoming increasingly important because patients need to obtain appropriate information and take an active role in their treatment decisions. Programme evaluation is required to determine the level of satisfaction and quality of experiences of users. The purpose of this study is (1) to identify users’ evaluation of CIS programmes by both satisfaction and outcomes that reflect the quality of experience and impact of using the CIS, (2) to examine the related factors of these evaluation outcomes and (3) to analyse the differences of those relations between patients and families. Method The self-reported questionnaire was answered by 447 patients and 216 families of patients who used Cancer Information Support Centres (CISCs) at 16 designated cancer hospitals from January 2016 to April 2016. We developed 12 evaluation items, including satisfaction, experience and the impact of using CISC. Results Respondents evaluated the CISC highly, especially in terms of overall satisfaction, followed by the counselling process. Immediate access to CISC was the strongest factor affecting outcomes. Patients who wanted to consult about ‘disease or symptoms’ or ‘had no specific problem’ tended to provide high scores for some outcomes, but those who wanted to consult about a ‘financial problem’ or ‘discharge or care at home’ provided negative scores. These trends were also observed in families but to a more limited extent. Conclusion Users’ evaluation of CISCs was sufficiently high in terms of overall satisfaction, showing reasonable scores in outcome levels. Immediate access was the strongest factor affecting outcomes and topics of consultation more directly affected evaluation by patients than by families. The distribution of the scores of the measures and related factors was reasonable. The 12-item measurement tool employed in this study seems to be useful for quality monitoring of the CIS.
Research on preventive healthcare services among people with disability in Japan is scarce. This study aimed to (1) examine the relationship between disability and the use of general health examination (GHE) and cancer screening (lung, gastric, colorectal, breast and cervical cancer) and (2) explore the reasons for not using GHE. This cross-sectional study used secondary data from individuals aged 20–74 years (n = 15,294) from the Comprehensive Survey of Living Conditions of 2016. Binomial logistic regression analysis was conducted to examine the relationship between disability and non-participation in preventive services. In addition, a descriptive analysis was conducted to explore the reasons for non-participation in GHE. Consequently, disability was identified as an independently associated factor for non-participation in GHE (odds ratios (OR): 1.73; 95% confidence interval (95%CI): 1.14–2.62) and screening for colorectal (OR: 1.78; 95%CI: 1.08–2.94), gastric (OR: 2.27; 95%CI: 1.27–4.05), cervical (OR: 2.12; 95%CI: 1.04–4.32) and breast cancer (OR: 2.22; 95%CI: 1.04–4.72), controlling for confounding factors. The most dominant reason for non-participation was “I can go to see the doctor anytime, if I am worried (25/54, 46.3%).” Our findings imply the existence of disability-based disparity in preventive healthcare service use in Japan.
6 March 2020 in Journal of Public Health Management & Practice
Under the recent trend of an increasing number of cancer survivors, there is a need to devise measures for visualization of medical care and public health programs related to cancer control, which will enable better overview of the activities at hospitals and local communities and allow various stakeholders to share the information about such activities. The aim of this study was to propose a new tool for proper implementation of cancer information and support programs provided under the national cancer control policy in Japan. Considering 5 elements reported by Handler et al (macro context, mission, structural capacity, processes, and outcomes), we conducted the focus group discussions to confirm the goals of activities of Cancer Information and Support Centers. Eventually, 2 final goals (“reduction in the number of patients/families having difficulties related to cancer” and “being able to live at ease even after diagnosis of cancer”) were identified, accompanied by 5 semifinal goals and 16 prerequisite conditions needed to achieve the final goals, as well as the necessary states and the activity indicators corresponding to them. This tool was utilized by 180 (42.7%) of 422 cancer care hospitals designated by the government of Japan (designated cancer care hospitals [DCCHs]) in 2016 and by 336 (77.1%) of 436 DCCHs in 2018, which were the data at 6 months and 3 years after introduction of the tool, respectively. Thus, the tool for evaluating the Cancer Information and Support Centers' activity presented here is expected to stimulate the stakeholders involved in providing supports in various fields of each local community, to share the final goals, to evaluate the status of their achievement, and to further advance their own activities.
Cancer Information and Support Centers (CISCs), which are set up at designated cancer care hospitals (DCCHs) according to the national cancer control programs in Japan, are expected to provide cancer patients and their families with information and counseling, but their public recognition remains low. Therefore, it is necessary to evaluate the publicity activities of CISCs. In this study, we evaluated two types of activities for publicizing CISCs conducted inside and outside one of the DCCHs ('Inside Activity' and 'Outside Activity', respectively) by multi-attribute utility technology (MAUT). Seven types of stakeholders, including physicians (n = 5), nurses (n = 4), CISC cancer counselors (n = 5), executives (n = 5), office department staff (n = 5), and licensed social insurance consultants in the hospital (n = 5), as well as patients and citizens (n = 19) were involved in the evaluation. Eight goals of the program for publicizing CISCs were determined. The utility score for each goal was separately calculated for Inside Activity and Outside Activity, and those of the eight goals were summed up to obtain an overall utility score for each activity. Finally, no substantial difference in overall utility score was found between the activity types (Inside Activity = 82.00 vs. Outside Activity = 81.18). It is implied that omitting or reducing either activity should be avoided in streamlining publicity activities at the CISCs. Despite the limited external validity of the finding, the methodology presented in this study is widely applicable to evaluate other multifaceted programs under an increasingly tight budget in the oncology setting. As the MAUT approach enables us to obtain numerical data for priority settings, it will contribute to rationalized healthcare management, especially in the oncology setting in which objective evaluations of the national cancer-related control programs are lacking and a broad range of stakeholders is involved.