Recent advancements have made two-dimensional (2D) clinical gait analysis systems more accessible and portable than traditional three-dimensional (3D) clinical systems. This study evaluates the reliability and validity of gait measurements using monocular and composite camera setups with VisionPose, comparing them to the Vicon 3D motion capture system as a reference. Key gait parameters—including hip and knee joint angles, and time and distance factors—were assessed under normal, maximum speed, and tandem gait conditions during level walking. The results show that the intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC(1,k)) for the 2D model exceeded 0.969 for the monocular camera and 0.963 for the composite camera for gait parameters. Time–distance gait parameters demonstrated excellent relative agreement across walking styles, while joint range of motion showed overall strong agreement. However, accuracy was lower for measurements during tandem walking. The Cronbach’s alpha coefficient for time–distance parameters ranged from 0.932 to 0.999 (monocular) and from 0.823 to 0.998 (composite). In contrast, for joint range of motion, the coefficient varied more widely, ranging from 0.826 to 0.985 (monocular) and from 0.314 to 0.974 (composite). The correlation coefficients for spatiotemporal gait parameters were greater than 0.933 (monocular) and 0.837 (composite). However, for joint angle parameters, the coefficients were lower during tandem walking. This study underscores the potential of 2D models in clinical applications and highlights areas for improvement to enhance their reliability and application scope.
Two-dimensional (2D) clinical gait analysis systems are more affordable and portable than contemporary three-dimensional (3D) clinical models. Using the Vicon 3D motion capture system as the standard, we evaluated the internal statistics of the Imasen and open-source OpenPose gait measurement systems, both designed for 2D input, to validate their output based on the similarity of results and the legitimacy of their inner statistical processes. We measured time factors, distance factors, and joint angles of the hip and knee joints in the sagittal plane while varying speeds and gaits during level walking in three in-person walking experiments under normal, maximum-speed, and tandem scenarios. The intraclass correlation coefficients of the 2D models were greater than 0.769 for all gait parameters compared with those of Vicon, except for some knee joint angles. The relative agreement was excellent for the time–distance gait parameter and moderate-to-excellent for each gait motion contraction range, except for hip joint angles. The time–distance gait parameter was high for Cronbach’s alpha coefficients of 0.899–0.993 but low for 0.298–0.971. Correlation coefficients were greater than 0.571 for time–distance gait parameters but lower for joint angle parameters, particularly hip joint angles. Our study elucidates areas in which to improve 2D models for their widespread clinical application.
Significant developments in sensing technology have had many impacts, enhancing monitoring and assessment accuracy across diverse fields. In the field of physical therapy, sensing, which plays a pivotal role in tele-physiotherapy, rapidly expanded amid the COVID-19 pandemic. Its primary objective is to monitor biological signals and patient movements at remote locations. To further enhance the effectiveness and the scope of tele-physiotherapy, it is essential to further develop sensing and data analysis technologies. However, there are usability and analysis issues that have limited its use. The development of these technologies will not only enhance the accuracy of deep learning by AI through the acquisition of big data, but also has the potential to elucidate movement characteristics associated with movement disorders or pathological conditions. Furthermore, improving sensing technologies can broaden applications extending beyond tele-physiotherapy to impact daily life. Looking forward, it holds promise for improving our understanding of disease prognosis and progression.