Two coupled four-beam acoustic Doppler current profilers were used to provide simultaneous and independent measurements of the turbulent kinetic energy (TKE) dissipation rate ε and the TKE production rate over a 36 h long period at a highly energetic tidal energy site in the Alderney Race. The eight-beam arrangement enabled the evaluation of the six components of the Reynolds stress tensor which allows for an improved estimation of the TKE production rate. Depth-time series of ε, and the Reynolds stresses are provided. The comparison between ε and was performed by calculating individual ratios of ε corresponding to . The depth-averaged ratio averaged over whole flood and ebb tide were found to be 2.2 and 2.8 respectively, indicating that TKE dissipation exceeds TKE production. It is shown that the term of diffusive transport of TKE is significant. As a result, non-local transport is important to the TKE budget and the common assumption of a local balance, i.e. a balance between production and dissipation, is not valid at the measurement site. This article is part of the theme issue ‘New insights on tidal dynamics and tidal energy harvesting in the Alderney Race’.
A system of two coupled four-beam acoustic Doppler current profilers was used to collect turbulence measurements over a 36-h period at a highly energetic tidal energy site in Alderney Race. This system enables the evaluation of the six components of the Reynolds stress tensor throughout a large proportion of the water column. The present study provides mean vertical profiles of the velocity, the turbulence intensity and the integral lengthscale along the streamwise, spanwise and vertical direction of the tidal current. Based on our results and considering a tidal-stream energy convertor (TEC) aligned with the current main direction, the main elements of turbulence prone to affect the structure (material fatigue) and to alter power generation would likely be: (i) the streamwise turbulence intensity ( Ix ), (ii) the shear stress, , (iii) the normal stress, and (iv) the vertical integral lengthscale ( Lz ). The streamwise turbulence intensity, ( Ix ), was found to be higher than that estimated at other tidal energy sites across the world for similar height above bottom. Along the vertical direction, the length ( Lz ) of the large-scale turbulence eddies was found to be equivalent to the rotor diameter of the TEC Sabella D10. It is considered that the turbulence metrics presented in this paper will be valuable for TECs designers, helping them optimize their designs as well as improve loading prediction through the lifetime of the machines. This article is part of the theme issue ‘New insights on tidal dynamics and tidal energy harvesting in the Alderney Race’.
This study examines how motion influences turbulent velocity fluctuations utilizing measurements obtained from a wind lidar profiler. Onshore tests were performed using a WindCube v2.1 lidar, which was mobile and mounted on a hexapod to simulate buoy motion. Additionally, a fixed WindCube v2.1 lidar was used as a reference during these tests. To assess the motion-induced effects on velocity fluctuations measured by floating lidar systems, the root-mean-square error (RMSE) of velocity fluctuations obtained from the fixed and mobile lidars was calculated. A comprehensive wind dataset spanning 22.5 h was analyzed, with a focus on regular motions involving single-axis rotations and combinations of rotations around multiple axes. The investigation of single-axis rotations revealed that the primary influencing factor on the results was the alignment between the tilt direction of the mobile lidar and the wind direction. The highest RMSE values occurred when the tilt of the mobile lidar leans in the wind direction, resulting in pitch motion, whereas the lowest RMSE values were observed when the tilt of the mobile lidar leans perpendicular to the wind direction, resulting in roll motion. Moreover, the addition of motion around extra axes of rotation was found to increase RMSE.
This study evaluates the impact of an enhanced sampling rate on turbulence measurements using the Vaisala WindCube v2.1 lidar profiler. A prototype configuration, sampling 4 times faster than the commercial setup, was compared to the commercial WindCube v2.1, with reference measurements provided by a 2D sonic anemometer mounted on a measurement mast. Over the 47 d experiment, the prototype configuration showed performance similar to the commercial setup for key performance indicators (KPIs) like slope and the coefficient of determination of mean wind speed compared to reference measurements, with both configurations meeting the “best-practice” threshold. However, for mean wind speed differences, the commercial configuration met the best-practice level, while the prototype met the “minimum-acceptance” criterion. Additionally, the data availability of the prototype configuration was 0.5 % lower than that of the commercial configuration. Moreover, the increased sampling rate of the prototype lidar resulted in higher mean variance in instrumental noise compared to that of the commercial configuration. Despite this limitation, the mean noise-corrected along-wind variance measured by the prototype lidar was approximately 7 % higher than that of the commercial lidar. This effect was especially evident at higher wind speeds. Error metrics for the noise-corrected along-wind standard deviation in the prototype lidar were approximately 25 % lower than those of the commercial configuration. However, the observed improvements to the prototype configuration in measuring turbulence fell short of expectations due to inherent limitations in the measurement process within the probe, where spatial and temporal filtering effects constrain the detection of turbulence at certain scales.
A dual-lidar system comprising two WindCube v2.1 Doppler lidars – one oriented horizontally at a 45° angle relative to the other – was deployed to estimate atmospheric turbulence using the variance method. This approach derives second-order velocity statistics directly from line-of-sight (LOS) velocity variances, enabling the reconstruction of the three-dimensional velocity variance components without retrieving instantaneous wind vectors. Its performance is evaluated against the traditional method commonly used in the wind energy sector, which reconstructs instantaneous velocity components from single-lidar LOS measurements prior to computing turbulence statistics. Both methods are assessed at a single measurement height using a 30 d collocated dataset, with sonic anemometer measurements as reference and classification by atmospheric stability. The analysis focuses on turbulence intensity (TI), and performance is quantified using the mean relative bias error (MRBE) and relative root mean square error (RRMSE), following Det Norske Veritas (DNV) load-validation acceptance criteria (MRBE within ±5 % and RRMSE ≤ 15 %). Results show that the variance method demonstrates improved agreement with the reference measurements across nearly all wind-speed bins. For along-wind TI, MRBE values range between 0 % and −5 %, with RRMSE remaining below 15 % over the full wind-speed range, fully satisfying the DNV criteria. For cross-wind TI, the MRBE criterion is met, while the RRMSE threshold is exceeded. In contrast, the traditional method meets both DNV criteria for along-wind TI only at wind speeds above approximately 7 m s−1 and fails to satisfy either criterion for cross-wind TI across the investigated range. Overall, the results demonstrate that the variance method provides more robust and DNV-compliant TI estimates than the traditional reconstruction approach, particularly for along-wind turbulence relevant to wind turbine load validation.