The Hubble constant (H0) tension between Type Ia supernovae (SNe Ia) and Planck measurements ranges from 4 to 6σ. To investigate this tension, we estimate H0 in the ΛCDM and CDM (cold dark matter) models by dividing the Pantheon sample, the largest compilation of SNe Ia, into 3, 4, 20, and 40 bins. We fit the extracted H0 values with a function mimicking the redshift evolution: , where α indicates an evolutionary parameter and at z = 0. We set the absolute magnitude of SNe Ia so that , and we fix fiducial values for and . We find that H0 evolves with redshift, showing a slowly decreasing trend, with α coefficients consistent with zero only from 1.2 to 2.0σ. Although the α coefficients are compatible with zero in 3σ, this however may affect cosmological results. We measure locally a variation of in three and four bins. Extrapolating to z = 1100, the redshift of the last scattering surface, we obtain values of H0 compatible in 1σ with Planck measurements independent of the cosmological models and number of bins we investigated. Thus, we have reduced the H0 tension in the range from 54% to 72% for both cosmological models. If the decreasing trend of is real, it could be due to astrophysical selection effects or to modified gravity.
The difference from 4 to 6 in the Hubble constant () between the values observed with the local (Cepheids and Supernovae Ia, SNe Ia) and the high-z probes (Cosmic Microwave Background obtained by the Planck data) still challenges the astrophysics and cosmology community. Previous analysis has shown that there is an evolution in the Hubble constant that scales as , where is and is the evolutionary parameter. Here, we investigate if this evolution still holds by using the SNe Ia gathered in the Pantheon sample and the Baryon Acoustic Oscillations. We assume as the local value and divide the Pantheon into three bins ordered in increasing values of redshift. Similar to our previous analysis but varying two cosmological parameters contemporaneously (, in the CDM model and , in the CDM model), for each bin we implement a Markov-Chain Monte Carlo analysis (MCMC) obtaining the value of assuming Gaussian priors to restrict the parameters spaces to values we expect from our prior knowledge of the current cosmological models and to avoid phantom Dark Energy models with . Subsequently, the values of are fitted with the model . Our results show that a decreasing trend with is still visible in this sample. The coefficient reaches zero in 2.0 for the CDM model up to 5.8 for CDM model. This trend, if not due to statistical fluctuations, could be explained through a hidden astrophysical bias, such as the effect of stretch evolution, or it requires new theoretical models, a possible proposition is the modified gravity theories, . This analysis is meant to further cast light on the evolution of and it does not specifically focus on constraining the other parameters. This work is also a preparatory to understand how the combined probes still show an evolution of the by redshift and what is the current status of simulations on GRB cosmology to obtain the uncertainties on the comparable with the ones achieved through SNe Ia.
4 October 2010 in The Astrophysical Journal Letters
Gamma Ray Bursts (GRB) observed up to redshifts $z>8$ are fascinating objects to study due to their still unexplained relativistic outburst mechanisms and a possible use to test cosmological models. Our analysis of 77 GRB afterglows with known redshifts revealed a physical subsample of long GRBs with canonical {\it plateau breaking to power-law} light curves with a significant {\it luminosity $L^*_X$ - break time $T^*_a$} correlation in the GRB rest frame. This subsample forms approximately the {\it upper envelope} of the studied distribution. We have also found a similar relation for a small sample of GRB afterglows that belong to the intermediate class (IC) between the short and the long ones. It proves that within the full sample of afterglows there exist physical subclasses revealed here by tight correlations of their afterglow properties. The afterglows with regular (`canonical') light curves obey not only a mentioned tight physical scaling, but -- for a given $T^*_a$ -- the more regular progenitor explosions lead to preferentially brighter afterglows.
