Every interaction between a brand and its consumers can shape their brand attitudes and purchase decisions. Brand rejection is the rejection or neglect that consumers experience when trying to connect with a brand, and it may have far-reaching effects on consumer psychology and behavior. Against this backdrop, consumer response to brand rejection has become a concern in interactive marketing. This study investigated how consumers cope with brand rejection by satisfying their need to reduce uncertainty based on the uncertainty–identity theory. This study examined the effect of brand rejection on consumers’ in-group brands (e.g., local brands) preference and the corresponding mediating mechanism and boundary condition through four experiments. The results demonstrated that consumers who experienced brand rejection were less likely to purchase products from that brand and showed a greater preference for other in-group brands than out-group brands (foreign brands). This relationship was mediated by consumers’ sense of control. Moreover, brand familiarity moderated the relationship between brand rejection and sense of control, affecting consumers’ in-group brand preference. These findings expand the research area of brand rejection and in-group brand preference and provide a practical reference for the development of local brands.
Algorithm-aversion research predicts that consumers prefer human curators to algorithmic ones in subjective decision domains, including taste-based hedonic recommendation. Drawing on the algorithmic-symbiosis paradigm and on assortment-perception theory, this paper identifies a boundary condition on that prediction: disclosing that recommendations are AI-curated rather than human-curated lifts purchase intention in hedonic e-commerce but not in utilitarian e-commerce. The mechanism is a search-side option-breadth inference—the consumer’s attribution about the size of the option pool the curator considered upstream—which is diagnostic in preference-formative consumption categories where consumers build, rather than match, a preference. Three online experiments deployed through a Chinese consumer panel test the framework. Study 1 () finds the predicted Disclosure × Product-type interaction () with the AI-versus-human lift confined to the hedonic cell (). Study 2 () isolates the option-breadth pathway against trust and competence as competing mediators. Study 3 () extends the design to a second hedonic category, decomposes option breadth into search-side and display-side subdimensions through an eight-item bi-factor scale, tests mentalizing alongside option breadth as a competing mediator, and brings the moderated-mediation test by consumer AI familiarity to conventional statistical power (index of moderated mediation , 95% CI ). Implications for interactive-marketing practice and algorithmic-disclosure regulation are discussed.
Conversational AI agents are now a routine touchpoint in e-commerce customer service, and AI empathy has emerged as the headline humanization strategy for repairing relational damage during service failures. A growing evidence base reports that empathic AI often backfires, because consumers cannot reconcile felt warmth with their lay model of what an artificial agent is. This research asks under what conditions AI empathy can be made credible to consumers. We propose that mechanistic interpretability, operationalized in the present studies as a consumer-facing visualization of an AI agent’s internal emotion-vector activations designed in the style of mechanistic-interpretability research, operates as a costly authenticity signal that rehabilitates empathic AI by enabling an attributional shift along the experience dimension of mind perception. Signaling Theory carries the antecedent stage of the causal chain, where mechanistic interpretability serves as a verifiable cue of computational authenticity. Mind Perception Theory carries the downstream stage, where the authenticated empathy is converted into consumer-brand intimacy. Two between-subjects experiments preceded by a feasibility pilot tested the account on Mainland Chinese consumers recruited via the Credamo online panel. Study 1 used a single-factor design contrasting high versus low AI empathy. Study 2 used a two (AI empathy) by two (mechanistic interpretability) full factorial. Study 1 showed a pattern consistent with high (versus low) AI empathy lowering brand intimacy through reduced perceived authenticity. Study 2 replicated the AI-empathy backfire when interpretability was absent, reversed the sign of the AI-empathy slope on the perceived-authenticity mediator when interpretability was present, and neutralized the negative conditional indirect effect on brand intimacy through perceived authenticity. The findings introduce mechanistic interpretability to consumer-marketing scholarship as a manipulable signaling channel, document a structural reversal in the mediator-stage slope coupled with neutralization of the indirect effect on the relational outcome, and prescribe pairing empathic AI phrasing with mechanistic-transparency design rather than deploying empathy without an accompanying transparency cue.
While Augmented Reality (AR) places a product visually and spatially inside the consumer’s own environment, it cannot deliver touch. The more faithfully AR renders an object, the more conspicuous its missing tactile channel becomes. We term this the reality–virtuality paradox, and it sits outside the prevailing account in interactive marketing, which has largely equated richer immersion with more favorable consumer response. In this study, we develop and test a chain mediation model explaining how AR, relative to 2D, 3D, or VR interfaces, elicits compensatory behaviors sequentially through perceived haptic gap and haptic craving. Study 1 (N = 80, AR vs. 2D), together with a same-device replication (Study 1b, N = 60), confirms the main effect of AR on compensatory behaviors. Study 2 (N = 228, AR vs. 3D) documents the chain mediation and the moderating effect of need for touch (NFT). Study 3 (N = 160, AR vs. VR × low vs. high haptic accessibility) establishes the moderating effect of haptic accessibility and extends the effect to a cross-context tactile-relevant choice. AR elicits stronger compensatory behaviors than 2D, 3D, and VR; the effect is sequentially mediated by perceived haptic gap and haptic craving; and it is stronger for high-NFT consumers and under low-haptic-accessibility conditions. We identify a perceptual cost that rises with visual fidelity, extend compensatory consumption from resource scarcity to sensory scarcity, and specify the individual and situational conditions under which the paradox binds most tightly.
Virtual influencers in diverse appearances emerged and gained popularity on virtual platforms. However, how the appearances of virtual influencers affect consumers’ attitudes and reactions remained largely unexplored. Through three experimental studies, this paper examines the psychological mechanism and boundary conditions for consumer reactions to virtual influencer transgressions. The results show that consumers are less forgiving and more negative in their reactions to transgressions conducted by human-like virtual influencers compared to anime-like ones, regardless of the type of transgression or the gender of the virtual influencer (Studies 1 and 2). Additionally, the driving mechanism of the virtual influencers has a moderating effect. When consumers are informed that the virtual influencer transgression is driven by a real person rather than AI, the impact of appearance on the reactions to transgressions is aggravated (Study 3). The result shows that appearance and driving mechanism both influence consumer perceptions of the virtual influencers’ agency, thereby determining the degree of reaction to transgressions.