Endotoxins, heat-stable lipopolysaccharides from Gram-negative bacteria, are potential contaminants that can be introduced during manufacturing of pharmaceutical products, including vaccines. Parental pharmaceutical products undergo endotoxin testing because endotoxins are pyrogenic in humans and can induce severe physiological reactions. Currently, animal-derived Limulus amoebocyte lysate (LAL) assays are widely used. Assays using recombinant Factor C (rFC), a non-animal-derived reagent, have been proposed as alternatives. Some components in the matrices of pharmaceutical products can interfere with these assays. We compared two LAL- and two rFC-based assays for endotoxin detection in four complex human vaccine matrices. We showed that the results for the rFC-based assays were at least equivalent to those for the LAL-based assays, although rFC-based assays were found to be adequate but slightly less suitable for one of the products which contained proteases and the methods used to inactivate the proteases reduced the assay performance. Likewise, LAL was adequate but less suitable for another product which contained glucans. The rFC assays offer a number of benefits, including compliance with the principles of the 3Rs, i.e., replacement, reduction and refinement of animal testing by safeguarding animal welfare and promoting more ethical and sustainable use of animals for testing. After they are fully validated, as per the compendial requirements, they could be considered as suitable replacement assays for the detection of endotoxin in the manufacturing processes of pharmaceutical products. In summary, we demonstrated that both LAL and rFC assays are adequate for testing and releasing four vaccine products.
Current bacterial endotoxin testing systems can be labor-intensive and time-consuming, involving several manual pipetting steps. In our quality control laboratory, annually, we test about 15,000 samples of different grades of purified water, WFI and water samples taken to validate cleaning procedures for endotoxins. We are currently using the Kinetic-QCL™ assay which is a pharmacopeia method that provides reliable results. We compared this assay with another Limulus amebocyte lysate (LAL)-based assay (Endosafe®-MCS) and an alternative endpoint fluorescent recombinant Factor C (rFC) assay (ENDOZYME II GO®). Both these assays have been developed to reduce analyst preparation time. Our objective was to assess if they could increase the throughput of our testing while maintaining low rates of invalid results. The results demonstrated that the two most appropriate methods for rapid endotoxin detection in water are our current assay, K-QCL, and the rFC-based assay, ENDOZYME II GO. This latter assay was found to be less sensitive to interference than our current assay, particularly in cleaning validation water samples. It also showed better performance, accuracy, repeatability and had a shorter time-to-results. ENDOZYME II GO assay allows quick testing of large numbers of samples with reliable results and is a good alternative for conventional LAL assays.
Mycobacteria can be one of the main contaminants of biological products, and their presence can have serious consequences on patients’ health. For this reason, the European Pharmacopoeia mandates the specific testing of biological products for mycobacteria, a critical regulatory requirement aimed at ensuring the safety of these products before they are released to the market. The current pharmacopeial reference, i.e., microbial culture method, cannot ensure an exhaustive detection of mycobacteria due to their growth characteristics. Additionally, the method is time consuming and requires a continuous supply of culture media, posing logistical challenges. Thus, to overcome these issues, pharmaceutical industries need to consider alternative non-microbiological techniques to detect these fastidious, slow-growing contaminating agents. This review provides an overview of alternative methods, which could be applied within a quality control environment for biological products and underlines their advantages and limitations. Nucleic acid amplification techniques or direct measurement of mycobacteria stand out as the most suitable alternatives for mycobacterial testing in biological products.
17 September 2025 in PDA Journal of Pharmaceutical Science and Technology
Mollicutes class (e.g. mycoplasma species) are notorious bacterial contaminants in eukaryotic cell cultures, known for being particularly difficult to detect and eliminate. Their presence can negatively impact the health of cultured cells, decrease bioreactor yields, interfere with in vitro tests and, in some cases, cause disease. Accordingly, mycoplasma testing represents a common bottleneck in the manufacturing process for which compendial mycoplasma tests may not be suitable due to their lengthy turnaround times. This is even more true, in the case of short shelf-life products, that requires short turnaround time for manufacturing. To address the need for more rapid test methods, pharmacopoeias have provided guidance on the use of mycoplasma Nucleic Acid Amplification Techniques (NATs) as an alternative to compendial methods for lot release testing and in-process testing. In this article, we summarize the discussion of a group of pharmaceutical experts who met to propose recommendations and a path forward for the method validation and method suitability testing of a new mycoplasma nucleic acid-based test, the BIOFIRE® Mycoplasma Test. In contrast to conventional NATs, which require a significant amount of hands-on time from highly skilled operators, BIOFIRE® Mycoplasma test provides a closed and fully automated “lab in a pouch” NAT system. This innovative solution offers minimal hands-on time, minimal user training and skill, and delivers the results in about one hour. This paper offers a summary of the different working sessions held outlining key recommendations for validating the BIOFIRE® Mycoplasma test for release of commercial drug products.
Mycobacteria can be one of the main contaminants of biological products, and their presence can have serious consequences on patients’ health. Thus, specific testing is necessitated by regulations such as the European Pharmacopoeia. The current pharmacopeial reference i.e., microbial culture method cannot ensure an exhaustive detection of mycobacteria due to their growth characteristics. Additionally, the method is time-consuming and requires a continuous supply of culture media, which could be further challenging. Thus, to overcome these challenges, pharmaceutical industries need to consider alternative non-microbiological techniques to detect these fastidious, slow-growing contaminating agents. This review provides an overview of alternative methods, which could be applied within a quality control environment of biological products, and underlines advantages and limitations of these methods. Nucleic acid amplification techniques or direct measurement of mycobacteria stands out as the most suitable alternatives for mycobacterial testing in biological products.