Vaccine immunogenicity and clinical efficacy are often assessed by the measure of serum-neutralizing antibodies. The present gold standard for detecting neutralizing antibodies against many viruses, including dengue, is the plaque/focus reduction neutralization test (P/FRNT). The FRNT is a cell-based assay that inherits high variability, resulting in poor precision and has lengthy turnaround times. The virus reduction neutralization test (VRNT) is a high-throughput alternative to the standard low-throughput and laborious FRNT. The VRNT is similar to FRNT using unaltered wild-type virus and immunostaining, yet uses imaging cytometry to count virus-infected cells 1 day post-infection, reducing assay time and increasing overall throughput 15-fold. In addition, the VRNT has lowered variability relative to FRNT, which may be explained in part by the observation that foci overlap alters foci count and titer over time, in the FRNT. The ability to count one infected cell, rather than waiting for overlapping foci to form, ensures accuracy and contributes to the precision (7–25% coefficient of variation) and sensitivity of the VRNT. Results from 81 clinical samples tested in the VRNT and FRNT show a clear positive relationship. During sample testing, a 96-well plate edge effect was noted and the elimination of this edge effect was achieved by a simple plate seeding technique. The VRNT is an improvement to the current neutralization assays for its shortened assay time, increased precision and throughput, and an alternative to the P/FRNT.
The rapid development of potency assays is critical in the development of life-saving vaccines. The traditional plaque assay or fifty percent tissue culture infectious dose (TCID50) assay used to measure the potency of live virus vaccines is time consuming, labor intensive, low throughput and with high variability. Described here is the development and qualification of a cell-based reporter potency assay for two vaccines for respiratory viral infection, one based on the recombinant vesicular stomatitis virus (rVSV) backbone, termed Vaccine 1 in this paper, and the other based on the measles virus vector, termed Vaccine 2. The reporter potency assay used a Vero E6 cell line engineered to constitutively express NanuLuc® luciferase, termed the VeroE6-NLuc or JM-1 cell line. Infection of JM-1 cells by a live virus, such as rVSV or measles virus, causes a cytopathic effect (CPE) and release of NanuLuc® from the cytoplasm into the supernatant, the amount of which reflects the intensity of the viral infection. The relative potency was calculated by comparison to a reference standard using parallel line analysis (PLA) in a log–log linear model. The reporter assay demonstrated good linearity, accuracy, and precision, and is therefore suitable for a vaccine potency assay. Further evaluation of the Vaccine 1 reporter assay demonstrated the robustness to a range of deliberate variation of the selected assay parameters and correlation with the plaque assay. In conclusion, we have demonstrated that the reporter assay using the JM-1 cell line could be used as a potency assay to support the manufacturing and release of multiple live virus vaccines.