This paper conducts a comprehensive analysis and comparison of the control loops of the grid-following and grid-forming voltage source converters connected to the power grid. Eigenvalue trajectories are studied in order to obtain an accurate stability analysis. A time-domain simulation model of a 1.5 kW grid-connected converter is developed by using Matlab/Simulink to investigate the stability of the grid-following and grid-forming control under different short-circuit ratios. The stability boundaries of the grid-following control and the grid-forming control are explored and compared with theoretical analysis. The result reveals that the grid-following control is better suited for a stiff power grid, while the grid-forming control is more suitable for a weak power grid. Finally, an experimental prototype is established to verify the effectiveness of the theoretical analysis.
1 October 2024 in IEEE Transactions on Industry Applications
In alignment with decarbonization efforts, there has been widespread global interest in renewable energy sources such as wind and solar, which are connected to the grid via grid-connected inverters. The transition from traditional synchronous generator-based power systems to power-electronic-based power systems has introduced increased complexity due to the stochastic and intermittent nature of renewable energy outputs. Consequently, grid-connected inverters need to dynamically adapt their control strategies to cope with varying external grid conditions and ensure high reliability. However, such transitions can cause abrupt changes in the control loops (e.g., power loop or voltage loop), and lead to voltage and current distortions, potentially compromising safe operation. To address this issue, this paper proposes a smooth switching method between the grid-following (GFL) and grid-forming (GFM) control in grid-connected mode. This method can improve the control flexibility of the grid-connected converters and broaden the stability boundary of the power system. The proposed method is verified in a case study of a 15.8 kVA grid-connected converter. Time-domain simulations carried out in Matlab/Simulink and an established experimental prototype are applied to verify the effectiveness of the proposed control method. The results demonstrate that the proposed control method effectively mitigates voltage and current distortions during transitions, ensuring safer and more reliable operation.
This paper analyzes and compares the control loops of the grid-following and the grid-forming voltage source converters connected to the power grid. Eigenvalue trajectories are studied in order to obtain an accurate stability analysis. A time-domain simulation model of 15 kW grid-connected converter is built in Matlab/Simulink to discuss the stability of the grid-following control and the grid-forming control under the conditions of different short-circuit ratios. The stability boundaries of the grid-following control and the grid-forming control are obtained. The result reveals that the grid-following control is more suitable for the stiff power grid, while the grid-forming control is more suitable for the weak power grid.
Initiatives to decarbonize contemporary power systems will lead to power systems dominated by inverter-based resources (IBR). These IBRs are broadly classified into grid-following (GFL) and grid-forming (GFM) inverter control regimes. In this paper, a small-signal state-space model is formulated for a 100% IBR-dominated power system. This formulation is then used to perform stability analysis on the IEEE 9-bus system. The analysis thoroughly investigates the impacts of varying GFM inverter penetration on system stability. The paper also discusses the system behavior in the wake of varying shares of different GFL inverter control schemes. The cause of instability is ascertained by investigating the participation factor of each component. Moreover, the paper examines the effects of phase-locked loop (PLL) and power synchronization loop (PSL) parameters on determining the minimum GFM penetration necessary for ensuring stable system operation. It has been found that the inverter type with the highest capacity is not always the biggest contributor to instability. Also, increasing the proportional coefficient and decreasing the integral coefficient of the PLL of GFL inverters allow the system to be operated under lower GFM penetration. Similarly, increasing the moment of inertia or damping coefficient of the GFM inverter’s power synchronization loop has a similar effect. The conclusions and the underlying theoretical analysis are verified by time-domain simulations of electromagnetic transient (EMT) models in Matlab/Simulink.
The growing integration of renewable energy sources has led to the development of virtual synchronous generator (VSG) control as a way to enhance system stability and offer primary frequency regulation. These functions of VSGs usually rely on the photovoltaic (PV) system or battery energy storage (BES), which is equipped at the DC side of the system. However, due to differences in the initial state of charges (SoCs) and uneven power distribution, the SoCs of battery energy storage systems (BESs) may become unbalanced, posing risks to the healthy operation of BESs and the overall system reliability. To realize SoC balancing, an adaptive control scheme for a paralleled PV-BES-VSG power system is presented. The adaptive SoC balancing term is applied to the active power references based on a simple segmented quadratic function. The proposed control strategy can realize optimal operation of paralleled VSGs and reduce SoC imbalance at the same time. The effectiveness of the proposed control scheme is evaluated via a case study system consisting of two paralleled PV-BES-VSG units using Matlab/Simulink R2021a.