Earl Woodruff

Dr. Earl Woodruff

orcid

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

5Years (2022-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
18 June 2024 in AI
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
EWEarl Woodruff
Earl Woodruff
Subjective understanding is a complex process that involves the interplay of feelings and cognition. This paper explores how computers can monitor a user’s sympathetic and parasympathetic nervous system activity in real-time to detect the nature of the understanding the user is experiencing as they engage with study materials. By leveraging advancements in facial expression analysis, transdermal optical imaging, and voice analysis, I demonstrate how one can identify the physiological feelings that indicate a user’s mental state and level of understanding. The mental state model, which views understandings as composed of assembled beliefs, values, emotions, and feelings, provides a framework for understanding the multifaceted nature of the emotion–cognition relationship. As learners progress through the phases of nascent understanding, misunderstanding, confusion, emergent understanding, and deep understanding, they experience a range of cognitive processes, emotions, and physiological responses that can be detected and analyzed by AI-driven assessments. Based on the above approach, I further propose the development of Abel Tutor. This AI-driven system uses real-time monitoring of physiological feelings to provide individualized, adaptive tutoring support designed to guide learners toward deep understanding. By identifying the feelings associated with each phase of understanding, Abel Tutor can offer targeted interventions, such as clarifying explanations, guiding questions, or additional resources, to help students navigate the challenges they encounter and promote engagement. The ability to detect and respond to a student’s emotional state in real-time can revolutionize the learning experience, creating emotionally resonant learning environments that adapt to individual needs and optimize educational outcomes. As we continue to explore the potential of AI-driven assessments of subjective understanding, it is crucial to ensure that these technologies are grounded in sound pedagogical principles and ethical considerations, ultimately empowering learners and facilitating the attainment of deep understanding and lifelong learning for advantaged and disadvantaged students.

9 March 2026 in AI
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
EWEarl Woodruff
Earl Woodruff
JHJim Hewitt
Jim Hewitt
Introduction: Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly employed as cognitive aids in research and professional inquiry, yet their fluent outputs are frequently regarded as authoritative knowledge. We contend that this practice signifies a fundamental epistemic misalignment. Methods/Approach: Building on Peirce’s theory of inquiry, Sellars’ concept of the space of reasons, Stanovich’s tripartite model of cognition, and knowledge-building theory, we develop a conceptual framework for analyzing epistemic agency in human–LLM collaboration. Results/Argument: We demonstrate that LLM outputs fail to satisfy the conditions for knowledge because they lack reflective regulation, resistance to revision, and normative commitment. While LLMs display strong autonomous and algorithmic abilities (e.g., pattern recognition and hypothesis development), reflective control remains a distinctly human function. This asymmetry supports a principled division of epistemic labour and motivates the concept of the Knowledge-Building Partner (KBP): an AI system designed to support inquiry without claiming epistemic authority. Discussion/Implications: We identify prompt-, system-, and model-level design requirements and introduce a triangulated framework for operationalizing epistemic agency through explainable AI, discourse analysis, and rational-thinking measures. These contributions collectively reposition LLM limitations as epistemic design challenges rather than technical issues.

17 January 2025 in AI
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
MLMilan Lazic
Milan Lazic
EWEarl Woodruff
Earl Woodruff
JJJenny Jun
Jenny Jun
The relationship between the cognitive and affective dimensions of understanding has remained unexplored due to the lack of reliable methods for measuring emotions and feelings during learning. Focusing on five phases of understanding—nascent understanding, misunderstanding, confusion, emergent understanding, and deep understanding—this study introduces an AI-driven solution to measure subjective understanding by analyzing physiological activity manifested in facial expressions. To investigate these phases, 103 participants remotely worked on 15 riddles while their facial expressions were video recorded. Action units (AUs) for each phase instance were measured using AFFDEX software. AU patterns associated with each phase were then identified through the application of six supervised machine learning algorithms. Distinct AU patterns were found for all five phases, with gradient boosting machine and random forest models achieving the highest predictive accuracy. These findings suggest that physiological activity can be leveraged to reliably measure understanding. Further, they advance a novel approach for measuring and fostering understanding in educational settings, as well as developing adaptive learning technologies and personalized educational interventions. Future studies should explore how physiological signatures of understanding phases both reflect and influence their associated cognitive processes, as well as the generalizability of this study’s findings across diverse populations and learning contexts (A suite of AI tools was employed in the development of this paper: (1) ChatGPT4o (for writing clarity and reference checking), (2) Grammarly (for grammar and editorial corrections), and (3) ResearchRabbit (reference management)).

19 August 2025 in AI
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
EWEarl Woodruff
Earl Woodruff
As large language model (LLM) tutors evolve from scripted helpers into adaptive educational partners, their capacity for self-regulation, ethical decision-making, and internal monitoring will become increasingly critical. This paper introduces the Needs-Driven Consciousness Framework (NDCF) as a novel, integrative architecture that combines Dennett’s multiple drafts model, Damasio’s somatic marker hypothesis, and Tulving’s tripartite memory system into a unified motivational design for synthetic consciousness. The NDCF defines three core regulators, specifically Survive (system stability and safety), Thrive (autonomy, competence, relatedness), and Excel (creativity, ethical reasoning, long-term purpose). In addition, there is a proposed supervisory Protect layer that detects value drift and overrides unsafe behaviours. The core regulators compute internal need satisfaction states and urgency gradients, feeding into a softmax-based control system for context-sensitive action selection. The framework proposes measurable internal signals (e.g., utility gradients, conflict intensity Ω), behavioural signatures (e.g., metacognitive prompts, pedagogical shifts), and three falsifiable predictions for educational AI testbeds. By embedding these layered needs directly into AI governance, the NDCF offers (i) a psychologically and biologically grounded model of emergent machine consciousness, (ii) a practical approach to building empathetic, self-regulating AI tutors, and (iii) a testable platform for comparing competing consciousness theories through implementation. Ultimately, the NDCF provides a path toward the development of AI tutors that are capable of transparent reasoning, dynamic adaptation, and meaningful human-like relationships, while maintaining safety, ethical coherence, and long-term alignment with human well-being.


17 April 2026 in Behavioral Sciences
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
ABAna Zdravkovic Barber
Ana Zdravkovic Barber
SESteve Engels
Steve Engels
EWEarl Woodruff
Earl Woodruff
Digital game-based learning environments (DGBLEs) are increasingly integrated into classrooms as learning tools, yet limited research exists regarding the impact of students’ discrete emotions on digital gameplay performance. This study examined the role of emotions and arousal in predicting performance outcomes during digital gameplay. Thirty-two grade 5 students (Mage = 10.99, 62.5% male) played four digital games (two math; two identically designed non-math). During gameplay, real-time heart rate and affective data were collected and analyzed using an interpretable machine learning approach (XGBoost). Results suggest that students performed better on non-math games, as compared to math games. Real-time anger was associated with lower performance, particularly in games, whereas other emotions and physiological measures were not significant predictors. This pilot investigation suggests that discrete emotions, particularly anger, may play a more important role in performance during math gameplay than in comparable non-math activities. The results highlight the importance of supporting emotional regulation during digital math learning, as unmanaged anger may impact performance. This study contributes to the growing literature on affective dynamics in digital game-based learning.