In this work, we perform direct numerical simulations of Rayleigh–Bénard convection in a two-dimensional confined square cell for Rayleigh numbers (Ra) from 109 to 1013 and a Prandtl number (Pr) of 0.7. In contrast to a previous study in a periodic box conducted by Zhu et al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 120, 144502 (2018)], our simulations apply two adiabatic sidewalls. In particular, boundary layer structures near the heating plates are examined using both mean velocity and temperature profiles in the impacting, shearing, and ejecting regions of the plumes. After an appropriate normalization using the wall units, the friction Reynolds numbers of our simulations exceed the critical value of 200 and follow Reτ∼Ra0.323, and we also observe the logarithmic mean velocity profiles (with the slope κv≈0.35) in the shearing regions and logarithmic mean temperature profiles (with the slope κθ≈2) in the ejecting regions. These logarithmic behaviors indicate that both the thermal and momentum boundary layers may have entered the fully developed turbulent state. However, for the Nusselt number (Nu), our data still follow the trend of classical 1/3 scaling, differing from the ultimate state reported before but agreeing with the three-dimensional results obtained by Iyer et al. [PNAS 117, 14 (2020)] for confined cells.
Direct numerical simulation (DNS) of non-slip two dimensional (2-D) Rayleigh-Benard convection (RBC) is conducted for a wide range of Rayleigh number (Ra up to 1013) at Prandtl number Pr = 0.7 and aspect ratio Γ =1. The thermal dissipation rate is shown to display an evident scaling transition through the compensated plot, i.e. ⟨εθ⟩ ∝ Raγ with γ ≈ −0.17 for 106 {less than or equal to} Ra {less than or equal to} 109, whilst γ ≈ −0.19 for Ra = 109 {less than or equal to} Ra {less than or equal to} 1013. To track the transition, separate contributions from the thermal boundary layer (BL) and the bulk flow region are examined, incorporated also with the mean and fluctuation decomposition. It turns out that the mean temperature gradient in the BL is the dominant contribution, and together with other parts (i.e. fluctuations in the BL and bulk, and the mean gradient in the bulk), they all exhibit an obvious transition at Ra ≈ 109. We have further checked the Nusselt number (Nu) which also shows the transition at Ra ≈ 109, and interestingly, Nu ∝ Ra0.33 is observed for small Ra whilst Nu ∝ Ra2/7 is absent in 2-D RBC cases. To understand the physical origin of transition, spatial distributions and probability density functions of thermal dissipation rate are finally discussed, with notable statistical features changed at Ra ≈ 109.
While thermal convection cells exhibit left–right and top–bottom symmetries at low Rayleigh numbers (), the emergence of coherent flow structures, such as elliptical large-scale circulation in Rayleigh–Bénard convection (RBC), breaks these symmetries as the Rayleigh number increases. Recently, spatial double-reflection symmetry was proposed and verified for two-dimensional RBC at a Prandtl number of 6.5 and values up to . In this study, we examined this new symmetry at a lower Prandtl number of 0.7 and across a wider range of Rayleigh numbers, from to . Our findings reveal that the double-reflection symmetry is preserved for the mean profiles and flow fields of velocity and temperature for , but it is broken at higher Rayleigh numbers. This asymmetry at high values is inferred to be induced by a flow-pattern transition at . Together with the previous study, our results demonstrate that the Prandtl number has an important influence on the symmetry preservation in RBC.
The Rayleigh–Bénard convection system exhibits certain known symmetries at low Rayleigh numbers that are broken as the Rayleigh number increases. In this study, we investigate the statistical symmetry of Rayleigh–Bénard convection at moderately high Rayleigh numbers through direct numerical simulations. The simulations are conducted for a fluid confined within two-dimensional walls, with an aspect ratio of unity and a fixed Prandtl number. Although elliptical large-scale circulations break both left-right and top-down reflection symmetries, we observe the emergence of a restored double-reflection symmetry. This symmetry is evident in the velocity and temperature fields, as well as in the variations of mean velocity and temperature profiles along the streamwise direction and the characteristics of the kinetic and thermal boundary layers. For Rayleigh numbers ranging between 107 and 1010, our results demonstrate a remarkable data collapse under this double-reflection transformation.
While seeking the ultimate statistical invariance of turbulence, classical boundary layer theory is unable to distinguish between the averaged states of wall flows with two-dimensional (2D) and three-dimensional (3D) fluctuations. Here we demonstrate glaring differences between 2D and 3D channel flows and present theoretical explanations for the differences in their Reynolds numbers' asymptotic behaviors. In particular, due to the peculiar inverse cascade, large-scale wavy structures (LSWSs) are developed in 2D flows, which inject a high-energy flux toward the wall and cause extreme wall dissipation. The latter follows a distinct scaling within the range covered by our direct numerical simulation . The same trend is also observed for the root mean square of the pressure and velocity fluctuations (as well as for the bulk velocity). Rationale for the scaling is further given through an LSWS-induced dissipative timescale (provided with the 2D friction law), which is unlike the viscous timescale in 3D flows due to the absence of LSWSs. As a counterpart to the classical boundary layer of bounded 3D fluctuations [Chen and Sreenivasan, J. Fluid Mech. 908, R3 (2021); J. Fluid Mech. 933, A20 (2022)], the results here reveal an unprecedented asymptotic state of wall flows in which the inverse cascade induces unbounded 2D fluctuations.