Autonomous driving navigation relies on diverse approaches, each with advantages and limitations depending on various factors. For HD maps, modular systems excel, while end-to-end methods dominate mapless scenarios. However, few leverage the strengths of both. This paper innovates by proposing a hybrid architecture that seamlessly integrates modular perception and control modules with data-driven path planning. This innovative design leverages the strengths of both approaches, enabling a clear understanding and debugging of individual components while simultaneously harnessing the learning power of end-to-end approaches. Our proposed architecture achieved first and second place in the 2023 CARLA Autonomous Driving Challenge’s SENSORS and MAP tracks, respectively. These results demonstrate the architecture’s effectiveness in both map-based and mapless navigation. We achieved a driving score of and the highest route completion of in the MAP track of the CARLA Challenge leaderboard 1, and driving scores of and in the CARLA Challenge SENSOR track with route completions of and , for, respectively, leaderboard 1 and 2. The results of leaderboard 2 raised the hybrid architecture to the first position, winning the edition of the 2023 CARLA Autonomous Driving Competition.
26 September 2023 in Journal of Control, Automation and Electrical Systems
Autonomous driving navigation relies on diverse approaches, each with advantages and limitations depending on various factors. For HD maps, modular systems excel, while end-to-end methods dominate mapless scenarios. However, few leverage the strengths of both. This paper innovates by proposing a hybrid architecture that seamlessly integrates modular perception and control modules with data-driven path planning. This innovative design leverages the strengths of both approaches, enabling a clear understanding and debugging of individual components while simultaneously harnessing the learning power of end-to-end approaches. Our proposed architecture achieved 1st and 2nd place in the 2023 CARLA Autonomous Driving Challenge’s SENSORS and MAP tracks, respectively. These results demonstrate the architecture’s effectiveness in both map-based and mapless navigation.
Autonomous vehicles depend on decision-making systems capable of interpreting environmental data and vehicle states to operate safely and efficiently. Single-scenario methods perform well in limited conditions but lack adaptability for diverse scenarios. Generalized approaches address these challenges but face issues with efficiency and safety. This systematic review compares single-scenario and multi-scenario decisionmaking techniques, categorized as rule-based, optimization, learning, and hybrid methods. It highlights gaps and advances needed to enhance flexibility and reliability for handling complex driving scenarios. Analyses show that hybrid methods tend to offer greater adaptability and security by combining explicit rules and constraints with the flexibility of learning. System evaluation uses databases, simulation, and closed-track and open-road testing, but the focus varies depending on the approach: in single-scenario, the aim is to diagnose and correct specific behaviors under controlled conditions; in multiple scenarios, the objective is to measure the system’s robustness and generalizability within the operational domain. Despite advances, gaps persist in the ability to deal with unknown and critical situations, demanding future investigations into generalization strategies, incremental learning and integration of contextual representations of the environment.
The objective of the first CARLA autonomous driving challenge was to deploy autonomous driving systems to lead with complex traffic scenarios where all participants faced the same challenging traffic situations. According to the organizers, this competition emerges as a way to democratize and to accelerate the research and development of autonomous vehicles around the world using the CARLA simulator contributing to the development of the autonomous vehicle area. Therefore, this paper presents the architecture design for the navigation of an autonomous vehicle in a simulated urban environment that attempts to commit the least number of traffic infractions, which used as the baseline the original architecture of the platform for autonomous navigation CaRINA 2. Our agent traveled in simulated scenarios for several hours, demonstrating his capabilities, winning three out of the four tracks of the challenge, and being ranked second in the remaining track. Our architecture was made towards meeting the requirements of CARLA Autonomous Driving Challenge and has components for obstacle detection using 3D point clouds, traffic signs detection and classification which employs Convolutional Neural Networks (CNN) and depth information, risk assessment with collision detection using short-term motion prediction, decision-making with Markov Decision Process (MDP), and control using Model Predictive Control (MPC).