Currently, there is no definitive conclusion in the literature regarding the relation between quality management systems and organisational performance. Beyond that, a few studies analyse if the maturity level of quality management systems and of processes affect organisational performance. Given these gaps, this paper shows a systematic literature review about quality management and organisational performance in the period between 2000 and 2017. For this, the search terms ISO 9001 and performance were consulted on the databases Emerald Insight®, Science Direct® and Web of Science®. The results showed that the majority of the studies found a positive relation between ISO 9001 implementation and one or more dimensions of organisational performance. Among those performance dimensions, operational and market performances have shown a greater relation with ISO 9001 implementation. The present review also indicates the lack of a consolidated model for evaluation of the management system’s maturity level and the non-consideration of aspects related to process management in studies about ISO 9001 and organisational performance. Those gaps may be addressed in future researches on quality management systems and organisational performance as indicated in this study.
Resumo O objetivo geral deste estudo foi avaliar a eficiência técnica dos hospitais de ensino do Brasil por meio da análise envoltória de dados. Para tanto, foi realizada uma pesquisa exploratória de natureza quantitativa utilizando dados secundários do Ministério da Saúde. Foi utilizado o método da análise envoltória de dados (DEA - Data Envelopment Analysis), orientada a output. A população deste estudo constituiu em 29 hospitais de ensino de grande porte nas regiões Centro-Oeste, Sul, Sudeste e Norte do Brasil. Identificou-se que 12 hospitais ficaram localizados na fronteira de eficiência, ou seja, foram relacionados como eficientes na maximização dos outputs (produtos), e 17 ficaram abaixo. Foi estabelecido o valor absoluto para a eficiência daqueles que não atingiram a fronteira por meio de benchmarks com pesos para o espelhamento. Identificou-se, quanto à natureza jurídica, que a personalidade “entidades empresariais” foi mais eficiente, seguida das “entidades sem fins lucrativos” e, por último, da “administração pública”. Os resultados desta pesquisa sugerem que a DEA tem potencial para avaliação de eficiência técnica no âmbito hospitalar quando avaliada a capacidade de produção do estabelecimento.
This paper presents a systematic literature review of ISO 9001 and process management from 1990 to 2017. In order to investigate the studies published in English on these topics, the keywords 'ISO 9001' and 'process management' were searched in science direct database. These terms should be mentioned in papers' title, abstract or keywords as an inclusion criterion. Studies which were redundant due to search criterion or which were published in a language other than English were excluded. Three rounds of analysis were conducted, including quantitative analysis of search results, bibliometric analyses, qualitative analysis, and in-depth reading of the selected studies. By carrying out the review, it was possible to identify an opportunity to deepen the studies that correlate ISO 9001 and process management, which is justified by the small number of papers published with this specific approach. In addition, the papers which were analysed in this systematic review did not address some important aspects in the relationship between ISO 9001 and process management, such as evidence of improved operational efficiency of processes, and cultural changes noticed in organisations after the implementation of ISO 9001.