The goal of this study is to develop an efficient machine learning framework for designing high-hardness multi-metal nitride coatings, overcoming the limitations of traditional trial-and-error methods. The development of multicomponent metal nitride hard coatings via multi-arc ion plating remains a significant challenge due to the vast compositional search space. Although theoretical studies in macroscopic, mesoscopic, and microscopic domains exist, these often focus on idealized models and lack effective coupling across scales, leading to time-consuming and labor-intensive traditional methods. With advancements in materials genomics and data mining, machine learning has become a powerful tool in material discovery. In this work, we construct a compositional search space for multicomponent nitrides based on electronic configuration, valence electron count, electronegativity, and oxidation states of metal elements in unary nitrides. The search space is further constrained by FCC crystal structure and hardness theory. By incorporating a feature library with micro-, meso-, and macro-structural characteristics and using clustering analysis with theoretical intermediate variables, the model enriches dataset information and enhances predictive accuracy by reducing experimental errors. This model is successfully applied to design multicomponent metal nitride coatings using a literature-derived database of 233 entries. Experimental validation confirms the model’s predictions, and clustering is used to minimize experimental and data errors, yielding a strong agreement between predicted optimal molar ratios of metal elements and nitrogen and measured hardness performance. Of the 100 Vickers hardness (HV) predictions made by the model using input features like molar ratios of metal elements (e.g., Ti, Al, Cr, Zr) and atomic size mismatch, 82 exceeded the dataset’s maximum hardness, with the best sample achieving a prediction accuracy of 91.6% validated against experimental measurements. This approach offers a robust strategy for designing high-performance coatings with optimized hardness.