A class of long gamma-ray bursts (GRBs) presenting light curves with an extended plateau phase in their X-ray afterglows obeys a correlation between the rest-frame end-time of the plateau, Ta, and its corresponding X-ray luminosity, La, (Dainotti et al). In this work we perform an analysis of a total sample of 176 Swift GRBs with known redshifts, exhibiting afterglow plateaus. By adding a third parameter that is the peak luminosity in the prompt emission, Lpeak, we discover the existence of a new three-parameter correlation. The scatter of data about this plane becomes smaller when a class-specific GRB sample is defined. This sample of 122 GRBs is selected from the total sample by excluding GRBs with associated supernovae (SNe), X-ray flashes and short GRBs with extended emission. With this sample the three-parameter correlation identifies a GRB “fundamental plane.” Moreover, we further limit our analysis to GRBs with light curves with good data coverage and almost flat plateaus, 40 GRBs forming our “gold sample.” The intrinsic scatter, , for the three-parameter correlation for this last sub-class is more than two times smaller than the value for the one, making this the tightest three-parameter correlation that involves the afterglow plateau phase. Finally, we also show that a slightly less tight correlation is present between Lpeak and a proxy for the total energy emitted during the plateau phase, , confirming the existence of an energy scaling between the prompt and afterglow phases.
A large fraction of gamma-ray burst (GRB) lightcurves (LCs) show X-ray plateaus. We analyze all GRBs with known redshifts presenting plateaus observed by The Neil Gehrels Swift Observatory from its launch until 2019 August. The fundamental plane relation between the rest-frame time and X-ray luminosity at the end of the plateau emission and the peak prompt luminosity holds for all the GRB classes when selection biases and cosmological evolutions are applied. We have discovered two important findings: (1) a new class of long GRBs with good data coverage: the platinum sample; and (2) the platinum, the SNe-LGRB, and the KN-SGRB samples, yield the smallest intrinsic scatter with σplatinum,GRB−SNe = 0.22 ± 0.10 and σKN−SGRB = 0.24 ± 0.12. The SNe-LGRBs are composed of GRBs associated spectroscopically with the SNe Ib,c, the KN-SGRBs are composed by eight GRBs associated with kilonovae or where there could have been such an association. The highest correlation coefficients are yielded for the SN-LGRB-ABC sample, which includes GRBs spectroscopically associated with SNe Ib/c or with a clear optical bump in the LC resembling the SNe Ib/c, ( ), the SN-LGRBs ( ), and the KN-SGRBs ( ) when the redshift evolution is considered. These category planes are reliable candidates to use as cosmological tools. Furthermore, the distance from the gold fundamental plane is a crucial discriminant among classes. In fact, we find that the distributions of the distances of the SNe-LGRB, SNe-LGRB-ABC, KN-SGRB, and SGRB samples from the gold fundamental plane are statistically different from the distribution of the gold GRBs’ distances from the gold fundamental plane with and without considering evolution cases.
The X-ray afterglow plateau emission observed in many gamma-ray bursts (GRBs) has been interpreted as being fueled either by fallback onto a newly formed black hole or by the spin-down luminosity of an ultra-magnetized millisecond neutron star. If the latter model is assumed, GRB X-ray afterglow light curves can be reproduced analytically. We fit a sample of GRB X-ray plateaus, interestingly yielding a distribution in the diagram of magnetic field versus spin period (B–P) consistent with B ∝ P7/6, which is consistent with GRB expectations of the well-established physics of the spin-up line for accreting Galactic X-ray pulsars. The normalization of the relation that we obtain perfectly matches spin-up line predictions for typical neutron star masses (∼1 M⊙) and radii (∼10 km), and for mass accretion rates typically expected in GRBs, . Short GRBs with extended emission (SEEs) appear toward the long-period end of the distribution, and long GRBs (LGRBs) toward the short-period end. This result is consistent with expectations from the spin-up limit, where the total accreted mass determines the position of the neutron star in the B–P diagram. The B–P distributions for LGRBs and SEEs are statistically different, further supporting the idea that the fundamental plane relation—a tri-dimensional correlation between the X-ray luminosity at the end of the plateau, the end time of the plateau, and the 1 s peak luminosity in the prompt emission—is a powerful discriminant among those populations. Our conclusions are robust against suppositions regarding the collimation angle of the GRB and the magnetar braking index, which shift the resulting properties of the magnetar parallel to the spin-up line, and strongly support a magnetar origin for GRBs presenting X-ray plateaus.