The rotavirus polymerase, VP1, mediates all stages of viral RNA synthesis within the confines of subviral particles and while associated with the core shell protein, VP2. Transcription [positive-strand (+) RNA synthesis] by VP1 occurs within double-layered particles (DLPs), while genome replication [double-stranded (ds) RNA synthesis] by VP1 occurs within assembly intermediates. VP2 is critical for VP1 enzymatic activity; yet the mechanism by which the core shell protein triggers polymerase function remains poorly understood. Structural analyses of transcriptionally-competent DLPs show that VP1 is located beneath the VP2 core shell and sits slightly off-center from each of the icosahedral fivefold axes. In this position, the polymerase is contacted by the core shell at 5 distinct surface-exposed sites, comprising VP1 residues 264-267, 547-550, 614-620, 968-980, and 1022-1025. Here, we sought to test the functional significance of these VP2 contact sites on VP1 in regard to polymerase activity. We engineered 19 recombinant (r) VP1 proteins that contained single- or multi-point alanine mutations within each individual contact site and assayed them for the capacity to synthesize dsRNA in vitro in the presence of rVP2. Three rVP1 mutants (E265A/L267A, R614A, and D971A/S978A/I980A) exhibited diminished in vitro dsRNA synthesis. Despite their loss-of-function phenotypes, the mutants did not show major structural changes in silico, and they maintained their overall capacity to bind rVP2 in vitro via their non-mutated contact sites. These results move towards a mechanistic understanding of rotavirus replication and identify precise VP2-binding sites on the polymerase surface that are critical for its enzymatic activation. IMPORTANCE Rotaviruses are important pathogens that cause severe gastroenteritis in the young of many animals. The viral polymerase, VP1, mediates all stages of viral RNA synthesis, and it requires the core shell protein, VP2, for its enzymatic activity. Yet, there are several gaps in knowledge about how VP2 engages and activates VP1. Here, we probed the functional significance of 5 distinct VP2 contact sites on VP1 that were revealed through previous structural studies. Specifically, we engineered alanine amino acid substitutions within each of the 5 VP1 regions, and assayed the mutant polymerases for the capacity to synthesize RNA in the presence of VP2 in a test tube. Our results identified residues within 3 of the VP2 contact sites that are critical for robust polymerase activity. These results are important because they enhance an understanding of a key step of the rotavirus replication cycle.