Cities are becoming smarter in their functions; however, they are not necessarily resilient and able to survive the impact of disasters. An integrated, smart and resilient city is a quest for today and future sustainability that has been scarcely studied. Therefore, this current paper develops a comprehensive framework for re-evaluating cities’ smartness and assessing their resilience against unforeseen disruptive events. A top-down approach is adopted with an expert’s validation process and evaluated in a hypothetical city’s water supply system to demonstrate its workability. The study contributes towards a holistic framework that includes smartness re-evaluation and resilience assessment components that can be used to ensure the resiliency of smart cities from both developed and developing countries resisting disasters.
Resilience of water supply systems (WSS) needs improvements to better cope with flood impacts. Resilience in Tanzania, given its significance, remains a theoretical concept. Yet increasing interest from the water industry means the development of tools to quantify resilience and the eventual use of those tools to assist in operational decision making is required. The current study developed a resilience measurement tool for Tanzania WSS. Preassessment and pretesting of globally based indicators were conducted, followed by a three-round Delphi process to refine the tool’s variables. The tool was finally tested and evaluated in two WSS. The conceptual framework of the final tool consists of (1) system in analysis, (2) dimensions, (3) principles, and (4) indicators, and the assessment tools consist of (1) measures and measurement scales, (2) weightings, and (3) aggregation of variables. The overall system resilience (OSR) identifies specific needs for improvement of resilience in various aspects of the system, leading to decisions on appropriate intervention, planning, and budgeting measures to improve the overall resilience of WSS.
The rapid increase in the global population is contributing to the urgent challenges we face in ensuring the sustainability of our planet. This demographic shift, which gained momentum in the 1990s, is closely linked to a surge in natural disasters, both in terms of their frequency and severity. The quest for resources and improved quality of life, including the need for housing and essential services, has compounded these challenges. With the world’s population projected to double by 2050, and approximately two-thirds of this population expected to reside in urban areas, we are facing a complex web of interconnected issues that will significantly magnify the impacts of climate change-induced disasters. It is imperative that we build resilient cities capable of withstanding and adapting to these changes. However, the growing complexity of urban services and the necessity for integrated management raise questions about the preparedness of these resilient cities to comprehend and address the multifaceted challenges posed by climate change. In response to these critical concerns, this study endeavors to address the intersection of resilience and climate change. We propose the development of a Smart Resilient City Assessment Framework, comprising two core components: resilience re-evaluation and smartness evaluation. Each component consists of eight essential steps. The culmination of these steps results in a semi-quantitative index that accurately reflects the city’s position regarding resilience and smartness in the face of climate change-related disasters. To demonstrate the framework’s practicality and suitability, we present results from a hypothetical scenario focusing on water supply management, a critical aspect of climate change adaptation. The framework equips city managers with the necessary tools to re-evaluate their cities’ resilience, evaluate their capacity to address climate change-induced challenges, and make informed decisions on integrating resilience and smart solutions to pave the way for a more sustainable and climate-resilient future.
1 February 2021 in Journal of Water Resources Planning and Management
Tanzania water supply systems (WSSs) are facing resilience problems, compromising the quality and coverage of water supply services during floods. The expected rise in flood frequency and magnitude due to climate change and rapid urbanization will result in more frequent and severe impacts to the systems, prompting the need to strengthen resilience to potential impacts and minimize recovery times. This study adopted a five-stage process—literature review, preassessment, pretesting, a three-round Delphi survey, and tool evaluation—to develop a qualitative technical resilience assessment tool (QTRAT). Thematic analysis and standard descriptive statistical analysis were applied during the study. A qualitative tool with 4 principles and 10 indicators is proposed with a final semiquantitative technical index (FSTRI), where system maintenance, future expansion capability, renewal plans, and spare parts and equipment availability are the leading indicators. Evaluation results suggest that Tanzania urban WSSs have moderate resilience and are in particular need of improved design guidelines encompassing resilience aspects. The tool developed in this study contributes to informed decision-making about priority planning and budgeting of water organizations to improve the urban WSSs’ technical resilience.