Researchers broadly recognize happiness and meaning in life as key indicators of hedonic and eudaimonic well-being respectively. Although happiness and meaning in life are life pursuits among many people, they might differ in their associations with mental health. Taking both a preventative and promotive approach (Wong, 2013), this study examined the relations of happiness and meaning in life with mental health using a university student sample (N = 284). Happiness and meaning in life were both uniquely, negatively related to perceived stress as well as anxiety and depressive symptoms, although happiness was more strongly linked to these mental health outcomes. Additionally, happiness and meaning in life were both indirectly related to anxiety and depressive symptoms through their positive association with perceived stress. Based on our findings and previous literature, we propose the following distinction between happiness and meaning in life: the former leads to self-satisfying outcomes and the latter yields self-transcending outcomes. We propose that the overlap between the two constructs result in salutary outcomes, reflecting the emphasis of Positive Psychology 2.0 on the complexity of meaning in life and the intricate link between positive and negative psychological processes. Implications for counseling are discussed.
16 May 2020 in International Journal for the Advancement of Counselling
Grounded in a tripartite existential meaninglessness model, the authors developed the 18-item Existential Meaninglessness Scale (EMS) to assess one’s concern and anxiety of existential meaninglessness. Across three samples, the EMS’s factor structure and evidence of convergent, criterion-related, and incremental validity, internal consistency, and test–retest reliability were examined. Exploratory factor analyses demonstrated three dimensions of the EMS: incomprehension, purposelessness, and insignificance. Confirmatory factor analyses revealed that a bifactor model was a better fit to the data than other models. The bifactor model provided evidence for a general factor and measurement invariance. Ancillary bifactor indices indicated EMS’s unidimensionality. Findings of bivariate correlations and hierarchical regression analyses provided evidence for different aspects of construct validity and internal consistency. Both the Concern and Anxiety measures of the EMS positively predicted depressive symptoms and suicide ideation above and beyond the effects of general existential meaninglessness, general feelings of anxiety, and presence of meaning in life. Based on the findings, the authors discuss future research directions on existential meaninglessness using the EMS.
A life scheme can be understood as the cognitive representation of individuals’ life events and their goal attainment in the past and future. We conceptualize beliefs in free will and determinism as two life schemes. The purpose of this study was to examine the relationship between beliefs in free will and determinism, search for meaning, and depressive symptoms. While belief in free will uniquely and negatively predicted depressive symptoms, deterministic belief was uniquely and positively associated with depressive symptoms. Moreover, a multiple mediation model revealed that beliefs in free will and determinism were indirectly associated with increased depressive symptoms via their positive relations with search for meaning. These findings are discussed in view of the relationship between inconsistent life schemes and the need to search for meaning, as well as the mediating role of the search for meaning.
11 November 2019 in The Journal of Positive Psychology
Although the theory of hope proposed by Charles R. Snyder is the dominant perspective in hope psychology, scholars have questioned whether it adequately represent laypeople’s understanding of hope. Accordingly, this mixed-methods study (N =298) explored U.S. college students’ lay beliefs about hope. Participants provided written responses to eight open-ended prompts on their beliefs about hope. A directed content analysis of participants’ qualitative responses identified interpersonal relationships, optimism, work, spirituality, and positive emotions as the five most prevalent beliefs about hope, whereas beliefs associated with Snyder’s theory of hope (agency and pathways) were rarely mentioned. The authors also investigated whether these five beliefs and two other beliefs – materialistic perspective on hope and belief in the unconditional nature of hope – predicted well-being outcomes. Multiple regression analyses indicated that belief in the unconditional nature of hope was the most robust positive predictor of well-being outcomes, followed by belief about the spiritual nature of hope.
19 October 2021 in The Journal of Positive Psychology
How do laypeople understand meaning in life (MIL) and how are lay beliefs about MIL related to well-being in specific groups of laypeople? To address these questions, we recruited 417 adults and identified their most prevalent lay beliefs about MIL: (1) interpersonal relationships, (2) purpose, (3) self-transcendence, (4) personal growth, (5) spirituality, and (6) meaning making. Two other MIL lay beliefs – comprehension and existential mattering – were rarely mentioned. Using latent profile analysis with the identified six lay beliefs, we uncovered a three-cluster solution. The three clusters were characterized by beliefs about self-transcendent, spiritual-personal growth, and the interpersonal nature of MIL, respectively. Overall, findings on cluster membership, MIL lay beliefs, and well-being suggest that thinking about MIL in other-oriented terms might exert positive effects on well-being, whereas a more self-focused belief could have detrimental effects. These findings underscore the heterogeneity of laypeople’s beliefs about MIL and their implications for well-being.