This study investigated the effect of feed formulation: the template:functional monomer (T:fM) and functional monomer:crosslinker (fM:X) ratios as well as the initiator concentration, on the binding performance and selectivity of caffeine (CAF) and theophylline (THP) imprinted polymers obtained by precipitation polymerisation in acetonitrile at 60 °C using methacrylic acid (MAA) and ethylene glycol dimethacrylate (EGDMA) as functional monomer and crosslinker, respectively. Template incorporation, monitored by quantitative 1H-NMR spectroscopy, ranged from 8 to 77% and was found to be more favourable at both high and low T:fM ratios, low fM:X ratio and high initiator concentration. The resulting T:fM ratio in most MIPs were found to be lower than their feed ratios. Incorporation of THP into the polymers was observed to be consistently higher than CAF and, for most MIPs, the observed binding capacities represent less than 10% of the incorporated template. Improved imprinting factors were obtained from molecularly imprinted polymers (MIPs) with high crosslinker content, i.e., fM:X ratio of 1:10, and high initiator concentration, i.e., initiator:total monomer (I:tM) ratio of 1:5, while T:fM ratio (1:2 to 1:8) was found not to influence binding capacities and imprinting factors (IF). The NIPs showed no preference for either CAF or THP in competitive selectivity studies while MIPs were observed to bind preferentially to their template with THP displaying higher selectivity (72–94%) than CAF (63–84%). Template selectivity was observed to increase with increasing initiator concentration, with MIPs from I:tM ratio of 1:5 shown to be the most selective towards CAF (84%) and THP (93%). The fM:X ratio only showed minimal effect on MIP selectivity. Overall, for the MIP systems under study, template incorporation, binding capacity, imprinting factor and selectivity are enhanced at a faster rate of polymerisation using an I:tM ratio of 1:5. Polymer particles obtained were between 66 to 140 nm, with MIPs generally smaller than their NIP counterparts, and have been observed to decrease with increasing T:fM and fM:X ratios and increase with increasing initiator concentration.
We present a new concept of synthesis for preparation of molecularly imprinted polymers using a functionalized initiator to replace the traditional functional monomer. Using propranolol as a model template, a carboxyl-functionalized radical initiator was demonstrated to lead to high-selectivity polymer particles prepared in a standard precipitation polymerization system. When a single enantiomer of propranolol was used as template, the imprinted polymer particles exhibited clear chiral selectivity in an equilibrium binding experiment. Unlike the previous molecular imprinting systems where the active free radicals can be distant from the template-functional monomer complex, the method reported in this work makes sure that the actual radical polymerization takes place in the vicinity of the template-associated functional groups. The success of using functional initiator to synthesize molecularly imprinted polymers brings in new possibilities to improve the functional performance of molecularly imprinted synthetic receptors.
Molecularly imprinted polymers (MIPs) for benzylpiperazine (BZP, 1), an illicit designer drug, were developed by using both self-assembly and semi-covalent approaches. From an array of potential functional monomers (FMs) and using a combination of pre-synthetic interaction studies (by molecular modelling and NMR analysis) and binding assays, the highest performing self-assembly 1-MIPs were confirmed to result from methacrylic acid (7) as FM, ethylene glycol dimethacrylate (EGDMA) or trimethylolpropane trimethacrylate (TRIM) as crosslinkers and chloroform as the porogen and rebinding solvent at template (T): FM ratios of 1:1 and 1:2, giving imprinting factors (IF) 3 to 7. The semi-covalent 1-MIPs were designed using benzylpiperazine (4-vinylphenyl) carbamate (16) as the template–monomer adduct in combination with either EDGMA or TRIM. Our comparative analysis showed the semi-covalent polymers to have a stronger affinity for 1 (significantly lower Kd values and higher IFs) and faster uptake than the self-assembly systems. Both approaches have comparable cross-reactivity: marginal to low against cocaine (17) and morphine (18) and high against ephedrine (19) and phenylpiperazine (20). They also have comparable selectivity: highly selective towards 1 against 17, moderate against 18 and non-selective against 19. EGDMA-based self-assembly MIPs displayed a greater imprinting effect (higher IFs and NIP-to-MIP Kd ratios) than TRIM-based MIPs, while the TRIM-based semi-covalent MIP outperformed its EGDMA-based equivalent. By virtue of its modest selectivity against the test illicit drugs, 1-MIPs could potentially be used as a dummy MIP for the broad-based capture and enrichment of illicit drug blends for subsequent laboratory analysis.
Six novel functional monomers: 4-(4-vinylphenyl)pyridine (M1), 4′-vinylbiphenyl-4-ol (M2), N,N-dimethyl-4′-vinylbiphenyl-3-amine (M3), (4′-vinylbiphenyl-4-yl)methanol (M4), 4′-vinylbiphenyl-4-carboxylic acid (M5) and 4-hydroxy-5-methyl-4′-vinylbiphenyl-3-carboxylic acid (M6), were examined for their ability to imprint theophylline (1). Using a molecular modelling-NMR titration approach, M2 and M6 were predicted to give rise to the most specific molecularly imprinted polymers (MIPs). Rebinding analysis suggests that no imprinting effect resulted from the polymerisation of monomers M1, M5 and M6, but modest to good levels of imprinting were evident from monomers M2, M3 and M4 with IF values ranging from 1.1 (MIPM3, 20 mg) to 45 (MIPM2, 10 mg). The selective recognition of 1 varied as a function of polymer mass used. At low polymer loadings MIPM2 gave the very high IF of 45, reducing to IF = 4.1–2.3 at 20–40 mg polymer loading. With monomer M2, microwave synthesised MIP (MW-MIPM2) was examined. The MW-MIPM2 displayed lower specific rebinding than its conventionally produced counterpart (MIPM2) with IF values ranging from 1.6–2.3 (cf., MIPM2 IF 2.3–45), but significantly higher levels of rebinding with 25–52% of 1 rebound from a 0.080 mM CH3CN solution of 1 (cf., MIPM2 5–25%). MW-MIPM2 displayed a lower BET surface area than MIPM2 (185 m2 g−1vs. 240 m2 g−1), and lower surface (zeta) potential (−13.1 ± 8.22 mV vs. −31.4 ± 4.84 mV). Freundlich isotherm analysis revealed that MW-MIPM2 possessed higher affinity binding sites for 1 than MIPM2 with Kd values of 1.38 and 2.31 respectively. In addition, MW-MIPM2 also exhibits a higher number of binding sites (NT) compared to MW-NIPM2 (0.72 and 0.41 mg g−1, respectively). In specificity studies using caffeine (2), MIPM2 displayed a two-fold preference for rebinding of 1 and MW-MIPM2 a five-fold preference for 1 over 2. The quantity of 2 bound in both cases was consistent with non-specific binding events. In competitive rebinding experiments, increased discrimination in favour of 1 over 2 was observed.
4 July 2016 in Macromolecular Chemistry and Physics